Karnataka High CourtCivil LawInsurance Law

Karnataka HC Raises Accident Award To ₹8.77 Lakh, Rules One-Third Income Deduction Applies Even If Only Widow Depends On Deceased

THE DIVISIONAL MANAGERv.SMT.MEHABOOBI W/O. ABDULSAB DESHANUR

Karnataka HC Raises Accident Award To ₹8.77 Lakh, Rules One-Third Income Deduction Applies Even If Only Widow Depends On Deceased. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER vs SMT.MEHABOOBI W/O. ABDULSAB DESHANUR. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether, where the deceased was married and only Claimant 1 (widow) is the dependant, the deduction towards the deceased's personal expenses should be one-half (insurer's contention) or one-third (claimants' contention).

The court held

Where the deceased was married, the personal-expense deduction is one-third even if only one dependant survives, and the notional income is ₹8,750 per month absent proof otherwise.

It also directed

The insurer's MFA No. 100297/2019 is dismissed. The claimants' MFA No. 101271/2021 is allowed in part. The award is modified to ₹8,77,000 with 9% interest from the date of petition till realization. The insurer must deposit the amount with interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks. Apportionment among Claimants 1–3 is 62:30:08. The Registry is directed to transmit the deposit and records and to draw the modified award.

01Facts

On 15.04.2016, a 407 passenger tempo (KA-28/3939) and a motorcycle (KA-24/U-4152) were involved in an accident.

¶ 2

The occurrence, the deceased's age (65 years) and his avocation were not disputed.

¶ 2

The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, II Addl. District & Sessions Judge, Belagavi (MVC No. 197/2017), held the claimants to be dependants, found rash and negligent driving of the tempo, and fastened liability on the insurer.

¶ 3

The Tribunal awarded ₹6,12,614 (medical ₹1,86,614; loss of dependency ₹3,36,000; funeral ₹10,000; transportation ₹5,000; loss of love and affection ₹75,000).

¶ 3

The insurer appealed (MFA 100297/2019) against quantum and liability; the claimants appealed for enhancement (MFA 101271/2021).

¶ 4

The insurer did not press its fitness-certificate objection.

¶ 4

Claimant 1 is the widow, Claimant 2 a major son earning from coolie work, and Claimant 3 a married daughter residing at her matrimonial home.

¶ 5

Claimants' counsel conceded that Claimants 2 and 3 are not dependants.

¶ 5

The claimants pleaded that the deceased was an agriculturist/mango trader, but no cogent evidence was produced.

¶ 8

02Issues

i.1. Whether, where the deceased was married and only Claimant 1 (widow) is the dependant, the deduction towards the deceased's personal expenses should be one-half (insurer's contention) or one-third (claimants' contention).

¶ 4, 5, 6, 7

ii.2. Whether the deceased's income should be fixed at ₹6,000 (Tribunal) or ₹8,750 per the KSLSA Notional Income Chart, in the absence of proof of agricultural/business income.

¶ 5, 8

iii.3. Whether the compensation under conventional heads (funeral, transportation, loss of consortium, loss of estate) is inadequate and requires enhancement.

¶ 5, 9

iv.4. Whether the 9% interest awarded by the Tribunal warrants interference.

¶ 10

03Law Applied

Sarla Verma & Ors. v. DTC & Anr. (2009) 6 SCC 121 prescribes standardized personal-expense deductions for married deceased persons: one-third where dependants number 2–3, one-fourth for 4–6, and one-fifth for more than six.

¶ 6

Ved Kanwar v. Babulal (CA 4296-4297/2026), after considering Sarla Verma and National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680, holds that the minimum deduction for a married deceased is one-third, even with a single dependant.

¶ 5, 7

The Division Bench decision in Smt. Ratna v. Veerayya (RP 100058/2021) applied the one-third deduction where a married deceased had a sole dependant.

¶ 7

For conventional heads, the court followed Pranay Sethi and Rojalini Nayak v. Ajit Sahoo (2024 INSC 584).

¶ 9

On interest, the court followed Puttamma v. K.L. Narayana Reddy (2013) 15 SCC 45 and United India Insurance Co. v. Malyadari (MFA 3895/2018).

¶ 10

The income-fixation basis is the KSLSA Notional Income Chart.

¶ 8

The insurer's cited authorities, United India Insurance Co. v. N.P. Joy (CA 7050/2026) and Deep Shikha v. National Insurance Co. (2025 INSC 675), are recorded but not expressly discussed in the reasoning.

¶ 4

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166

04Reasoning

The court rejected the insurer's one-half deduction. Relying on paragraph 30 of Sarla Verma, it observed that the one-third rate applies to 2–3 dependants, but held that Ved Kanwar and Ratna confirm a one-third floor for married deceased persons even where only one dependant survives. Hence, one-third was deducted from the income of the deceased.

¶ 6, 7

With no cogent proof of agricultural or mango-business income, the court adopted the KSLSA Notional Income Chart figure of ₹8,750 per month, given that the accident occurred in 2016.

¶ 8

Applying a multiplier of 7 (deceased aged 65), the loss of dependency was computed as ₹8,750 − ₹2,917 = ₹5,833 × 12 × 7 = ₹4,90,000.

¶ 8

Finding the conventional heads and loss-of-estate/consortium awards on the lower side, the court applied Pranay Sethi and Rojalini Nayak to enhance them: consortium ₹53,240 × 3 = ₹1,59,720; estate ₹19,965; funeral ₹19,965.

¶ 9

The revised total of ₹8,76,264 was rounded to ₹8,77,000.

¶ 9

The interest challenge failed because the cited authorities supported the Tribunal's rate.

¶ 10

05Holding

Where the deceased was married, the personal-expense deduction is one-third even if only one dependant survives, and the notional income is ₹8,750 per month absent proof otherwise.

¶ 7, 8

The insurer's MFA No. 100297/2019 is dismissed. The claimants' MFA No. 101271/2021 is allowed in part. The award is modified to ₹8,77,000 with 9% interest from the date of petition till realization. The insurer must deposit the amount with interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks. Apportionment among Claimants 1–3 is 62:30:08. The Registry is directed to transmit the deposit and records and to draw the modified award.

order (i)–(viii) · ¶ 11
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

THE DIVISIONAL MANAGERvsSMT.MEHABOOBI W/O. ABDULSAB DESHANUR

Karnataka High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment