Jammu and Kashmir High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

J&K High Court Refers to Larger Bench Whether Magistrate's FIR Orders Are Revisable, Including Against Police Officers

BHARAT BHUSHAN AND ANOTHERv.NEELAM GORKHA

J&K High Court Refers to Larger Bench Whether Magistrate's FIR Orders Are Revisable, Including Against Police Officers. BHARAT BHUSHAN AND ANOTHER vs NEELAM GORKHA. Jammu and Kashmir High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether an order under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. directing registration of an FIR and investigation is invariably interlocutory within Section 397(2) Cr.P.C.

The court held

The Court did not finally answer whether a Section 156(3) order is interlocutory or revisable. It held that the question requires authoritative determination by a larger Bench, given the existing contrary decision in Satpal Sharma and divergent High Court views. It formulated six questions for reference, covering: interlocutory versus intermediate character; relevance of final disposal; the effect of Amar Nath, Madhu Limaye and Girish Kumar Suneja on Satpal Sharma; whether jurisdictional or safeguard defects are revisable; the permissible scope of revisional interference at each stage; and the effect of Section 175(3) BNSS read with Section 438(2) BNSS

It also directed

The Registry was directed to place the records of both petitions before the Chief Justice for constitution of a larger Bench. The judgment does not set aside the impugned revisional orders or the Magistrate's directions, and it does not remit the matters for merits consideration. The petitioners' prayer for setting aside and remand is therefore left to the larger Bench's determination

01Facts

Two petitions raise whether an order under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. (Section 175(3) BNSS) directing registration of an FIR and investigation is an interlocutory order barring revision under Section 397(2) Cr.P.C. (Section 438(2) BNSS), or an intermediate order that is revisable

¶ 1

The petitioners run M/s National Medical Hall at Bishnah, Jammu, as tenants of the respondent's family, and allege threats of forcible dispossession from 15.11.2023

¶ 19–20

The petitioners obtained a civil injunction restraining dispossession

¶ 21

On 09.03.2024 and 10.03.2024, the respondent and her sons allegedly forcibly entered the shop and assaulted petitioner No. 2, and FIR No. 0027/2024 was registered under IPC Sections 447, 441, 323 and 34

¶ 22

The respondent then moved the Munsiff/JMIC, Bishnah under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.

¶ 22

On 03.06.2024 the Magistrate allowed the application and directed the SHO to register an FIR

¶ 18, 22

The Additional Sessions Judge, Jammu dismissed the revision on 28.02.2025 as non-maintainable, holding the order interlocutory

¶ 18, 22

In CRM(M) No. 678/2021, the petitioners are the then SSP Jammu, the Cyber Crime PS DySP, and the SHO Janipur PS, and the order directed FIR registration against senior police officials

¶ 16, 23–24

The petitioners contend that no statutory sanction was obtained and that the order was passed without jurisdiction, judicial application of mind, or compliance with statutory safeguards

¶ 16, 23–24

The revisional court dismissed the revision as non-maintainable

¶ 4(iv), 17

02Issues

i.1. Whether an order under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. directing registration of an FIR and investigation is invariably interlocutory within Section 397(2) Cr.P.C.

¶ 4(i) · ¶ 1

ii.2. Whether final disposal of a Section 156(3) application, with its consequences, renders the order revisable

¶ 4(ii) · ¶ 47–49

iii.3. Whether the revisional court may examine lack of jurisdiction, non-application of mind, or non-compliance with statutory safeguards in such an order

¶ 4(iii) · ¶ 57

iv.4. Whether the Additional Sessions Judge was justified in dismissing the revisions solely as non-maintainable

¶ 4(iv) · ¶ 18

v.5. Whether Satpal Sharma (coordinate Bench) requires reconsideration and reference to a larger Bench

¶ 60–62

03Law Applied

Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., which permits a Magistrate to direct investigation at the pre-cognizance stage, together with the judicial-discretion requirement that accompanies it

¶ 26–27

Section 397(1) and (2) Cr.P.C. (Section 438 BNSS) confer revisional power but bar revision of interlocutory orders, and Section 175(3) BNSS adds affidavit and police-submission safeguards

¶ 27–28

Under Amar Nath v. State of Haryana and Madhu Limaye v. State of Maharashtra, the classification of orders is not binary; intermediate orders with finality on a distinct issue fall outside the bar

¶ 30–31

Girish Kumar Suneja v. CBI adds that the test is whether acceptance of the objection would end the proceedings or a part of them

¶ 32

Father Thomas v. State of U.P. (Allahabad FB) holds such orders interlocutory and non-revisable at the instance of a prospective accused

¶ 34–35

Arun P. Gidh v. Chandraprakash Singh (Bombay FB) recognises revisional jurisdiction within its precedents without deciding the general question

¶ 37–39

Manohar Nath Sher v. State of J&K (1980 KLJ 1) lays down the test for interlocutory orders

¶ 40

Satpal Sharma v. Pawan Singh Rathore (J&K HC) holds such orders interlocutory and non-revisable, and binds a coordinate Bench absent distinction or a larger-Bench reference

¶ 41–42

Anurag Bhatnagar v. State (NCT of Delhi) (SC) requires independent judicial application of mind

¶ 43–45

HDFC Securities v. State of Maharashtra (SC) limits interference with investigation

¶ 46

Priyanka Srivastava v. State of U.P. and Anil Kumar v. M.K. Aiyappa (SC) require the Magistrate to apply judicial mind and not act as a forwarding authority

¶ 53–54

Where a statutory prohibition or sanction applies to public servants, the Magistrate must examine it

¶ 56–57

Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 156Section 190Section 397Section 482

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 175Section 438

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 447Section 441Section 323Section 34

04Reasoning

The Court held that neither the finality of the Section 156(3) disposal nor the serious consequences of investigation is determinative. Disposal of the application terminates only the request for a procedural direction, not the criminal proceeding, and the test of finality cannot be applied mechanically

¶ 47–48

Consequences such as examination, search or arrest are relevant but do not by themselves decide the order's character, since an investigation order is not a finding of guilt

¶ 50–51

The Court accepted that jurisdictional defects and non-application of mind must be checked, but held that the existence of a defect and the availability of revision are distinct questions; the revisional court must first have jurisdiction

¶ 52, 57

On Satpal Sharma, the Court noted that a coordinate Bench may not overrule an earlier decision merely because a different view appears preferable

¶ 42, 60

Where a substantial question of law exists and divergent High Court views persist, the proper course is a larger-Bench reference, given the frequency of such orders and their continuing relevance under Section 175(3) BNSS

¶ 61

The Court therefore did not decide the merits of either petition

05Holding

The Court did not finally answer whether a Section 156(3) order is interlocutory or revisable. It held that the question requires authoritative determination by a larger Bench, given the existing contrary decision in Satpal Sharma and divergent High Court views. It formulated six questions for reference, covering: interlocutory versus intermediate character; relevance of final disposal; the effect of Amar Nath, Madhu Limaye and Girish Kumar Suneja on Satpal Sharma; whether jurisdictional or safeguard defects are revisable; the permissible scope of revisional interference at each stage; and the effect of Section 175(3) BNSS read with Section 438(2) BNSS

¶ 58, 62–63

The Registry was directed to place the records of both petitions before the Chief Justice for constitution of a larger Bench. The judgment does not set aside the impugned revisional orders or the Magistrate's directions, and it does not remit the matters for merits consideration. The petitioners' prayer for setting aside and remand is therefore left to the larger Bench's determination

¶ 17, 64
Jammu and Kashmir High Court

Original Court PDF

BHARAT BHUSHAN AND ANOTHERvsNEELAM GORKHA

Jammu and Kashmir High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment