01Facts
The complainant (respondent) filed a private complaint under s. 200 Cr.P.C. alleging that the accused, a close friend of the complainant's family, obtained a hand loan of ₹30,00,000 for family necessity.
¶ 4The accused issued post-dated cheque No. 35543 dated 15.02.2015 drawn on Axis Bank, Doddaballapur. On presentation on 12.05.2015, it was returned on 13.05.2015 with the endorsement "funds insufficient".
¶ 4A legal notice dated 09.06.2015 was served on 13.06.2015; the accused did not reply or pay. The complaint was filed on 06.07.2015.
¶ 4The accused pleaded not guilty, cross-examined the complainant at length, and led defence evidence. He denied the transaction in toto.
¶ 6The defence contended that the complainant lacked financial capacity. The complainant had not stated the date of lending in the complaint, legal notice or examination-in-chief, and first gave November 2014 in cross-examination.
¶ 9, 32The lending was not reflected in the complainant's IT returns, and his bank statements did not show the funds.
¶ 10The defence produced a private complaint by one Smt. Manjula Devi against the complainant (Exs. D.1, D.2), and cases filed by Chennigappa and KSFC against the accused.
¶ 34–35The accused also claimed he had lent ₹16,00,000 to the complainant, which was unrepaid.
¶ 46The trial court convicted the accused under s. 138 NI Act and imposed a fine of ₹45,02,000, of which ₹45,00,000 was payable as compensation.
¶ 7 · ¶ 49The appellate court (IV Addl. Sessions Judge, Doddaballapur, Crl.A. No. 10001/2022, dated 29.11.2024) dismissed the appeal.
¶ 8The accused filed this revision.
02Issues
i.1. Whether the revision petitioner has established perversity, gross erroneousness, or non-consideration/misappreciation of material evidence in the concurrent findings of the trial and appellate courts, such that interference under revisional jurisdiction is warranted.
¶ 18ii.2. Whether the sentence of fine imposed by the trial court, confirmed by the appellate court, requires interference.
¶ 1803Law Applied
The court applied the revisional limits laid down in Kuntegowda v. Thurubaiah (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1485), under which interference is permitted only where the order is perverse, grossly erroneous, glaringly unreasonable, wholly unreliable or untenable, rests on immaterial or no material, ignores relevant material, or reflects arbitrary or capricious exercise of discretion.
¶ 20–21The court applied the ingredients of s. 138 NI Act, and the presumptions under ss. 118 and 139 NI Act, which are rebuttable.
¶ 22–23The court relied on Rajaram v. Maruthachalam (AIR 2023 SC 471) and Basalingappa v. Mudibasappa (AIR 2019 SC 1983) on the rebuttal of presumptions and on inconsistency regarding the date of lending.
¶ 11, 37–38The court applied the principle that the accused need only establish a probable defence on a preponderance of probabilities, after which the burden shifts to the complainant to prove the loan with cogent evidence, as articulated in Rajesh Jain v. Ajay Singh (SLP (Crl) No. 12802/2022).
¶ 44–45Ashok Singh v. State of U.P. (2025 INSC 427) holds that the complainant need not establish financial capacity unless the accused raises a probable defence on this point.
¶ 43The court also cited H.R. Sheshadri v. U.V. Nataraj (Crl.R.P. No. 573/2019), Jadesha Reddy v. G. Chandranna (Crl.A. No. 100114/2014), N. Vijay Kumar v. Vishwanath Rao N (Crl.A. No. 5305/2024), and Smt. Latha B.M. v. N. Nagesh (Crl.R.P. No. 1293/2023) on financial capacity, probable defence, and the mandate of ss. 118/139.
¶ 39–42On sentence, the court applied the principle that a fine must be reasoned and not exorbitant, drawing on the approach in Ashok Singh v. State of U.P. (sentence modified to fine).
¶ 43, 49–52Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 397Section 401Section 200Section 313
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 438Section 442
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138Section 139Section 118
04Reasoning
The statutory ingredients under s. 138 were established, since the accused admitted his signature and the cheque, and the presentation, notice, and complaint timelines were satisfied. The presumptions under ss. 118 and 139 therefore arose.
¶ 25–27The court then assessed whether the accused's cross-examination and defence evidence rebutted the presumptions. It found the defence points partly substantiated. The complainant's first statement of November 2014 as the lending date, made only in cross-examination, was inconsistent with the earlier pleadings, and his bank balance at that time was only some thousands.
¶ 28–29, 32, 37–38The lending was also absent from the complainant's IT returns.
¶ 36The court nonetheless found that the complainant's KIADB acquisition receipts of about ₹2 crore in 2013, with gradual withdrawals in 2013 and early 2014, supported his capacity to lend.
¶ 31The Manjula Devi complaint related to a June 2015 transaction, later than the present loan, and the complainant denied it, so it did not help the accused.
¶ 34, 48The accused's ₹16,00,000 counter-claim was undocumented, and his claim that the cheque was given only for discounting was unproven and denied in cross-examination.
¶ 46–47The court therefore held that the accused had not discharged the burden of a probable defence, and the presumptions stood. Applying the revisional standard, it concluded that the trial court had not ignored material evidence or relied on irrelevant material, and that there was no gross erroneousness.
¶ 45–48On sentence, the court noted that the trial court gave no reasons for a fine exceeding the cheque amount. It also observed that the appellate court's reasoning, that the fine was not twice the cheque amount and that 9% interest was not imposed, did not justify it.
¶ 49–50Given that the transaction was a loan between friends rather than a commercial transaction, and that the matter had been pending since 2015, the court held the ₹45,00,000 fine exorbitant.
¶ 51–5205Holding
The concurrent findings of conviction under s. 138 NI Act were not perverse or grossly erroneous, and the accused failed to rebut the statutory presumptions under ss. 118 and 139. The conviction was therefore confirmed.
¶ 48, 52The fine of ₹45,00,000 was held to be exorbitant and was reduced.
¶ 52The operative order reduces the fine from ₹45,00,000 to ₹38,02,000, of which ₹38,00,000 is payable as compensation to the complainant and ₹2,000 to the State, with all other parts of the trial and appellate judgments left unaltered. The petition is allowed in part.
¶ 53Original Court PDF
SRI R GOVINDARAJUvsSRI K MUNIYAPPA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
