Karnataka High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Forest Daily Wagers Who Took Welfare Act Benefits Can Still Seek Regularisation, Karnataka HC Rules

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITSv.N B BALIHALLI S/O BASAPPA BALIHALLI,

Forest Daily Wagers Who Took Welfare Act Benefits Can Still Seek Regularisation, Karnataka HC Rules. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS vs N B BALIHALLI S/O BASAPPA BALIHALLI,. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether an employee who, after 20–25 years of daily-wage service, accepted the benefits of the Karnataka Daily Wage Employees Welfare Act, 2012 and the Rules thereunder is precluded from seeking regularization of his services.

The court held

The Court answered Issue 1 in the negative: acceptance of Welfare Act benefits does not preclude an employee from seeking regularization

It also directed

On Issue 2, amounts received under the Welfare Act are not refundable from employees but must be set off against the amounts payable under the Tribunal's order

The writ petitions were dismissed, the KSAT orders were affirmed, and the time for compliance granted by the Tribunal was extended by four weeks from the date of the order. The Court also admonished the State against repeating the same submission in future cases

01Facts

The respondents were appointed on daily wage basis as forest watchers, drivers, or wireless operators in the Forest Department between 1985 and 1988

¶ 4

Their regularization claims were not considered despite a State order directing regularization of daily wagers appointed before 01.07.1984 with ten years' service. The Tribunal, in Application Nos. 9551–9560/2001, directed consideration in 2002, but this was not implemented

¶ 4

Meanwhile, the State enacted the Karnataka Daily Wage Employees Welfare Act, 2012 ("Welfare Act") and framed Rules. The respondents were brought under the Welfare Act and accepted its benefits

¶ 4

The respondents then approached the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal (KSAT), Belagavi, which, by orders dated 24.07.2023 and 25.07.2023 in Application Nos. 11457–11465/2022 and 11466–11467/2022, allowed their claims. The KSAT directed regularization from completion of ten years' service, on parity with Narasimharaju & Ors., and ordered consequential benefits within four months

¶ 4 · Tribunal order · ¶ 14–21

The State filed these writ petitions under Articles 226–227 on a single ground: having accepted Welfare Act benefits, the respondents cannot seek regularization

¶ 5

02Issues

i.1. Whether an employee who, after 20–25 years of daily-wage service, accepted the benefits of the Karnataka Daily Wage Employees Welfare Act, 2012 and the Rules thereunder is precluded from seeking regularization of his services.

¶ 9

ii.2. Whether amounts received under the Welfare Act must be refunded by the employees or set off against their entitlement under the Tribunal's order.

¶ 17–18

03Law Applied

The Court relied on the Welfare Act, which protects pay and allowances and provides certain benefits, but does not contemplate regularization

¶ 4 · Tribunal order · ¶ 16 · Supreme Court decision in Civil Appeal No. 5292 of 2019, quoted at para. 14

It applied the Supreme Court's 2019 ruling that the Welfare Act does not affect earlier judgments granting regularization, and that the Act's benefits do not displace the right to regularization

¶ 14

It relied on Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) for the regularization framework, as clarified by the Division Benches: employees with over ten years' service in sanctioned posts before the cut-off date are entitled to regularization, and procedural delay cannot defeat it

¶ 10–13

It also applied the 01.07.1984 cut-off in Dharwad District P.W.D. Literate Daily Wage Employees Association v. State of Karnataka and the Government Order dated 06.08.1990

¶ 13 (quoting WP 104676/2023 at paras. 7–8, 12)

The Court also considered the Supreme Court's observations in Daram Singh, Shripal, and Jaggo on exploitative ad hocism

¶ 13 (quoting WP 104676/2023 at paras. 8–9)

The Court applied the principle that the State must not exploit daily wagers, and that equal treatment of similarly situated employees is required under Article 14

¶ 11, 13

04Reasoning

The Court noted that the State's sole contention had been rejected by the Supreme Court's 2019 decision and several Division Benches, including orders in WA No. 1882/2024 (para. 7 of that order), WP No. 104676/2023, and WA No. 100349/2024

¶ 10–14

It held that the respondents, who worked for decades, were not barred from seeking regularization merely because they took the Welfare Act's benefits. Using the "hungry man" analogy, it reasoned that an employee denied regularization would naturally accept an available statutory benefit, and that the benefit does not extinguish the larger right to regularization

¶ 15

The Court found the State's repeated submissions, despite the 2019 Supreme Court ruling, reflected a lack of clarity. It admonished the State but refrained from imposing exemplary costs to avoid burdening the employees

¶ 16

On refunds, the Court held that recovery from employees is impermissible, since the State must itself pay the amounts the Tribunal's order requires. The Welfare Act amounts received by employees must instead be set off against their dues under the Tribunal order

¶ 17–18

05Holding

The Court answered Issue 1 in the negative: acceptance of Welfare Act benefits does not preclude an employee from seeking regularization

¶ 15–16

On Issue 2, amounts received under the Welfare Act are not refundable from employees but must be set off against the amounts payable under the Tribunal's order

¶ 17–18

The writ petitions were dismissed, the KSAT orders were affirmed, and the time for compliance granted by the Tribunal was extended by four weeks from the date of the order. The Court also admonished the State against repeating the same submission in future cases

¶ 19 · ¶ 16
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITSvsN B BALIHALLI S/O BASAPPA BALIHALLI,

Karnataka High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment