01Facts
On 16.06.2015, a motorcycle (KA-22/EA-1768) and a Tempo Trax (KA-23/M-8486) were involved in an accident. The occurrence and the vehicles involved are not disputed.
¶ 2The claimant, the rider of the motorcycle, filed MVC No. 2212/2015 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 before the Senior Civil Judge and Additional MACT, Bailhongal.
¶ 3The Tribunal, by judgment dated 04.02.2019, fastened liability on the insurer of the Tempo Trax and awarded Rs. 1,91,960/- under the heads of pain and suffering (Rs. 30,000), medical expenses (Rs. 50,000), attendant and nourishment charges (Rs. 1,800), and loss of future income (Rs. 1,10,160).
¶ 3Charge sheets were filed against the Tempo Trax driver under Sections 279 and 338 IPC, and against the claimant under Section 3 r/w 181 and Section 146 r/w 196 of the MV Act.
¶ 4, 8The insurer contended that the claimant had no driving licence and the vehicle had no valid insurance policy, and that the claimant contributed to the accident.
¶ 5The claimant contended that the Tribunal undervalued the income, disability and injuries, and failed to award loss of amenities and loss of income during the laid-up period.
¶ 4The claimant filed MFA No. 104359/2019 seeking enhancement, and the insurer filed MFA No. 102150/2019 seeking to set aside the award.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal's finding that the claimant (rider) did not contribute to the accident, despite his lack of a driving licence, requires interference.
¶ 7(i) · ¶ 9–11ii.2. Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal, including the income, disability and head-wise amounts, requires modification.
¶ 7(i) · ¶ 12–1303Law Applied
Sections 166 and 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 govern compensation claims and appeals.
¶ 1The criminal provisions invoked under Sections 279 and 338 IPC against the Tempo Trax driver and Section 3 r/w 181 and Section 146 r/w 196 MV Act against the rider prima facie indicate negligence on the driver's part.
¶ 4, 8Meera Devi & Anr. v. H.R.T.C. & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 5764/2008) holds that contributory negligence cannot be inferred without cogent evidence.
¶ 9Dinesh Kumar @ Dinesh J v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 22966/2017), adopting Sudhir Kumar Rana v. Surinder Singh, (2008) 12 SCC 436, para 9, holds that driving without a licence is an offence that may ground negligence, but does not by itself establish contributory negligence unless the rider was driving rashly or negligently and this contributed to the accident.
¶ 10For quantum, the Court relied on the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority's notional income chart for the year of accident (2015) and on the standard multiplier for a claimant aged 28 years, namely 17.
¶ 12The functional disability principle assesses disability with reference to the impairment and the claimant's avocation and physical strength requirements.
¶ 13Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166Section 3Section 181Section 146Section 196
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279Section 338
04Reasoning
The chargesheets against both drivers, particularly the IPC charges against the Tempo Trax driver, prima facie indicated negligence on that driver's part.
¶ 8On contributory negligence, the insurer proved the claimant's lack of a driving licence and led evidence on the point, but failed to establish that the rider drove rashly or negligently or that his conduct caused the accident.
¶ 9Following Dinesh Kumar, the absence of a licence alone was held insufficient to fasten contributory negligence, and the Court therefore declined to apportion any liability on the claimant.
¶ 10–11The Court distinguished Meera Devi only on the insurer's argument that the claimant there was a minor, but held that the principle of requiring cogent evidence applied equally.
¶ 5, 9On quantum, the claimant produced no material supporting his plea of Rs. 10,000/- per month income as a labour contractor's worker. The Court therefore fixed notional income at Rs. 8,000/- per month, rather than the Tribunal's Rs. 6,000/-.
¶ 12Applying multiplier 17 and considering the wound certificate (two simple and two grievous injuries), a 25% disability of the right lower limb and 10% of the right upper limb, the Court assessed functional disability at 11%.
¶ 13Head-wise compensation was reassessed: pain and suffering Rs. 65,000; medical expenses Rs. 50,000 (unchanged); attendant/nourishment Rs. 10,000; laid-up income Rs. 24,000; loss of amenities Rs. 30,000; and loss of future income Rs. 1,79,520 (Rs. 8,000 × 12 × 17 × 11%), totalling Rs. 3,58,520.
¶ 1305Holding
Interference with the Tribunal's award was required only insofar as quantum was concerned. The claimant's rider was not held contributorily negligent, as the insurer failed to show rash or negligent riding contributing to the accident.
¶ 11, 14On Issue 2, the Court reassessed compensation at Rs. 3,58,520/- and affirmed the increased heads.
¶ 12–13MFA No. 104359/2019 (claimant) is partly allowed; MFA No. 102150/2019 (insurer) is dismissed; the award is modified; the claimant is entitled to Rs. 3,58,520/- with 9% interest per annum from the date of petition until realisation; the insurer must deposit the amount with interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks of receipt of a certified copy; no other interference is ordered; and the Registry is to transmit the deposit and records to the Tribunal and draw the modified award.
¶ 14Original Court PDF
VITTALvsSHAMSHAD
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
