01Facts
Shankrappa V. Mugad (Respondent No. 2 in the Writ Appeals; Petitioner No. 2 before the Single Judge) was elected a Director of Shivalli Milk Producer Co-operative Society ("Shivalli Society"), a primary society, for a five-year term from 06.01.2020.
¶ 6He was elected Director of the Dharwad, Gadag and Uttara Kannada District Milk Producers' Co-operative Union Ltd. ("Apex Society") as Shivalli Society's representative on 30.06.2024, and became its President on 12.07.2024.
¶ 6The five-year term of the Shivalli Society Board ended on 05.01.2025.
¶ 6 · ¶ 25Between 2024 and 2025 the Shivalli Society election was repeatedly stayed and deferred through multiple proceedings.
¶ 6On 02.06.2025, the Assistant Registrar disqualified the Shivalli Board under s. 29-C of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 ("KCS Act").
¶ 6Mugad's side asserted that a stay of that order was granted on 30.06.2025; the State denied it, and the interim order could not be traced in the original file.
¶ 6On 03.07.2025 the Deputy Commissioner treated the Apex Society post as vacant and appointed a Returning Officer; this Court stayed further proceedings on 07.07.2025.
¶ 6Mugad was re-elected to the Shivalli Board on 22.09.2025, and the Shivalli Board on 03.10.2025 resolved to continue him as its representative in the Apex Society.
¶ 6, 36On 30.10.2025 the Apex Society issued notice for an urgent board meeting on 03.11.2025 to co-opt a Director to the vacant Dharwad/Alnavar/Navalgund/Annigeri seat under s. 29-E.
¶ 6Shivalli Society and Mugad challenged that notice in W.P. No. 108123/2025.
¶ 4 · ¶ 6The learned Single Judge on 15.12.2025 quashed the notice, restored status quo ante, dismissed W.P. No. 104391/2025 as not surviving, and directed an inquiry into the missing interim order.
¶ 6The Union and Sri Neelakanth Asuti (an impleading applicant) appealed.
¶ 6A Division Bench stayed the Single Judge's order subject to further orders on 10.03.2026.
¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether Mugad's directorship in the Apex Society ceased on 05.01.2025 under s. 18-B of the KCS Act upon the end of his term as Director of the primary society, thereby creating a casual vacancy.
¶ 23 · ¶ 25 · ¶ 27–29 · ¶ 37ii.2. Whether the subsequent amendment (Act No. 73 of 2025, effective 12.09.2025) substituting "Member" for "Director" in s. 2(e-1-a), and the Explanation to s. 21, affects that cessation.
¶ 30–35iii.3. Whether Mugad's re-election on 22.09.2025 and the Shivalli Board resolution of 03.10.2025 revived or continued his Apex Society directorship.
¶ 36 · ¶ 37iv.4. Whether the pendency of s. 29-C disqualification proceedings and the disputed interim stay bar the process of filling the vacancy.
¶ 38–41v.5. Whether the Single Judge erred in quashing the co-option notice and restoring status quo ante.
¶ 40–4303Law Applied
Section 18-B of the KCS Act provides that a Director of an Apex Society who represents another co-operative society "shall cease to be a Director of such co-operative society forthwith" if he ceases to be a Director of the society he represents.
¶ 27 · ¶ 28The principle, relied on from H.S. Mohan Reddy v. State of Karnataka, is that the Apex Society directorship of a representative is co-terminus with his primary society directorship, and that s. 18-B operates on the occurrence of specified events, not as a disqualification.
¶ 29, quoting paras. 65–67 · ¶ 39, referring to para. 30Section 2(e-1-a) (definition of "Delegate," as amended by Act No. 73 of 2025) and the Explanation to s. 21 operate on the manner of voting and cannot override s. 18-B.
¶ 31–33Section 6A of the Karnataka General Clauses Act, 1899 preserves consequences that have already accrued under a provision against later amendment.
¶ 34The disqualification regime under s. 29-C has different legal consequences from s. 18-B, and its proceedings remain pending.
¶ 38–39The co-option power under s. 29-E, as amended, is the mechanism for filling the resulting casual vacancy.
¶ 6 · ¶ 44Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
KARNATAKA CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT, 1959. Section 106Section 18Section 2Section 21
04Reasoning
The cessation of Mugad's Apex Society directorship under s. 18-B became effective "forthwith" on 05.01.2025, when his primary society term expired.
¶ 25, 28, 37The amendment substituting "Member" for "Director" in s. 2(e-1-a) came into force on 12.09.2025, after that date, and could not be applied to alter accrued legal consequences. The court therefore did not need to decide the merits of the "Delegate" definition.
¶ 31, 34, 35Even if the Explanation to s. 21 were read as enabling a member to represent a society, s. 18-B governs the existence of directorship itself, while s. 21 governs the exercise of voting rights; the two operate in different spheres.
¶ 33The re-election of Mugad as a primary society Director on 22.09.2025 and the 03.10.2025 resolution could not revive the Apex Society directorship. The Apex Society post had become vacant on 05.01.2025, and the later election only made him eligible to contest afresh.
¶ 37The disqualification proceedings, the disputed stay, and the pending appeal did not bar the filling of the vacancy. The vacancy arose from s. 18-B, which is independent of the s. 29-C proceedings, and the correctness of the alleged stay was of "academic interest" for this purpose.
¶ 38–39, 41The Single Judge had relied on the stay of the s. 29-C proceedings to hold that no vacancy existed, without considering the independent operation of s. 18-B. The Single Judge's reasoning on this point lacked sufficient reasons and did not address the s. 18-B contention.
¶ 40, 42, 4305Holding
Mugad's directorship in the Apex Society ceased "forthwith" on 05.01.2025 under s. 18-B of the KCS Act, creating a casual vacancy. The subsequent amendment to s. 2(e-1-a) and the re-election of 22.09.2025 did not revive his directorship. The pending s. 29-C proceedings do not bar filling the vacancy.
¶ 37–39, 41, 43Both Writ Appeals (Nos. 100006/2026 and 100025/2026) were allowed. W.P. No. 108123/2025 was dismissed, and the court directed that necessary steps be taken forthwith to fill the vacancies in the posts of Director and President of the Apex Society. The interim order of 10.03.2026, which made any co-opted or elected representative subject to the outcome of the appeals, is not expressly addressed in the operative paragraph.
¶ 44 · ¶ 6Original Court PDF
DHARWAD, GADAG AND UTTARA KANNADA DISTRICTvsSHIVALLI MILK PRODUCER CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY SHIVALLI
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
