01Facts
On 22.12.2015, the claimant was riding a motorcycle on NH-63 when a Mahindra Scorpio (KA-35/N-0048), coming from the opposite direction, collided with it. The claimant fell and sustained grievous injuries.
¶ 2The driver-cum-owner (R1) did not contest the claim. The insurer (R2) filed objections alleging that the petition was not maintainable, that the claim was exorbitant, and that R1 held no valid driving licence.
¶ 3The claimant examined himself (PW1) and a doctor (PW2) and produced Exs. P1–P13. R2 produced Ex. R1 and led no oral evidence.
¶ 4The Tribunal held the accident was caused by the rash and negligent driving of the Scorpio, assessed disability at 10%, and awarded ₹2,80,800/-.
¶ 5Medical evidence showed fractures of the right humerus (greater tuberosity) and right tibia (lateral condyle and tibial tuberosity), along with soft-tissue injuries.
¶ 10PW2 assessed permanent partial disability at 34% to the whole body.
¶ 11The claimant contended before the High Court that his income was ₹10,000/- per month, and that he had been assessed at ₹6,000/- per month by the Tribunal.
¶ 6, 11The claimant appealed for enhancement under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal's award of compensation, including its fixing of disability at 10% and income at ₹6,000/- per month, requires interference in appeal?
¶ 8ii.2. Whether the claimant's functional disability and notional income should be determined by reference to the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority Notional Income Chart, given the absence of documentary proof of actual earnings?
¶ 11iii.3. Whether interest at 7% per annum awarded by the Tribunal is just and proper, or whether a higher rate is warranted?
¶ 1303Law Applied
The court proceeded under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (claim for compensation) and Section 173(1) (appeal against the award).
¶ 1Compensation was computed under the head of loss of earning capacity by applying the formula: monthly income × 12 × multiplier × percentage of disability, with a multiplier of 14 for a claimant aged 41.
¶ 11Where the claimant's income is unproven, the court relied on the Notional Income Chart issued by the Karnataka State Legal Services Authority, fixing income at ₹8,000/- per month for accidents in 2015.
¶ 11On interest, the court relied on Puttamma & Ors. v. K.L. Narayana Reddy & Anr., (2013) 15 SCC 45, which holds that inflation, economic change and RBI policy must be considered in fixing interest.
¶ 13The court also relied on United India Insurance Co. v. Malyadari, MFA No. 3895/2018 (Karnataka HC, Co-ordinate Bench), which holds that 9% per annum is appropriate in death and serious-injury cases.
¶ 13Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166
04Reasoning
The court affirmed the Tribunal's finding of R1's rash and negligent driving. It relied on Exs. P1–P3 (FIR, chargesheet and spot panchnama), and noted that R2 had cross-examined PW1 without leading any evidence to prove contributory negligence by the motorcyclist.
¶ 9On quantum, the court found the claimant's ₹10,000/- income claim unsupported by any documents, so it applied the notional income of ₹8,000/- per month.
¶ 11The court rejected the Tribunal's 10% disability finding because the claimant performed physically demanding coolie work. It therefore fixed functional disability at 12%, reasoning that the 34% medical disability did not translate in full to loss of earning capacity.
¶ 11Applying the formula, loss of income was computed at ₹1,61,280/-.
¶ 11The Tribunal's awards for medical expenses (₹1,10,000/-) and future medical expenses (₹10,000/-) were left undisturbed. Pain and suffering was enhanced from ₹40,000/- to ₹75,000/- and loss of amenities from ₹20,000/- to ₹60,000/-.
¶ 12On interest, the court applied Puttamma and Malyadari to enhance the rate from 7% to 9% per annum.
¶ 13The judgment does not address R2's plea that R1 lacked a valid driving licence, and it does not expressly discuss the basis for the 14 multiplier or the authority for it.
05Holding
The appeal is allowed in part. The Tribunal's award is modified.
¶ 12The claimant is entitled to total compensation of ₹4,16,280/- (up from ₹2,80,800/-).
¶ 12, 14(iii)Interest at 9% per annum is payable from the date of the petition until realization.
¶ 14(iii)The insurance company must deposit the compensation with accrued interest before the jurisdictional Tribunal within eight weeks of receipt of a certified copy of the judgment.
¶ 14(iv)The Registry is directed to transmit any deposited amount and the trial court records to the Tribunal and to draw the modified award.
¶ 14(v)–(vi)Original Court PDF
S KHAJA, S/O. HUSSAIN SAB,vsH K PAKKIRAPPA @ KORI PAKKIRAPPA @ PAKKIRAPPA,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
