Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEnvironmental Law

Forest Department Can't Evict Karnataka Coffee and Resort Owners on a 1920 Notification Withdrawn in 1924

MRS SABRINA FLORA BRITTO HOUGAARDv.STATE OF KARNATAKA

Forest Department Can't Evict Karnataka Coffee and Resort Owners on a 1920 Notification Withdrawn in 1924. MRS SABRINA FLORA BRITTO HOUGAARD vs STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the notification dated 05.02.1920 (R.8806-Ft.43-15-6) continues to remain operative, and whether the Government Order dated 11.01.1924 withdrew or cancelled it.

The court held

The notification dated 05.02.1920 (R.8806-Ft.43-15-6) was dropped by the Government Order dated 11.01.1924 (IC 4236.8), has been abandoned and lapsed, and has no operative effect to found proceedings under the 1963 Act against the petitioners.

It also directed

No final notification under Section 17 of the Regulation or Section 4(1) notification under the 1963 Act exists for the Block.

The writ petitions are partly allowed. In WP 29656/2024, notices dated 04.06.2024, 28.08.2024, 10.09.2024, 20.09.2024 and 18.10.2024 are quashed; the Respondents shall not disturb possession on the strength of the 1920 notification; the order dated 24.10.2025 is neither set aside nor upheld.

In WP 16251/2023, the order dated 26.07.2022 and notice dated 18.07.2023 are quashed; the proclamation dated 09.11.2023 is quashed as to the petitioners; possession is protected except in accordance with law; seized articles in custody are to be returned within four weeks.

In WP 19980/2023, the order dated 26.07.2022, notice dated 18.07.2023 and proclamation dated 09.11.2023 are quashed; no right to occupation is declared.

In WP 29690/2025, the proclamation dated 19.07.2023 is quashed as to the petitioners' lands; notices dated 11.08.2025, 26.08.2025 and 30.06.2025 are quashed; the Respondents shall not proceed with enquiry or penal action on the 1920 notification.

In WP 33767/2025, proclamations and notices, and consequential inquiry and report, are quashed as against the petitioners; the State's statement not to proceed against admitted claims of Petitioners 13, 14, 15, 25, 26 and 50 is recorded; the prayer to delete the Forest Department's name from revenue records is refused, with liberty to apply to revenue authorities.

In WP 700/2026, notice dated 30.06.2025 is quashed; no enquiry or penal action on the 1920 notification.

Interim orders merge and cease to operate; the State remains free to constitute reserved forest afresh under Sections 3 and 4(1) of the 1963 Act or act under Section 64A after compliance with its requirements.

The Court directed a State-wide scientific identification of forests and forest-like areas within nine months, with the Principal Secretary, Forest, Environment and Ecology Department to report on progress, relisted on 12.03.2027.

No order as to costs.

01Facts

The petitioners are landowners and resort operators in the Moorkangudda block, Sakleshpura Taluk, Hassan District, claiming lands by auction, sale deeds, partition, grants and conversion orders.

pp. 36–p.39 · ¶ 7–13

The Forest Department relies on Notification No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6 dated 05.02.1920 under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, covering about 7,938 acres 38 guntas.

p. 135 · ¶ 65.1–65.2

The petitioners contend that the Government Order dated 11.01.1924 cancelled the proposal and that the notification ceased to operate.

p. 40 · ¶ 18, 39–40

The State denies cancellation, asserting the 1924 order related only to a separate acquisition notification (No. R.8808-Ft.43-15-7) covering 68 acres 33 guntas.

p. 147 · ¶ 65.20–65.22

A Forest Mobile Squad order dated 26.07.2022 and Range Forest Officer notices (18.07.2023) led to alleged eviction and seizure at the WP 16251 resort.

pp. 39–41 · ¶ 15, 21

The Forest Settlement Officer was appointed by GO dated 19.12.2022, issued a proclamation on 19.07.2023 and later notices, and passed an order dated 24.10.2025 in WP 29656.

pp. 173–176 · ¶ 65.59–65.63

Coordination meetings before the Regional Commissioner (10.06.2022, 08.09.2022) recorded directions to withdraw cases.

pp. 453–457 · ¶ 79.6–79.10

The State admitted no final notification under Section 17 has been issued.

p. 275 · ¶ 70.5

02Issues

i.1. Whether the notification dated 05.02.1920 (R.8806-Ft.43-15-6) continues to remain operative, and whether the Government Order dated 11.01.1924 withdrew or cancelled it.

