01Facts
The appellant-claimant, a 27-year-old agriculturist, was injured in a road traffic accident on 06.10.2024, which he attributed to the rash and negligent driving of a Maruti Suzuki Alto car bearing registration No. KA-42/N-6331
¶ 3The claimant's age is recorded as 27 in the reasoning, though the cause-title describes him as "aged about 29 years"
¶ 6 · p. 1He sustained (i) a displaced fracture of the lateral end of the right clavicle (grievous), (ii) contusion over the right flank, and (iii) contusion over the upper abdomen
¶ 6PW-2, a doctor, assessed 20% disability of the right upper limb and 7% disability of the whole body
¶ 6The Tribunal (MACT, Bengaluru, MVC No. 8911/2024) awarded Rs. 2,92,850 under seven heads, including Rs. 50,000 for pain and suffering, Rs. 1,23,350 for medical expenses, and Rs. 49,500 for loss of income during the laid-up period
¶ 3The Tribunal awarded no compensation for loss of future income due to disability, reasoning that the fracture was of an "ornamental bone" and had united
¶ 6The Tribunal awarded 6% interest from the date of the petition
¶ 4The claimant appealed under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, challenging only the denial of loss of future income
p. 1Respondent No. 2 (insurer) contested the appeal
¶ 1, 502Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in denying compensation for loss of future earning capacity arising from the permanent disability caused by a clavicle fracture to an agriculturist claimant.
¶ 6ii.2. Whether the claimant is entitled to enhanced compensation and, if so, the quantum thereof, computed on the notional income, multiplier, and disability percentage applicable to the case.
¶ 6, 703Law Applied
The Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, under which the appeal was preferred (Section 173(1))
p. 1Loss of future earning capacity is compensable where a permanent physical disability affects the claimant's avocation
¶ 6Notional income of Rs. 17,000 per month fixed for 2024 by the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority
¶ 6Multiplier of 17 applicable to the claimant's age
¶ 6Disability to an upper limb is converted to whole-body disability by taking one-fourth of the upper-limb percentage
¶ 6No specific statutory provision, precedent, or authority is cited for the multiplier or the one-fourth conversion rule
Loss of future income = monthly income × 12 × multiplier × disability percentage
¶ 6Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
04Reasoning
The Tribunal denied future income loss on the basis that the clavicle is an "ornamental bone" and that the fracture had united
¶ 6The High Court rejected this reasoning, holding that the claimant is an agriculturist whose work requires lifting heavy articles and that a clavicle fracture would necessarily affect that avocation
¶ 6Applying the notional income of Rs. 17,000 per month, a multiplier of 17, and the converted disability of 5% (one-fourth of the 20% upper-limb disability), the Court computed the loss as Rs. 17,000 × 12 × 17 × 5% = Rs. 1,73,400
¶ 6The Court did not enhance any other head, as the claimant did not seek enhancement under them
¶ 7Respondent No. 2 was held liable to pay the enhanced amount with interest
¶ 7The Court's characterisation of the clavicle as an "ornamental bone" is noted in the judgment but was effectively displaced by the finding of avocation-related impact
¶ 605Holding
The Tribunal erred in denying loss of future income due to disability, as the permanent 20% upper-limb disability materially affects the claimant's agricultural work
¶ 6The appeal is allowed in part. The claimant is awarded enhanced compensation of Rs. 1,73,400 with 6% interest per annum from the date of the petition until realisation
¶ 6, 7 · p. 6Respondent No. 2 (insurer) is directed to deposit the enhanced compensation with interest before the Tribunal within six weeks, and the claimant is entitled to release of the entire enhanced amount
¶ 8, orders (ii)–(iv)Original Court PDF
SRI PUNITH V RvsMR GIRISH
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
