01Facts
The plaintiffs sued for a declaration that they were owners in possession of 5 acres 23 guntas in Sy. Nos. 162/1B/1 and 162/1B/2 of Sarwad village (the ABEF portion), with a claim that the ABGF portion (1 acre 24 guntas) formed part of their land, and for a consequential perpetual injunction against Defendants 1 and 2.
¶ 3Their case was that Ishwarappa (plaintiffs' predecessor) and Girimallappa, sons of Muttappa, orally partitioned the land in 1966, recorded through a waradi and mutation (ME No. 8043).
¶ 3The defendants pleaded that the suit was barred by limitation, that the plaintiffs were not in possession, and that Girimallappa had purchased 1 acre 24 guntas from Ishwarappa in 1983 with possession delivered and revenue records rectified.
¶ 4Defendant No. 4 claimed to be a bona fide purchaser for value of Sy. No. 162/3.
¶ 6The Trial Court framed issues and two additional issues.
¶ 7, 9On additional issue framing, the Trial Court dismissed the suit.
¶ 9, 10The First Appellate Court affirmed the dismissal.
¶ 10, 11In the Trial Court, PW-1 admitted in cross-examination that the plaintiffs were not in possession and that Defendant No. 4's name was entered in the record of rights.
¶ 17The respondents were unrepresented in this Court.
¶ 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the findings of the Courts below that the plaintiffs failed to prove title over the suit property, and that Ex. P10 (mutation based on the 1966 waradi) did not support their claim, are perverse?
¶ 15, Substantial Question 1ii.2. Whether the First Appellate Court erred in not examining the plaintiffs' grievance regarding the additional issues framed after trial, without relegating the parties to further evidence?
¶ 15, Substantial Question 2iii.3. Whether both Courts erred in conferring title on the defendant based on a waradi given to revenue officials, when immovable property valued above Rs. 100 cannot be transferred by waradi?
¶ 15, Substantial Question 3iv.4. Whether a suit for declaration of title and perpetual injunction, without seeking the consequential relief of possession under the proviso to Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, is maintainable in light of Vasantha (Dead) through LRs v. Rajalakshmi alias Rajam (2024) 5 SCC 282?
¶ 16, Additional Substantial Question03Law Applied
The Court applied the proviso to Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, which bars a court from granting a declaration of title where the plaintiff, being able to seek further relief than a mere declaration, omits to do so.
¶ 18The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Vasantha (Dead) through LRs v. Rajalakshmi alias Rajam (2024) 5 SCC 282 as the governing authority that a declaration suit by a plaintiff out of possession, without a consequential prayer for possession, is not maintainable.
¶ 18The Trial Court's reasoning reflected the requirement of seeking possession where the plaintiff is out of possession.
¶ 17No other statutory provision or precedent was discussed in the judgment on the remaining substantial questions, including the waradi and registration point, the perversity standard, or the additional-issues procedure.
Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Specific Relief Act, 1963 Section 34
04Reasoning
The Court found the additional substantial question dispositive. The Trial Court had recorded PW-1's admission that the plaintiffs were out of possession and that Defendant No. 4's name was in the record of rights for the suit land, and that the plaintiffs had not sought possession despite knowing that Defendant No. 4 was in possession.
¶ 17Applying Section 34's proviso and Vasantha, the Court held that a declaration of title without a prayer for possession, where the plaintiffs are out of possession, is not maintainable.
¶ 18, 19The Court noted that the record showed no objection by the plaintiffs' father to the 1983 entry in Sy. No. 162/3, though he was alive until 1999.
¶ 17The Court found no error in the concurrent judgments of the Courts below.
¶ 19Because the suit was held not maintainable, the Court did not address the original substantial questions on title, perversity, additional issues, or waradi.
¶ 21The judgment states at para. 19 that "Defendant No.1 is in possession," whereas para. 17 identifies Defendant No. 4 as the party in possession; the holding does not depend on this discrepancy.
¶ 17, 1905Holding
The Court answered the additional substantial question in the negative, holding that the suit for declaration of title and perpetual injunction without a prayer for possession is not maintainable.
¶ 19, 20The Court did not answer Substantial Questions 1 to 3 as they did not arise for consideration.
¶ 21The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed, the judgments and decrees of the Trial Court (O.S. No. 175/2006, dated 23.02.2010) and the First Appellate Court (R.A. No. 47/2010, dated 30.06.2014) are confirmed, and no order as to costs is made.
¶ 22Original Court PDF
HANAMANTH S/O ISHWARAPPA PARADI AND ORSvsMALLIKARJUN S/O GIRIMALLAPPA PARADDI AND ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
