01Facts
The petitioners were appointed in 2011–2012 by the Dharwad Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences (Respondent No. 2).
Petitioner No. 1 was appointed as Assistant Professor in Clinical Psychology by Official Memorandum dated 01.08.2011, at a pay scale of Rs.15,200–25,650 "and allowance as per AICTE".
¶ 1Petitioner No. 2 was appointed as Lecturer in Psychiatric Nursing by communication dated 08.02.2012.
¶ 2 · Annexure-DThe petitioners rely on Government Order dated 16.12.2011 (Annexure-A), which brought the relevant posts under AICTE/UGC pay scales from 01.04.2011.
¶ 4The petitioners also rely on Respondent No. 2's communication dated 22.05.2012 (Annexure-H), which refers to a Government endorsement dated 09.05.2012 permitting extension of the AICTE pay scale to all employees.
¶ 4, 10The petitioners further rely on a Government communication dated 14.12.2020 (Annexure-Q3) referring to a Government Order dated 04.05.2020 extending AICTE pay scales to teaching staff.
¶ 4Respondent No. 2 contends that the petitioners were appointed in the State Government approved pay scale sanctioned by Government Order dated 18.12.2010 (Annexure-R1), and that the "AICTE" reference was a bona fide mistake.
¶ 6Respondent No. 2 further states that no endorsement dated 09.05.2012 was issued and that Annexure-H is unauthorised.
¶ 6By communication dated 11.12.2020 (Annexure-R), Respondent No. 2 declined the petitioners' request for AICTE pay scale.
¶ 3The petitioners challenged this communication under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
02Issues
i.1. Whether the impugned communication dated 11.12.2020 (Annexure-R), declining extension of the AICTE pay scale to the petitioners, is sustainable in view of Annexure-A, Annexure-H and the Government communications relied upon.
¶ 5 · pp. 4–5ii.2. Whether Respondent No. 2 can be directed to extend the AICTE pay scale to the petitioners in the absence of a verified Government order or endorsement extending that benefit.
¶ 14 · p. 1103Law Applied
The Court examined the appointment orders (Annexures B2 and C1) and the Government Order dated 18.12.2010 (Annexure-R1), which sanctioned the State Government approved pay scale for the relevant posts.
¶ 9 · p. 8The Court considered the Government Order dated 16.12.2011 (Annexure-A) and the Government communication dated 02.12.2020, which extended AICTE pay scale to teaching staff.
¶ 4, 13The Court considered the Minimum Qualification for Teachers in Medical Institutions Regulations, 1998, issued by the Medical Council of India, which defines the teaching staff covered by the extension.
¶ 6 · Annexure-R2The Court applied the principle that a writ court cannot direct the implementation of a pay-scale benefit without a prior order of the Government establishing entitlement.
¶ 14 · p. 11No judicial precedent is cited in the order.
04Reasoning
The appointment orders expressly fixed the State Government approved pay scale, and the petitioners accepted those appointments without demur. The reference to "allowance as per AICTE" in those orders was unclear and did not, on its face, displace the stated pay scale.
¶ 9 · p. 8The petitioners' repeated representations were met with Annexure-H, which referred to a Government endorsement dated 09.05.2012 extending the AICTE pay scale to all employees. Neither party could produce that endorsement. The petitioners pleaded ignorance, Respondent No. 2 denied that it was ever issued, and the Additional Government Advocate stated that it had to be traced.
¶ 6, 7, 11The Court held that the existence of this endorsement was a matter solely within the State's knowledge and that the State had to clarify it.
¶ 12The scope of the 02.12.2020 communication was disputed, since Respondent No. 2 argued it applied only to the teaching staff listed in the MCI Regulations.
¶ 13Because entitlement depended on these unresolved Government orders, the Court held that a direction to Respondent No. 2 to pay the AICTE scale would be issued without a prior Government order and was therefore impermissible.
¶ 14 · p. 11The impugned communication was quashed because it rested on a conclusion reached without examining the Government's own orders.
¶ 15(ii) · p. 1205Holding
The impugned communication dated 11.12.2020 (Annexure-R) is quashed.
¶ 15(ii) · p. 12Respondent No. 2 cannot be directed to extend the AICTE pay scale to the petitioners until the State Government determines whether such extension has been granted.
¶ 14 · p. 11The writ petition is partly allowed. The State Government (Respondent No. 1) is directed to (a) verify whether the endorsement dated 09.05.2012 referred to in Annexure-H was ever issued and extended the AICTE pay scale to the petitioners; and (b) verify the intent and purpose of Annexure-A and the communication dated 02.12.2020.
¶ 15(i), (iii), (iv) · pp. 12–13The State must pass appropriate orders and communicate them to the petitioners within 90 days of receipt of a certified copy of the order.
¶ 15(iv) · p. 13Original Court PDF
DR. VIJAY PRASAD B.,vsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
