01Facts
The respondent's hotel was hired by the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, from 15.11.2020 at a fixed room rent and per-head catering rate, and was de-hired w.e.f. 05.10.2021.
¶ 3–4Part payment for that period was made, and the balance was reportedly pending before the Divisional Commissioner.
¶ 4, 17The Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, re-hired 19 rooms by order dated 27.10.2021 on the same terms, and the rooms were occupied by protected persons until 25.10.2022.
¶ 5, 21The order named 38 protected persons.
¶ 21–22After vacation, the respondent's bills were not cleared. A Committee constituted on 05.11.2022 verified payments on the basis of actual occupancy and reported on 10.02.2023, and the bills were cleared accordingly.
¶ 6The respondent filed WP(C) No. 590/2023 seeking certiorari against the 05.11.2022 order and the Committee report, and mandamus for payment for all 19 rooms.
¶ 7–8The Divisional Commissioner was not impleaded.
¶ 9The 15.11.2020–05.10.2021 claim was introduced only through a supplementary affidavit, without amendment of the petition.
¶ 11, 18The writ Court allowed the petition, quashed the impugned order and report, and directed payment for the entire period from 15.11.2020 to 25.10.2022.
¶ 12The Union appealed.
¶ 1, 13–1402Issues
i.1. Whether the writ Court travelled beyond the pleadings and violated natural justice by allowing a claim for 15.11.2020–05.10.2021, which was raised only by supplementary affidavit, without impleading the Divisional Commissioner.
¶ 13, 16–20ii.2. Whether the respondent is entitled to boarding and lodging (room rent) charges for all 19 hired rooms for 27.10.2021–25.10.2022, irrespective of actual occupancy.
¶ 21–23iii.3. Whether catering charges are payable on the basis of all 38 named protected persons or only on actual heads availing catering services.
¶ 24–2503Law Applied
Relief in a writ petition must be confined to the pleadings, and an authority against whom a claim lies must be heard before adverse relief is granted, which is a requirement of natural justice.
¶ 19–20The terms of the hiring order dated 27.10.2021 are controlling. Under those terms, the rooms were hired on a per-room basis, and absent any stipulation that payment would depend on actual occupancy, the hotel had to keep all rooms ready.
¶ 21–22The Divisional Commissioner's circular dated 07.11.2020 fixed room rent per day per room and catering charges per head per day.
¶ 21, 24The judgment cites no precedent.
04Reasoning
The 15.11.2020–05.10.2021 claim had not been pleaded. The petition sought no relief for that period, the Divisional Commissioner was not impleaded, and the claim entered only through a supplementary affidavit.
¶ 16–18The writ Court therefore granted relief against an authority that had no opportunity to contest it, which was both beyond the pleadings and contrary to natural justice.
¶ 19–20On room rent for 27.10.2021–25.10.2022, the Court held that the hiring order fixed the rooms on a per-room basis with no occupancy condition. Payment linked to actual occupancy was therefore unjustified, and the Committee's approach was untenable.
¶ 22–24On catering, the Court held that the charge is per head per day under the circular. Charges are therefore payable only for persons who actually took food, not for all 38 named persons.
¶ 24–2505Holding
The writ Court's direction is set aside insofar as it covers 15.11.2020–05.10.2021. The respondent may make a representation to the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, which must be decided on merits and paid without delay, with liberty to file a fresh writ petition if aggrieved.
¶ 20, 26(a)–(c)Room rent is payable for all 19 rooms for 27.10.2021–25.10.2022, less amounts already paid, irrespective of occupancy.
¶ 26(d)Catering charges for the same period are payable only on actual occupancy, i.e., per head actually availing catering services, and any pending amount is to be released forthwith.
¶ 25, 26(e)Balance payments are to be made within two months, failing which interest at 6% per annum runs from the due date until payment. The appeal is partly allowed, and the writ Court's judgment stands modified accordingly.
¶ 26(f), 27Original Court PDF
UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND OTHERS (REVENUE)vsHOTEL NEW METRO
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
