Karnataka High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Karnataka HC Upholds Triple-Murder Convictions, But Sets Aside Sessions Court's Natural-Life Jail Term

MAHADEVv.THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka HC Upholds Triple-Murder Convictions, But Sets Aside Sessions Court's Natural-Life Jail Term. MAHADEV vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the appellants proved that the judgment of conviction and order of sentence are perverse, arbitrary, and without appreciation of the evidence on record.

The court held

The Court dismissed the challenge to the conviction. It held that the appellants had not shown the judgment to be perverse, and it confirmed the convictions under ss. 354, 451, 504, 506, 323, 324 and 302 IPC read with s.34.

It also directed

The Court held that the Sessions Court's direction for life imprisonment till the end of natural life was impermissible, following Kiran and Durgappa.

The sentence order dated 24.09.2025 was modified. Each accused was sentenced to life imprisonment (without the natural-life direction) and to pay a fine of ₹5,00,000 for the s.302 IPC offence, with one year's simple imprisonment in default.

The appeal was allowed in part. The modification addresses the s.302 sentence only. The order does not expressly address the sentences for the other offences, which must be read as subsisting under the confirmed convictions.

01Facts

On 23.06.2017, Nagamma (PW1) complained that about 15–20 days earlier, Accused No.1 (A1) had caught her hand and tried to drag her into a sugarcane groove when she went to hold a water pipe at his land; she raised an alarm and he left.

pp. 3–4 · pp. 25–26

Following a village panchayat, the accused allegedly became hostile toward the family over an accusation about the removal of a transformer (TC) jump.

pp. 4–5 · p. 12

On the same day, A1 allegedly trespassed into the complainant's house, abused and threatened Sharanabasavaraj.

p. 5 · p. 20

At about 6:00 p.m., A1 (with a spade and koita/chopper) and Accused No.2 (A2) (with an axe) allegedly attacked Sangappa, Malakappa and Sharanabasavaraj in the frontyard, causing their deaths. Akkamahadevi (PW2) and Shankaramma (PW4), who intervened, were also allegedly injured or threatened.

pp. 5–8 · pp. 20–22

The FIR (Crime No.136/2017, Almel PS) was registered for offences under IPC ss. 109, 504, 324, 34, 451, 302 and 354.

pp. 8–9

The charge-sheet was filed for ss. 451, 323, 324, 302, 354, 504, 506 r/w s.34 IPC.

p. 9

The Sessions Court (SC No.92/2018) framed charges on 02.09.2022; the prosecution examined 25 witnesses and the accused were examined under s.313 CrPC.

pp. 10–11

Several witnesses (PW3, PW13, PW14) turned hostile.

p. 46 · pp. 32–33

By judgment dated 19.09.2025 and sentence order dated 24.09.2025, the Sessions Court convicted both accused and imposed life imprisonment "for the remainder of natural life" under s.302 IPC, plus fines and terms for the other offences.

pp. 11–15

The accused appealed under s.374(2) CrPC / s.415(2) BNSS.

p. 3 · pp. 15–16

02Issues

i.1. Whether the appellants proved that the judgment of conviction and order of sentence are perverse, arbitrary, and without appreciation of the evidence on record.

¶ 9 · p. 24

ii.2. Whether the Sessions Court could lawfully impose life imprisonment extending to the remainder of the convicts' natural lives.

¶ 18 · pp. 113–114 · ¶ 20 · pp. 114–115

03Law Applied

IPC ss. 354, 451, 504, 506, 323, 324 and 302, read with s.34, governed the offences charged.

pp. 11–12 · p. 21

The Court treated the evidence of interested or related witnesses (wives of the deceased) as admissible but requiring cautious scrutiny and corroboration, while noting that their relationship alone does not discredit them.

¶ 11–12 · pp. 107–108

Panchnama and seizure evidence, and medical evidence, were treated as corroborative where they link the witnesses' account to the physical evidence.

