01Facts
The Deputy Commissioner, Kalaburagi, granted 4 acres 20 guntas in Survey No. 8, Neelur Tanda, Afzalpur Taluk, to the father of Respondent No. 4 by order dated 01.10.1980.
¶ 5The grantee alienated the land to Respondent No. 7 (the petitioner's brother) by registered sale deed dated 06.07.1992.
¶ 5The petitioner claims the land under a partition that allotted it to him.
¶ 2The grantee filed O.S. No. 5/2014 for declaration, which was dismissed on 23.08.2017.
¶ 5About 22 years after the sale, the grantee filed an application under Section 5 of the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978 ("the Act") seeking cancellation of the sale deed and restoration of possession.
¶ 2, 5The Assistant Commissioner, Kalaburagi, allowed the application on 04.07.2025, declared the sale void and ordered restoration.
¶ 5The Deputy Commissioner dismissed the petitioner's appeal on 29.10.2025.
¶ 5, 9The petitioner challenged both orders under Article 226.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the grantee's application under Section 5 of the Act, filed approximately 22 years after the alienation, was within a reasonable period and could be entertained.
¶ 6ii.2. Whether the grantee could avoid the delay by alleging breach of the 15-year prohibition on alienation in the grant and fraud in the sale.
¶ 7iii.3. Whether the 2011 amendment to the Act removes any limitation for proceedings under Section 5.
¶ 3, 803Law Applied
Section 5 of the Act provides the mechanism for restoring granted land transferred in breach of the grant conditions.
¶ 3, 5Erappa v. Assistant Commissioner, Koppal (W.A. No. 100265/2023, dated 23.06.2023) and Smt. Devamma v. Deputy Commissioner, Mysore (W.A. No. 880/2023, dated 23.02.2026), Division Bench decisions, hold that such proceedings filed after an unreasonable delay cannot be entertained.
¶ 2, 6, 7Smt. Gouramma @ Gangamma v. Deputy Commissioner, Haveri (W.A. No. 100101/2024, dated 29.07.2024) holds that the statutory amendment does not assist a grantee seeking relief beyond a reasonable time.
¶ 804Reasoning
The grantee's application was filed more than 22 years after the 1992 sale, a delay the court treated as admitted and squarely covered by Erappa and Devamma.
¶ 6The grantee's assertions of a breach of the 15-year bar on alienation and of fraud did not alter the analysis, because the belated initiation of proceedings for cancellation, declaration, and restoration was itself beyond a reasonable period.
¶ 7The court rejected the contention that the amendment to the Act removes limitation, relying on Gouramma.
¶ 8The court's reasoning rests on delay alone, and it did not examine the merits of the fraud allegation or the grant condition.
¶ 6, 7Because the impugned orders were passed on an application that should not have been entertained, they could not stand.
¶ 6, 905Holding
A Section 5 application filed after an unexplained delay of over 22 years is not maintainable as within a reasonable period.
¶ 6Allegations of fraud or breach of grant condition do not cure that delay.
¶ 7The 2011 amendment does not revive such claims.
¶ 8The writ petition is allowed. The Assistant Commissioner's order dated 04.07.2025 (Annexure-D) and the Deputy Commissioner's order dated 29.10.2025 (Annexure-G) are set aside, with no order as to costs.
¶ 9Original Court PDF
TAVARUvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
