01Facts
The respondents, lecturers in Pre-University Vocational Education Colleges, were appointed as vocational teachers. Their colleges were later placed under the Directorate of Pre-University and Vocational Education.
p. 3A government order dated 13.07.1999 extended a special pay scale of ₹6,600–₹12,160 to Pre-University lecturers whose services were regularised after ten years.
p. 3The respondents sought the same scale. Their representations were rejected, and the rejection (Annexure-M, dated 03.05.2012) was challenged in W.P. No. 72001/2012.
pp. 3–4In that writ petition, the learned Single Judge quashed Annexure-M and directed reconsideration, holding that no justification existed for discrimination in pay scale where duties and hours were on par with Government College lecturers.
pp. 5–6The State re-rejected the claim by endorsement dated 24.08.2013, citing the absence of Cadre and Recruitment Rules, differing qualifications, temporary engagement, and a different teaching pattern.
pp. 8, SJ order paras 2–3The respondents, who had been regularised on an adhoc basis in Government Pre-University Colleges by orders dated 18.02.1995 and 28.03.1995 with prior service counted for pension and leave, challenged this in W.P. No. 85296/2013 and W.P. Nos. 100507–508/2013.
p. 8, SJ order paras 1, 7 · p. 6, para 4The Single Judge allowed the writ petitions, quashed the 24.08.2013 endorsement, and directed extension of the scale with consequential benefits within three months.
pp. 10–11, SJ order paras 7–8The State filed the present writ appeal.
pp. 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the State was justified in denying the ₹6,600–₹12,160 pay scale to vocational lecturers who performed duties on par with Government Pre-University College lecturers, merely because of differences in Cadre and Recruitment Rules, qualifications, and the vocational nature of their engagement.
pp. 6–7, paras 5–7 · p. 10, SJ order para 8ii.2. Whether the Letters Patent Bench may interfere with the Single Judge's findings in an intra-Court appeal arising from writ jurisdiction.
pp. 11–13, para 903Law Applied
The Court relied on the principle of equal pay for equal work, as applied by the Single Judge, which holds that employees performing similar duties and hours in government service cannot be denied a pay scale without a justifiable basis.
p. 6, para 5 · p. 11, SJ order para 8The Court treated the earlier judgment in W.P. No. 72001/2012, which quashed Annexure-M for non-application of mind, as binding in the present proceedings.
p. 6, para 3 · p. 11, SJ order para 8The Court applied the Supreme Court's decision in R. Saravanan v. Periyar University, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 2202, which holds that a Letters Patent Bench (Clause 15) may interfere with a writ court's decision only where the findings are demonstrably erroneous and the mistake is glaring on the face of the record, and that it should not interfere with a writ court's discretion under Article 226 that is just and reasonable.
pp. 11–13, para 9The State's contention on differing qualifications and temporary status was raised only as a factual distinction without establishing a justifiable difference in duties.
p. 7, para 6 · p. 6, para 5Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
04Reasoning
The Single Judge had earlier held, in W.P. No. 72001/2012, that the State had not shown how the vocational lecturers' services and responsibilities differed from those of Pre-University lecturers, and that the classification rested solely on the institution in which they worked.
p. 6, para 5The subsequent 2013 endorsement repeated the same reasons (absence of Cadre and Recruitment Rules, qualifications, temporary engagement, teaching pattern).
p. 8, SJ order para 3The Single Judge found, on undisputed facts, that the respondents had worked for over ten years, that their regularisation carried the same benefits, and that their duties and teaching duration were the same as those of Government Pre-University lecturers.
pp. 10, SJ order paras 7–8On that basis, the Single Judge held the reasons unsustainable and the classification discriminatory under equal pay principles.
pp. 10–11, SJ order para 8The Letters Patent Bench held that the State's arguments, including the claimed difference in qualifications and status, did not displace these concurrent findings.
pp. 7, paras 6–7Applying Saravanan, the Bench found no demonstrably erroneous finding or glaring mistake in the Single Judge's reasoning that would justify appellate interference.
pp. 11–13, paras 8–9The Single Judge's order was therefore treated as just and reasonable.
p. 13, para 905Holding
The Court held that the Single Judge's findings are not open to interference in intra-Court appeal, as no demonstrable error exists under the standard in Saravanan.
p. 13, para 9The writ appeal was dismissed. The direction to extend the pay scale of ₹6,600–₹12,160 with consequential benefits to the respondents, as lecturers working in Government Pre-University Colleges, stands affirmed. The time limit for compliance was extended by three months from the date of the judgment.
p. 13, para 11 · p. 11, SJ order ORDER (iii) · p. 13, para 10Original Court PDF
THE STATE OF KARNATAKAvsKARNATAKA PRE UNVERSITY VOCATIONAL
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
