CAT - ['Allahabad']

Full pension must be restored upon completion of the 15-year commutation period.

Munni bai vs PENSIONS AND PENSIONERS WELFARE

CAT - ['Allahabad']JUDGMENT: October 15, 20262 MIN READSOURCE JUDGMENT
Full pension must be restored upon completion of the 15-year commutation period.. Munni bai  vs PENSIONS AND PENSIONERS WELFARE. CAT - ['Allahabad']. LawLens
THE ORIGINAL LAWLENS SUMMARY
01

Facts

The applicant, a retired Railway employee, retired on 31 August 2007. Her Pension Payment Order (PPO) recorded 1 September 2007 as the pension commencement date and 1 September 2022 as the date for restoration of full pension after 15 years of commutation.

Source reference: para. 6

She alleged that the commuted portion continued to be deducted after that date and sought restoration of full pension, consequential arrears, refund of ₹92,058, and interest.

Source reference: paras. 2–3

The respondents filed no counter despite opportunities, and their opportunity to do so was closed.

Source reference: para. 4

At the hearing, the respondents’ counsel accepted her entitlement to restoration from 1 September 2022 and referred to a departmental communication dated 22 March 2024 concerning revision of her pension.

Source reference: para. 7
02

Issues

1. Whether the applicant was entitled to restoration of full pension with effect from 1 September 2022, on completion of 15 years from commutation.

Source reference: paras. 6, 9

2. Whether the respondents were required to issue or implement a revised PPO and pay consequential pension arrears, with interest.

Source reference: paras. 9–10
03

Law Applied

The Tribunal applied the entitlement recorded in the applicant’s PPO: full pension was to be restored upon completion of 15 years from commutation, with the relevant restoration date specified as 1 September 2022.

Source reference: paras. 6, 9

The order cites no statute, regulation, or judicial precedent; its decision rests on the PPO and the respondents’ acknowledgment of the applicant’s entitlement.

Source reference: paras. 7, 9
04

Reasoning

The PPO expressly identified 1 September 2022 as the date for restoration of full pension, and the respondents’ counsel accepted that the applicant was entitled to restoration from that date.

Source reference: paras. 6–7

The Tribunal therefore directed the respondents to revise the PPO and ensure restoration, requiring implementation even if the departmental communication of 22 March 2024 had already been sent to the bank.

Source reference: para. 9

It further directed payment of consequential arrears with interest at the applicable GPF rate.

Source reference: para. 10
05

Holding

The Tribunal disposed of the application by directing the respondents to issue a revised PPO and restore the applicant’s full pension with effect from 1 September 2022.

The revised PPO was to be issued within one month of receipt of a certified copy of the order, and consequential arrears, with interest at the applicable GPF rate, were to be paid within the same period.

Source reference: paras. 9–10

No order as to costs was made.

Source reference: para. 10
CAT - ['Allahabad']

Original Court PDF

Munni baivsPENSIONS AND PENSIONERS WELFARE

CAT - ['Allahabad'] · October 15, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment