01Facts
The case arises from a family dispute involving the sale of ancestral agricultural land in 2007 for approximately Rs. 15.31 crores, the proceeds of which were received by Respondent No. 2 (father of the parties)
pp. 2-3Respondent No. 1 (daughter) filed a suit for recovery of Rs. 45 lakhs and partition, claiming her share in the sale proceeds
p. 3Defendant No. 3 (appellants' late father) filed a written statement mentioning a family settlement where he received Rs. 3 crores
p. 3A preliminary decree later fixed each party’s share at 1/6th (approx. Rs. 2.55 crores)
p. 4Respondent No. 1 then sought a decree on admission under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, arguing Defendant No. 3 admitted to receiving more than his share
pp. 4-5While the Trial Court dismissed the application citing triable issues, the Delhi High Court reversed this in revision, decreeing the suit based on the written statement
p. 502Issues
i.1. Whether the averments made by Defendant No. 3 in the written statement amounted to a clear, unequivocal, and unconditional admission to justify a decree under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC
¶ 30ii.2. Whether the High Court exceeded its revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC by reversing a finding of fact regarding the existence of triable issues
¶ 17, 4403Law Applied
The Court applied Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC, which grants discretionary power to pass a judgment on admissions provided the admission is "clear, unambiguous, and unconditional"
¶ 31, 35It referenced Sections 17 and 18 of the Evidence Act, 1872, regarding the definition of admissions
¶ 32Precedentially, the Court relied on Vikrant Kapila v. Pankaja Panda and Himani Alloys Ltd. v. Tata Steel Ltd., which establish that Order XII Rule 6 is an enabling, discretionary provision that should not be used to deny a defendant’s right to a trial unless the admission is categorical
¶ 35Regarding revisional powers, it invoked Pandurang Dhondi Chougule v. Maruti Hari Jadhav, holding that Section 115 CPC does not allow a court to act as an appellate body to reassess facts
¶ 44Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 115Section 151Section 12
04Reasoning
The Supreme Court reasoned that the High Court erred by reading a single paragraph of the written statement in isolation
¶ 39When read holistically, Defendant No. 3’s statement regarding the receipt of Rs. 3 crores was contextualized within a disputed family settlement and was accompanied by a denial of liability toward the plaintiff
¶ 38-39The Court noted that since the entire sale amount was held by Respondent No. 2, the liability of Defendant No. 3 involved complex factual questions of fiduciary duty and inter-se distribution that required evidence
¶ 40-41Crucially, the Court observed that the High Court had previously framed specific issues for trial in 2015, which inherently acknowledged the existence of triable disputes, making the subsequent summary decree under Order XII Rule 6 inappropriate
¶ 42The Court found the High Court's exercise of Section 115 CPC jurisdiction flawed as it substituted its own interpretation of pleadings for that of the Trial Court without identifying a jurisdictional error
¶ 4405Holding
The Court held that a decree on admission is an exception to the rule of full adjudication and cannot be granted when admissions are not categorical or require inferential reasoning
¶ 45-46The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the Delhi High Court's judgment and restoring the Trial Court's order; the suit was remanded to the Trial Court for independent adjudication on merits
¶ 48-49, 50Original Court PDF
PushpavsDayawati
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
