01Facts
In 1957, land in Survey Nos. 628/A and 628/B at Huvina Hadagali, Ballari District, was granted to Talwar Hanumappa and his daughter, Lesi Huligemma, under orders dated 06.11.1957 and 07.01.1969. The grant was made to the petitioners' ancestors.
¶ 4.1On 16.12.1972, Huligemma sold the property to M.S. Venkobanna by registered sale deed. She is said to have executed a Will in favour of the petitioners' father, H. Kalanagouda, on 18.07.1998.
¶ 4.1In PTCL No. 37/1990-91, the Assistant Commissioner, Hosapete, under Section 5(B) of the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978, declared the sale deed null and void on 16.12.1992. The land was directed to be resumed and granted to other needy SC/ST persons.
¶ 4.2The petitioners have filed O.S. No. 190 of 2017 seeking a permanent injunction against the respondents.
¶ 5Respondents 5 to 9, claiming to be Huligemma's legal heirs, challenged the 1992 order before the Deputy Commissioner (Appeal/PTCL/104/2022-23) without impleading the petitioners. The appeal was dismissed on 21.12.2023.
¶ 5On review, the Deputy Commissioner set aside the 1992 order only insofar as it concerned grant to other needy SC/ST persons and remanded to the Assistant Commissioner.
¶ 5On remand, the Assistant Commissioner re-granted the land to the private respondents and directed the Tahsildar to effect RTC changes (Impugned Order, PTCL/04/2024, dated 30.05.2025, Annexure J).
¶ 5The petitioners challenged the re-grant in PTCL No. 07/2025 before the Deputy Commissioner, contending they were not parties to the earlier proceedings. That appeal was dismissed on 02.04.2026, with the observation that parties are bound by the outcome of the pending civil suit (Impugned Order, Annexure L).
¶ 5–6The petitioners filed this writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution seeking certiorari against both orders.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Deputy Commissioner was justified in dismissing the petitioners' appeal (PTCL No. 07/2025) despite their non-impleadment in the earlier proceedings, given the disputed questions of legal heirship and the validity of the Will.
¶ 8ii.2. Whether this Court, in exercise of its writ jurisdiction, should interfere with the impugned orders dated 02.04.2026 and 30.05.2025, or leave the parties to the pending civil suit.
¶ 7, 903Law Applied
Section 5(B) of the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978, under which the Assistant Commissioner may declare an alienation null and void and resume land for re-grant to other needy SC/ST persons.
¶ 4.2Counsel for the petitioners submitted that a Will must be proved under the Indian Succession Act, 1925, read with the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, and that legal heirship is a matter for the competent Civil Court.
¶ 7Where legal heirship and title are disputed, adjudication belongs to the competent Civil Court, and revenue entries are subject to the declaration of parties' rights by that Court.
¶ 8, 10Pending adjudication, parties must maintain status quo and create no third-party rights.
¶ 10Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution define the scope of the writ jurisdiction invoked.
¶ 1Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA SCHEDULED CASTES AND SCHEDULED TRIBES (PROHIBITION OF TRANSFER OF CERTAIN LANDS) ACT, 1978 Section 5
04Reasoning
The petitioners' title depends on a Will allegedly executed by Huligemma and on their status as her legal heirs. Both matters are contested and must be proved before the Civil Court.
¶ 7, 8Because the factual dispute on legal heirship could not be resolved in writ proceedings, the Deputy Commissioner correctly dismissed the appeal, even if the petitioners were not arrayed as parties earlier.
¶ 8Because the petitioners' own suit (O.S. No. 190 of 2017) was pending on the same question, the Court declined to interfere with the Deputy Commissioner's order and held that the parties would be bound by the outcome of that suit.
¶ 9The revenue authorities' RTC entries are provisional and subject to the Civil Court's determination.
¶ 10To protect the disputed property pending that determination, the Court directed status quo.
¶ 10The Court did not decide the merits of the Will or the validity of the 1992 and 2025 orders.
05Holding
Disputed questions of legal heirship and the Will's validity must be decided by the competent Civil Court, and the Deputy Commissioner rightly dismissed the appeal.
¶ 8The Court found no ground to interfere with the Deputy Commissioner's order and held that the parties are bound by the result of the pending suit.
¶ 9The writ petition was disposed of with the following directions: (i) revenue entries in the RTC are subject to the Civil Court's declaration of rights; and (ii) both parties must maintain status quo over the disputed properties and create no third-party rights until the suit is decided. The petition was disposed of accordingly, and no separate relief was granted to either side.
¶ 10Original Court PDF
HALAMMA W/O LATE KALANAGOUDAvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