p. 248 · ¶ 67(i), 69.36

ii.2. Whether the absence of a final notification under Section 17 of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900 precludes the State from asserting forest status or acting under the forest legislation.

p. 248 · ¶ 67(ii), 70.38–70.39

iii.3. Whether the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 repeal (Section 117) affects the 1920 notification and proceedings.

p. 248 · ¶ 67(iii), 71.20–71.21

iv.4. Whether the prolonged delay renders the proceedings unsustainable.

pp. 248–249 · ¶ 67(iv), 72.40–72.42

v.5. Whether the grants, revenue entries, registered instruments and permissions confer enforceable rights.

p. 249 · ¶ 67(v), 73.62–73.65

vi.6. Whether the petitioners' properties fall within the notified boundaries.

p. 249 · ¶ 67(vi), 74.23

vii.7. Whether the writ petitions are maintainable despite alternative statutory remedies.

p. 249 · ¶ 67(vii), 75.30

viii.8. Whether Section 64A of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 applies, and whether the proceedings were by competent officers after due hearing.

p. 249 · ¶ 67(viii), 76.44–76.47

9.9. Whether the Forest Settlement Officer's proceedings complied with the 1963 Act.

p. 250 · ¶ 67(ix), 77.28–77.29

10.10. Whether the Section 16 appellate remedy bars relief against Section 14 orders.

p. 250 · ¶ 67(x), 78.25–78.27

11.11. Whether the Regional Commissioner's proceedings bind the State or Forest Department.

p. 250 · ¶ 67(xi), 79.22

12.12. Whether the petitioners have established enforceable rights warranting relief.

p. 250 · ¶ 67(xii), 80.56–80.57

03Law Applied

Sections 4 and 17 of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, under which a Section 4 notification is a proposal and only a Section 17 notification confers State Forest status.

p. 256 · ¶ 69.7–69.8, 70.9–70.10

Section 6 of the Regulation, whose bar on acquisition of rights operates only after the Section 5 proclamation.

p. 281 · ¶ 70.15–70.16

Sections 2(14), 4, 5, 6, 7, 11–17 and 23 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, holding that a Section 4(1) notification is the statutory foundation for Chapter II proceedings.

p. 279 · ¶ 70.12 · p. 427 · ¶ 77.8–77.9

Section 117 (repeal and savings) of the 1963 Act, under which savings continue only actions still in force on commencement.

p. 302 · ¶ 71.11–71.12

The principle that statutory power must be exercised within a reasonable time (Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy v. D. Narsing Rao; Union of India v. Citi Bank; V. Sampangi Ramaiah, para. 19).

pp. 110–114, 313–320 · ¶ 63.61–63.64, 72.12–72.14

M/s. Godrej Sara Lee Ltd. and Radha Krishan Industries, recognising exceptions for want of jurisdiction and natural justice in writ maintainability.

pp. 123–127 · ¶ 63.71–63.74, 75.7–75.8

Section 64A(1) of the 1963 Act, requiring the land to fall within a specified category and a reasonable opportunity of hearing.

pp. 69–70 · ¶ 76.12–76.13

Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and the public trust doctrine, referred to without deciding their application to individual parcels.

pp. 290–291 · ¶ 70.31–70.33 · p. 159 · ¶ 65.40

Provisions in the judgment · 29 · Linked ones open on LawLens

KARNATAKA FOREST ACT, 1963 26 provisionsSection 2Section 3Section 4Section 5Section 6Section 7Section 8Section 9Section 10Section 11Section 12Section 13Section 14Section 15Section 16Section 17Section 18Section 19Section 20Section 23Section 24Section 64Section 73Section 104Section 109Section 117

Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980 Section 2

Indian Forest Act, 1927 Section 5

Customs Act,1962 Section 27

04Reasoning

The Court read the Government records and held that the Government Order of 11.01.1924 (Entry 271, IC 4236.8) directed that "the proposal to constitute the area into a State Forest be dropped," which concerned the entire Block, not merely the 68 acres 33 guntas acquisition, which was a separate, consequential withdrawal (Entry 272).

pp. 258–269 · ¶ 69.12–69.24

Because the Regulation prescribes no form for abandoning a proposal, the decision was effective without a further notification.

p. 268 · ¶ 69.26–69.28

Consequently, the 1920 notification was not a live proposal.

p. 271 · ¶ 69.36

On Section 117, the Court held the repeal preserved only validly accrued consequences and continued instruments in force at commencement; it could not revive a proposal withdrawn in 1924.

