01Facts
The appellant, aged 76, claims to be a family member of the original grantee, Smt. Harijana Huligemma, in respect of Sy. No. 128/3 (2 acres 85 cents) in Sankalapura Village, Hospet Taluk, granted under an order of 1950–51.
¶ 2.1The grantee allegedly executed a Will in the appellant's favour on 20.04.1984 and died in 1987.
¶ 2.1 · ¶ 7The grantee's son sold the land to Respondents 3 and 4 on 30.03.1993.
¶ 2.1 · ¶ 7The appellant applied under Section 5(1) of the Karnataka SC/ST (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978 ("the 1978 Act") for resumption, claiming the sale was void. The application was registered in 2007.
¶ 2.2The Assistant Commissioner dismissed the application on 21.06.2008, and the Deputy Commissioner affirmed on 26.10.2009.
¶ 2.3 · ¶ 7The learned Single Judge dismissed Writ Petition No. 85723 of 2013 on 08.10.2021, holding that the land was ryotwari patta land, not "granted land," and that the challenge was delayed and the appellant had not approached with clean hands.
¶ 7The appellant contended he was unaware of the 1993 sale and that a pending application (IA No. 1 of 2017) was never considered.
¶ 3The Court noted the appellant is a signatory to the 1993 sale deed.
¶ 4 · ¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the land, granted under a ryotwari patta under the 1948 Act, qualifies as "granted land" under Section 3(1)(b) of the 1978 Act.
¶ 7 (quoting SJ paras 6–11) · ¶ 8ii.2. Whether the application under Section 5 of the 1978 Act to annul the 1993 sale is liable to be rejected for unreasonable delay, laches, and unclean hands, even if the land were granted land.
¶ 7 (quoting SJ paras 12–17) · ¶ 8–9iii.3. Whether the Single Judge's failure to expressly consider IA No. 1 of 2017 warrants remand.
¶ 3 · ¶ 10–1103Law Applied
The Court relied on Sections 3(1)(b), 4 and 5 of the 1978 Act, which define "granted land" and provide for annulment of transfers and resumption.
¶ 7The Court applied the Full Bench decision in Mohammed Jaffar, holding that occupancy rights conferred by a Land Tribunal are declarations of pre-existing rights and therefore not "granted land."
¶ 7, SJ para. 9The Court followed the Co-ordinate Bench decision in Gowramma, holding that grants under the Mysore (Religious and Charitable) Inams Abolition Act, 1955 recognise pre-existing rights and are not "granted land."
¶ 7, SJ para. 10The Court applied State of Tamil Nadu on the nature of ryotwari settlement under the 1948 Act, where a pre-existing claim is adjudicated.
¶ 7, SJ paras. 7–8On limitation, the Court relied on Nekkanti Rama Lakshmi, holding that Section 5 prescribes no period but action must be taken within reasonable time, and overruling contrary High Court decisions.
¶ 7, SJ para. 14The Court applied Vivek M. Hinduja, extending the reasonable-time requirement to suo motu action.
¶ 7, SJ para. 15The Court referred to the Division Bench decisions in Srinivas Murthy and Muniraju v. Sheik Hyder on rejection of belated applications.
¶ 7, SJ paras. 16–17A pending application not considered after dismissal of the writ petition does not survive.
¶ 10–1104Reasoning
The Court first accepted the Single Judge's finding that the impugned grant was a ryotwari patta under the 1948 Act, which adjudicates a pre-existing claim, so the land falls outside "granted land" under Section 3(1)(b). Even assuming the land was granted land, the Court held the challenge was barred. The sale occurred on 30.03.1993, but the application was filed in 2007, a delay of about 14 years, which is unreasonable under Nekkanti Rama Lakshmi and Vivek M. Hinduja. The appellant's claim of ignorance was rejected because he is a named signatory to the sale deed, and the appellant could not "put the clock back" after 14 years of the respondents' possession. The Court therefore treated the appellant's approach as lacking clean hands.
¶ 8 · ¶ 7, SJ paras. 12–15 · ¶ 9On IA No. 1 of 2017, the Court accepted that the Single Judge's failure to deal with it was an inadvertent omission. Since the writ petition itself failed, the pending application could not survive, so no remand was needed.
¶ 10–1105Holding
The Court held that the subject land is not "granted land" under Section 3(1)(b) of the 1978 Act, because it was granted as ryotwari patta recognising a pre-existing right. Even if it were granted land, the Section 5 application was barred by unreasonable delay of about 14 years and the appellant's lack of clean hands.
¶ 7, SJ para. 11 · ¶ 8 · ¶ 7, SJ paras. 12–16The Court found no ground for interference and dismissed the Writ Appeal, affirming the Single Judge's order dated 08.10.2021 in WP No. 85723 of 2013. The pending IA No. 1 of 2017 and all other pending applications were disposed of as not surviving.
¶ 8 · ¶ 10–11 · ¶ 11Original Court PDF
HANUMANTHAPPA S/O DODDA GALEMMAvsTHE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