¶ 13–16 · pp. 109–113

On sentencing, the Court relied on Kiran v. State of Karnataka, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2863, which holds that a Sessions Court cannot direct life imprisonment to run for the rest of the convict's natural life. Such power is reserved to Constitutional Courts, and the remission and commutation powers under ss.432–435 CrPC are preserved.

¶ 19 · pp. 113–114

The Court also followed Durgappa S/o Sangappa Timmapur v. State of Karnataka, Crl.A No. 200001/2014 (decided 10.08.2020), on the same point.

¶ 20 · pp. 114–115

Provisions in the judgment · 18 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 9 provisionsSection 164Section 207Section 209Section 313Section 374Section 432Section 433Section 434Section 435

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 415

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 34Section 302Section 323Section 324Section 354Section 451Section 504Section 506

04Reasoning

The Court first examined the eye-witness testimony of PW1, PW2 and PW4. It held that their relationship with the deceased did not, by itself, render them unreliable, since the presence of outsiders in a private house was remote.

¶ 11 · pp. 107–108

Because one of the three witnesses was injured (PW2, corroborated by Ex.P40) and the other two were the complainant and an eyewitness present in the frontyard, the Court required corroboration as a matter of prudence.

¶ 11–12 · p. 108

It found corroboration in: (a) the location of the body on the road in front of the complainant's house, consistent with the spot mahazar and photographs; (b) the clothes seized under Ex.P24 and their identification by the eyewitnesses; (c) the common panch (PW7) to the spot, inquest and seizure mahazars; and (d) the post-mortem findings and the opinion of PW21 that the injuries could have been caused by the axe (MO9), koita (MO1) and spade (MO2).

¶ 15(a) · pp. 110–111 · ¶ 15(b) · p. 111 · ¶ 15(b)–(c) · pp. 111–112 · ¶ 15(c) · p. 112 · ¶ 16 · pp. 112–113

On this basis the Court held that the eyewitness accounts were corroborated by medical evidence.

¶ 17 · p. 113

On sentence, the Court held that the Sessions Court erred in imposing life imprisonment for the rest of the natural life, because the power to fix such a term is available only to Constitutional Courts.

¶ 18 · pp. 113–114 · ¶ 19 · p. 114 · ¶ 20 · pp. 114–115

It therefore confined the modification to the sentence, while confirming the conviction.

¶ 21(ii)–(iii) · pp. 115–116

The judgment does not expressly address several arguments advanced by the appellants: the alleged delay of over 14 hours in forwarding the FIR to the Magistrate; the conduct of the post-mortem by a private medical college; the non-seizure of the accused's clothes; the omission to cite independent witnesses; and the dropping of two named accused from the complaint. These issues are therefore not reflected in the Court's reasoning.

pp. 17–18 · p. 18 · p. 92 · pp. 18–19 · p. 98 · p. 17 · p. 19

05Holding

The Court dismissed the challenge to the conviction. It held that the appellants had not shown the judgment to be perverse, and it confirmed the convictions under ss. 354, 451, 504, 506, 323, 324 and 302 IPC read with s.34.

¶ 9 · p. 24 · ¶ 21(ii) · p. 115

The Court held that the Sessions Court's direction for life imprisonment till the end of natural life was impermissible, following Kiran and Durgappa.

¶ 18–20 · pp. 113–115

The sentence order dated 24.09.2025 was modified. Each accused was sentenced to life imprisonment (without the natural-life direction) and to pay a fine of ₹5,00,000 for the s.302 IPC offence, with one year's simple imprisonment in default.

¶ 21(iii)–(iv) · pp. 115–116

The appeal was allowed in part. The modification addresses the s.302 sentence only. The order does not expressly address the sentences for the other offences, which must be read as subsisting under the confirmed convictions.

¶ 21(i) · p. 115 · ¶ 21 · pp. 115–116
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

MAHADEVvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · September 15, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment