01Facts
The plaintiff and his brothers purchased the suit property under a registered sale deed dated 24.11.2004, were mutated in revenue records, and paid tax to the BBMP.
¶ 4They erected a temporary iron-rod structure on it. The plaintiff alleged that BBMP officials threatened demolition, and he issued a notice under Section 482(1) of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, 1976 ("KMC Act") on 06.08.2019, received by BBMP on 08.08.2019.
¶ 5He then sued in O.S. No. 26289/2019 for perpetual prohibitory injunction, alleging that BBMP was demolishing the structure without due process.
¶ 5BBMP contended that it had issued a notice under Section 308 of the KMC Act calling for documents and removal of the illegal structure, that the plaintiff had received it, and that the suit was not maintainable.
¶ 6–7The Trial Court framed issues on threats and interference, maintainability, non-joinder, and entitlement to injunction.
¶ 8The plaintiff examined himself (P.W.1). BBMP led no evidence but confronted the plaintiff with its notice, Ex. D1.
¶ 9The Trial Court held that there was no acknowledgment or other evidence of service of Ex. D1, so no proceedings under the KMC Act could be initiated. It decreed a blanket permanent injunction restraining demolition and interference.
¶ 10–11BBMP appealed.
¶ 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court was correct in holding that BBMP had not issued a show cause notice under Section 308 of the KMC Act.
¶ 18(i)ii.2. Whether the Trial Court was justified in granting a decree for permanent injunction without recognising that BBMP was at liberty to act by due process of law.
¶ 18(ii)iii.3. Whether the judgment and decree of the Trial Court required modification.
¶ 18(iii)03Law Applied
The burden of proof for service of a statutory notice lies on the authority asserting that the notice was served.
¶ 20A municipal authority empowered under the KMC Act to act against unauthorised or illegal construction may do so only through lawful process, so an injunction must not stop it from acting lawfully.
¶ 22The parties relied on Section 308 of the KMC Act (notice for removal of unauthorised structures) and Section 482(1) of the KMC Act (pre-suit notice).
¶ 5, 6, 13BBMP relied on Section 9 CPC (implied bar) and Section 248 of the BBMP Act, 2020.
¶ 12–14The Division Bench ruling in Chief Commissioner Another v. Smt. Smita Vijay, W.A. No. 1301/2023 (16.09.2025), which set aside the single-judge order in Smt. Kavitha Jain v. Commissioner, BBMP, W.P. No. 9934/2023, was cited.
¶ 17The court did not quote the text of these provisions or analyse them in detail.
Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96Section 41Section 9
KARNATAKA MUNICIPAL CORPORATIONS ACT, 1976. Section 482Section 308
04Reasoning
Although Ex. D1 was addressed to the plaintiff, it bore no signature or acknowledgment from him or the co-owners showing receipt, so BBMP failed to discharge its burden. The Trial Court's finding was therefore affirmed.
¶ 20–21The court accepted that BBMP was empowered to act against unauthorised construction under the statute, so non-service of the notice did not extinguish that power. A blanket injunction against demolition "in any form" would therefore curtail lawful statutory action, although the Trial Court was right to grant prohibitory relief against action without due process.
¶ 22The court modified the decree to preserve the injunction only until BBMP follows due process, while leaving BBMP free to proceed lawfully. Issue 3 followed from that reasoning.
¶ 22–23The court also made observations on the nomenclature of the "Greater Bengaluru Governance Act, 2024" and recommended that the Government consider Kannada names for the enactment. These observations were not part of the adjudication.
¶ 24–2805Holding
The court answered Point (i) in the affirmative, holding that the Trial Court correctly found no proof of service of the Section 308 notice.
¶ 21, 23The court answered Point (ii) in the negative, holding that the blanket injunction was not justified in that form.
¶ 22The court answered Point (iii) in the partly affirmative.
¶ 23The RFA was allowed in part and the decree modified. BBMP is restrained from demolishing the structure or interfering with the plaintiff's possession unless due process of law is taken. The injunction continues until BBMP passes an order and takes action in accordance with law, and other observations of the Trial Court are not to bar that process.
¶ 29(ii)–(iii)The Registrar General was directed to forward the observations at paras. 24–28 to the Chief Secretary and the Minister for Kannada and Culture, Government of Karnataka.
¶ 29(iv)Original Court PDF
BRUHATH BANGALORE MAHANAGARA PALIKEvsMR. T JAYASHANKARA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
