01Facts
The petitioners (legal heirs of L. Muthappa and H.M. Bhagavan) owned Sy. Nos. 16/3 (39 guntas) and 21/1A (16 guntas) at Hulimavu Village, Begur Hobli, Bengaluru South Taluk
¶ 2(i) · p. 6The BDA issued a preliminary notification under Section 17 of the BDA Act, 1976 on 08.09.1987 for the BTM VI Stage Layout, covering 524 acres 9 guntas in Hulimavu
¶ 2(i) · pp. 6-7A final notification followed on 28.07.1990 covering 388 acres 9 guntas
¶ 2(i) · pp. 6-7The petitioners contended that BDA never took possession, and that the scheme was not implemented within five years, so the acquisition lapsed under Section 27 of the BDA Act
¶ 2(ii) · pp. 7-8Their earlier writ petitions (W.P. Nos. 25277-25280/2012) were dismissed on 06.02.2013 as belated, on the basis of BDA's statement that possession was taken on 22.03.1994. The writ appeals (W.A. Nos. 2097-2100/2013) were also dismissed on 21.11.2013
¶ 2(ii) · pp. 8-9The petitioners then relied on the Right to Fair Compensation Act, 2013 (effective 01.01.2014), particularly Section 24(2), and on later de-notifications, quashing orders and abandonment endorsements affecting neighbouring lands
¶ 2(iii) · pp. 9-10 · ¶ 2(v) · pp. 12-14BDA maintained that it took possession on 16.11.1993/22.03.1994, issued a Section 16(2) notification on 16.06.1994, and formed a layout with allotments
¶ 3(ii) · pp. 15-16 · ¶ 4(i)-(ii) · pp. 17-20Respondent Nos. 3-5 are allottees and are in possession and/or constructing on Sites 508 and 509
¶ 4(i)-(ii) · pp. 17-2002Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioners are barred by res judicata from again contending that the acquisition has lapsed under Section 27 of the BDA Act, having lost the same ground in W.P. Nos. 25277-25280/2012 and the connected writ appeals
¶ 11 · pp. 28-29ii.2. Whether the challenge to the acquisition under Section 27 of the BDA Act is a continuing cause of action permitting repeated challenges
¶ 11 · pp. 28-29iii.3. Whether the petitioners are in possession of Sy. Nos. 16/3 and 21/1A so as to sustain a lapse claim
¶ 12 · pp. 29-30iv.4. Whether the acquisition lapsed under Section 24(2) of the Right to Fair Compensation Act, 2013, for non-payment of compensation and non-taking of possession, given that the acquisition was under the BDA Act
¶ 12 · pp. 29-31 · ¶ 14(iii) · p. 32v.5. Whether the BTM VI Stage scheme has been implemented in respect of Sy. Nos. 16/3 and 21/1A, such that the acquisition cannot be assailed on the ground of lapse
¶ 14(ii) · pp. 31-32vi.6. Whether the petitioners, as landowners not having challenged the acquisition before 1989, are entitled to an incentive site under the BDA (Incentive Scheme for Voluntary Surrender of Land) Rules, 1989
¶ 13 · p. 31 · ¶ 14(iv) · p. 3303Law Applied
Section 27 of the BDA Act provides that acquisition lapses where a scheme is not implemented within the prescribed period; the Supreme Court in Offshore Holdings (P) Ltd. v. BDA (2011) 3 SCC 139, read with Section 36, holds that a scheme lapse does not automatically lapse the acquisition, a question of fact and circumstance
¶ 9 · p. 27 · ¶ 2(ii) · p. 8The doctrine of res judicata bars re-agitation of a ground already decided against a party, and the Court applied it to the petitioners' earlier dismissed writs
¶ 11 · pp. 28-29Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act operates only on acquisitions under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894; the Division Bench's holding, following Bangalore Development Authority v. R. Hanumaiah (2005) 12 SCC 508, is that acquisition under the BDA Act is incidental to town planning and outside the 2013 Act
¶ 12 · pp. 29-31 · ¶ 14(iii) · p. 32Under the BDA (Incentive Scheme for Voluntary Surrender of Land) Rules, 1989, landowners who had not challenged acquisition by 1989 are entitled to an incentive site
¶ 13 · p. 31The petitioners' reliance on Bondu Ramaswamy v. BDA (2010) 7 SCC 129 and Commissioner, BDA v. State of Karnataka ILR 2006 KAR 318 for the proposition that lands around the subject land being de-notified or excluded supports a lapse argument was not accepted in the form advanced
¶ 2(v) · pp. 12-14 · ¶ 6 · pp. 23-24Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 Section 24
04Reasoning
The Court first held that the petitioners' earlier writs, which were dismissed on the same Section 27 lapse ground, and the dismissal of the appeals, bar them by res judicata
¶ 11 · pp. 28-29It rejected the reliance on the Co-ordinate Bench decision in W.P. No. 55159/2014 that the cause of action is continuing, observing that the Section 27 cause of action arose on expiry of five years after the final notification and cannot be revived by successive writs
¶ 11 · p. 29On possession, the Court relied on the documents and photographs produced by Respondent Nos. 3-5, showing that BDA formed a layout, roads and amenities on the subject survey numbers and allotted sites. It found the petitioners' claim of continuing possession untenable
¶ 12 · pp. 29-30On the 2013 Act, the Court held that the Division Bench had settled that the Act does not apply to BDA acquisitions, so the Section 24(2) plea failed even though the petitioners framed it as a fresh cause of action
¶ 12 · pp. 29-31The Court then declared that the scheme had been implemented in respect of these survey numbers, which disposed of the Section 27 lapse argument on the merits as well
¶ 14(ii) · pp. 31-32Finally, because the petitioners had not challenged the acquisition by 1989, the Court held them entitled to the incentive site under the 1989 Rules, relying on its earlier order in W.P. No. 10936/2016
¶ 13 · p. 3105Holding
The Court held that the petitioners are barred by res judicata from re-agitating the Section 27 lapse ground and that a Section 27 challenge is not a continuing cause of action
¶ 11 · pp. 28-29It held that possession rests with BDA and that the layout has been formed, so the petitioners' possession claim fails
¶ 12 · pp. 29-30It held that the 2013 Act, including Section 24(2), does not apply to acquisitions under the BDA Act
¶ 12 · pp. 30-31 · ¶ 14(iii) · p. 32The Court upheld the validity of the preliminary notification dated 08.09.1987 and the final notification dated 28.07.1990 insofar as they relate to Sy. Nos. 16/3 and 21/1A
¶ 14(i) · p. 32It declared that the BTM VI Stage scheme is implemented for these lands, so the petitioners cannot assail the notifications on the ground of lapse
¶ 14(ii) · pp. 31-32The writ petition was disposed of with a direction that BDA allot an incentive site to the petitioners, who own 1 acre 11 guntas in these survey numbers, under the 1989 Rules, preferably in the same or a nearby layout
¶ 14(iv) · p. 33Original Court PDF
SMT SUBBAMMA (SINCE DECEASED)vsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