pp. 302–306 · ¶ 71.11–71.12

The State's own admission that no Section 17 notification exists, combined with the absence of any proclamation or inquiry for nearly a century, led the Court to hold that the State could not rely on the proposal as a continuing basis, and in the alternative that the delay was unreasonable and established abandonment.

pp. 318–327 · ¶ 72.11–72.25

The Court distinguished Arun Kumar Bhardwaj, B.R. Ganapathi Singh and Girish H.E. as concerning subsisting notifications.

pp. 284–287 · ¶ 70.18–70.23

On maintainability, the Court held that the challenge goes to jurisdiction, not merits, so the writ remedy was available, while orders on individual claims under Section 14 remain subject to Section 16 appeal.

pp. 381–392 · ¶ 75.9–75.30 · pp. 440–452 · ¶ 78.10–78.25

On Section 64A, the Court held the Respondents had not established parcel-wise that the lands fell within a statutory category; the 1920 notification could not supply that, and the RFO lacked rank to act; the order dated 26.07.2022 therefore could not stand.

pp. 410–414 · ¶ 76.15–76.33

The Court made no finding on title, boundaries or grants, which were left open.

pp. 364–376 · ¶ 74.21–74.23 · ¶ 73.59–73.65

05Holding

The notification dated 05.02.1920 (R.8806-Ft.43-15-6) was dropped by the Government Order dated 11.01.1924 (IC 4236.8), has been abandoned and lapsed, and has no operative effect to found proceedings under the 1963 Act against the petitioners.

p. 272 · ¶ 71.20–71.21 · pp. 506–507 · ¶ 81.29(ii)

No final notification under Section 17 of the Regulation or Section 4(1) notification under the 1963 Act exists for the Block.

p. 272 · ¶ 70.38

The writ petitions are partly allowed. In WP 29656/2024, notices dated 04.06.2024, 28.08.2024, 10.09.2024, 20.09.2024 and 18.10.2024 are quashed; the Respondents shall not disturb possession on the strength of the 1920 notification; the order dated 24.10.2025 is neither set aside nor upheld.

p. 474 · ¶ 80.25–80.26 · pp. 507–508 · ¶ 81.29(iii)

In WP 16251/2023, the order dated 26.07.2022 and notice dated 18.07.2023 are quashed; the proclamation dated 09.11.2023 is quashed as to the petitioners; possession is protected except in accordance with law; seized articles in custody are to be returned within four weeks.

pp. 476–479 · ¶ 80.30–80.35 · pp. 508–510 · ¶ 81.29(iv)

In WP 19980/2023, the order dated 26.07.2022, notice dated 18.07.2023 and proclamation dated 09.11.2023 are quashed; no right to occupation is declared.

p. 480 · ¶ 80.37 · p. 510 · ¶ 81.29(v)

In WP 29690/2025, the proclamation dated 19.07.2023 is quashed as to the petitioners' lands; notices dated 11.08.2025, 26.08.2025 and 30.06.2025 are quashed; the Respondents shall not proceed with enquiry or penal action on the 1920 notification.

p. 481 · ¶ 80.40–80.42 · pp. 510–511 · ¶ 81.29(vi)

In WP 33767/2025, proclamations and notices, and consequential inquiry and report, are quashed as against the petitioners; the State's statement not to proceed against admitted claims of Petitioners 13, 14, 15, 25, 26 and 50 is recorded; the prayer to delete the Forest Department's name from revenue records is refused, with liberty to apply to revenue authorities.

pp. 482–486 · ¶ 80.44–80.50 · pp. 511–512 · ¶ 81.29(vii)

In WP 700/2026, notice dated 30.06.2025 is quashed; no enquiry or penal action on the 1920 notification.

p. 486 · ¶ 80.51–80.52 · p. 512 · ¶ 81.29(viii)

Interim orders merge and cease to operate; the State remains free to constitute reserved forest afresh under Sections 3 and 4(1) of the 1963 Act or act under Section 64A after compliance with its requirements.

pp. 489–490 · ¶ 81.2 · p. 513 · ¶ 81.29(ix)(c)

The Court directed a State-wide scientific identification of forests and forest-like areas within nine months, with the Principal Secretary, Forest, Environment and Ecology Department to report on progress, relisted on 12.03.2027.

pp. 497–506 · ¶ 81.15–81.27 · p. 514 · ¶ 81.29(xiv)

No order as to costs.

p. 514 · ¶ 81.29(xii)
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

MRS SABRINA FLORA BRITTO HOUGAARDvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment