Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Couple Teachers Lose Bid for Kumta Posting as Court Says Spouse Posting Guidelines Confer No Enforceable Right

SHRI. ULLAS S/O SUBBAIAH NAIKv.THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

Couple Teachers Lose Bid for Kumta Posting as Court Says Spouse Posting Guidelines Confer No Enforceable Right. SHRI. ULLAS S/O SUBBAIAH NAIK vs THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the KSAT erred in holding that the petitioners' transfer/posting to Bhatkal taluk was in accordance with the Act and Rules, 2020, and was not in violation of Guidelines No. 10 and 15(3).

The court held

The impugned KSAT order did not suffer from any legal infirmity warranting interference.

It also directed

The spouse/couple guidelines do not confer an enforceable right to a particular posting, and the petitioners' posting at Bhatkal was consistent with the Act and Rules, 2020.

The medical grounds raised for the first time were not adjudicated and are for the competent authority.

The writ petition is dismissed, and the KSAT order dated 04.08.2025 in Application Nos. 10470–10471/2025 is affirmed.

01Facts

The petitioners, a married couple, are Primary School Assistant Teachers. They were posted as Block Resource Persons (BRP-Primary) in Kumta taluk on 04.05.2016.

¶ 2

Under Section 8(2) of the Karnataka Civil Service (Regulation of Transfer of Teachers) Amendment Act, 2020 ("the Act"), the tenure in a specified post is 3 to 5 years. The petitioners completed the maximum five-year tenure by 03.05.2021 and, on that basis, claimed retention in Kumta for teaching posts.

¶ 2

The petitioners challenged a memorandum dated 07.12.2021 before the KSAT. The KSAT admitted the applications, and the petitioners reported to schools in Bhatkal taluk, subject to the outcome.

¶ 2

While the petitioners were at Bhatkal, ten teaching posts fell vacant at Kumta. The petitioners sought posting to those vacancies, and the KSAT directed the respondents to consider their representation.

¶ 2

The respondents issued an endorsement dated 17.11.2022, stating that the petitioners' case had been considered under the one-time measure in the Karnataka State Civil Services (Regulation of Transfer of Teachers) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2021, and that no provision permitted transfer to current vacancies at Kumta. Contempt proceedings were dropped with liberty to challenge the endorsement.

¶ 2

The KSAT dismissed the challenge (Application Nos. 10470–10471/2025, order dated 04.08.2025). It held that (i) the one-time measure applied only to the 2019–20 compulsory transfer counselling; (ii) the petitioners had, after completing their BRP tenure, chosen Bhatkal in counselling under Rule 15(1) of the Karnataka Civil Services (Regulation of Transfer of Teachers) Rules, 2020 ("the Rules, 2020"); and (iii) under Section 11 of the Act, no manual counselling was permissible.

¶ 2

The petitioners filed a memo with medical certificates of petitioner No. 2 and her son to support their request for posting at Kumta.

¶ 5, 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether the KSAT erred in holding that the petitioners' transfer/posting to Bhatkal taluk was in accordance with the Act and Rules, 2020, and was not in violation of Guidelines No. 10 and 15(3).

¶ 5 · ¶ 7–8

ii.2. Whether the petitioners, as spouses who completed maximum tenure as BRPs, possess an enforceable right to posting at Kumta taluk under the spouse/couple guidelines.

¶ 10–12

iii.3. Whether medical grounds produced for the first time before the High Court can be appraised by the writ court to justify a change of posting.

¶ 9, 14

03Law Applied

The Court relied on the Act, specifically Section 8(2) (tenure of three to five years in specified posts) and Section 11 (no manual counselling once regular counselling is complete).

¶ 2

The Court applied Rule 15(1) and Rule 15(3) of the Rules, 2020, which provide that teachers in specified posts are transferred through counselling on completion of maximum tenure and that priority orders form the basis of counselling.

¶ 2, 7, 8

The Court referred to Guidelines No. 10 and 15(3), which provide for exemptions and priorities such as spouse-employment claims.

¶ 7

The Court treated the Ordinance's one-time measure (Sections 2 and 10) as limited in scope.

¶ 2, 6

The settled rule applied is that transfer is an incident of service, that no employee has a vested right to a particular place, and that interference is warranted only for mala fides, violation of the Rules or Act, or lack of jurisdiction.

¶ 10

Shilpi Bose (Mrs) & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors., 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659, and Union of India & Ors. v. S.L. Abbas, 1993 (4) SCC 357, hold that spouse-posting guidelines issued by executive instructions are to be considered subject to administrative exigencies and vacancy availability and do not confer enforceable rights to a particular posting.

¶ 11

A writ court cannot appraise medical evidence for the purpose of altering a posting, which is a matter for the competent authority.

¶ 14

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

KARNATAKA STATE CIVIL SERVICES (PROHIBITON OF ABSORPTION OF THE SERVICES OF THE EMPLOYEES OF ESTABLISHMENTS IN PUBLIC SECTOR IN TO PUBLIC SERVICE) ACT, 2020 Section 8Section 11Section 10

04Reasoning

The KSAT recorded a speaking finding that the petitioners had already been considered under the one-time measure and had, after completing their BRP tenure, participated in counselling and chosen Bhatkal, where they were working in accordance with Rule 15(1).

¶ 8

The petitioners' contention of violation of Guidelines No. 10 and 15(3) had no merit, since those guidelines were applied in the spouse context and the KSAT had found the transfer consistent with the Rules.

¶ 8, 12

Because the regular counselling was complete, the bar in Section 11 against manual counselling applied, and no statutory violation was shown.

¶ 8

No mala fides were alleged against any officer and the competence of the transferring authority was not questioned. The petitioners did not show that Guidelines 10 and 15(3) were statutory in character or that the benefit claimed was available as of right in the vacancies, given administrative requirements, applying Shilpi Bose and S.L. Abbas.

¶ 11–12

As to the medical certificates, which were not before the Tribunal, the Court declined to evaluate them in writ jurisdiction and left the matter to the competent authority.

¶ 14

05Holding

The impugned KSAT order did not suffer from any legal infirmity warranting interference.

¶ 13

The spouse/couple guidelines do not confer an enforceable right to a particular posting, and the petitioners' posting at Bhatkal was consistent with the Act and Rules, 2020.

¶ 11–12

The medical grounds raised for the first time were not adjudicated and are for the competent authority.

¶ 14

The writ petition is dismissed, and the KSAT order dated 04.08.2025 in Application Nos. 10470–10471/2025 is affirmed.

¶ 15
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SHRI. ULLAS S/O SUBBAIAH NAIKvsTHE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY

Karnataka High Court · October 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment