01Facts
The appellants were engaged by the Karnataka Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Agency/Department under the World Bank-assisted "Jal Nirmal" Project, initially for about three years and then continued in successive extensions.
¶ 2–3Instead of appointment orders, the Respondents executed "Agreement for Consultancy Services" dated 12.10.2009 with each appellant as an individual consultant, on a fixed, time-based contract with a monthly consolidated fee.
¶ 3, 9–10The fee was initially Rs. 7,000, later increased to Rs. 13,000, with no HRA or conveyance allowance.
¶ 9, 12The appellants stated that they had worked for about ten years and sought regularisation.
¶ 4By orders dated 30.03.2019, 08.07.2019 and 25.03.2019, their temporary services were terminated on the ground that they were no longer required.
¶ 4They challenged these orders and sought regularisation in W.P. Nos. 205275/2019, 226043/2020 and 223136/2020.
¶ 5The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petitions on 12.11.2024 on the ground that the appellants were not appointed on a regular or permanent basis.
¶ 6The appellants relied on an interim order said to have continued them, and contended that the Respondents had not moved to vacate it.
¶ 1702Issues
i.1. Whether individual consultants engaged under a consultancy agreement for a World Bank-assisted project, without sanctioned posts or a due selection process, can claim regularisation or absorption into civil posts under the State.
¶ 13–16, 26ii.2. Whether long, continued engagement, or the continuance of services under an interim order, confers a right to regularisation on such consultants.
¶ 17–18, 26iii.3. Whether the learned Single Judge erred in dismissing the writ petitions.
¶ 2503Law Applied
The constitutional principle that public employment must follow Articles 14 and 16, and that appointments not made under the relevant rules and after a proper competition confer no right to regularisation.
¶ 18, 20State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1, which holds that a contractual appointment ends with the contract and that High Courts should not ordinarily direct absorption or regularisation unless the recruitment was regular and in terms of the constitutional scheme.
¶ 20Vibhuti Shankar Pandey v. State of M.P. (2023 LiveLaw (SC) 91), which holds that a person never appointed against a post by a competent authority has no regularisation claim under Umadevi.
¶ 21State of Gujarat v. R.J. Pathan (2022 LiveLaw (SC) 313), which holds that Umadevi does not apply to temporary appointments made for a particular project and that absorption of such employees cannot be directed.
¶ 22Madan Singh v. State of Haryana (2026 SCC OnLine SC 628), which holds that regularising persons appointed without advertisement or interview is arbitrary, and that the one-time measure in Umadevi cannot be invoked repeatedly.
¶ 23Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Thane v. Santosh Tukaram Tiware (2023) 1 SCC 456, which holds that continuation on a contract basis does not justify an order of regularisation.
¶ 24Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
04Reasoning
The Court first characterised the relationship as contractual. The 2009 agreement and its annexed Letter of Agreement describe the appellants as individual consultants, fix a consultancy fee, and exclude employee benefits, so they were not employees of the Respondents.
¶ 9–10The Court found that the appellants were not appointed against sanctioned posts and did not go through a due selection process, and that they had not produced material showing otherwise.
¶ 13Having accepted the consultancy terms knowingly, they could not later claim that they were appointed to sanctioned posts.
¶ 15Applying Umadevi and R.J. Pathan, the Court held that project-specific consultancy engagements do not generate a right to absorption, since the State may discontinue them when the project ends.
¶ 16, 19On the second issue, the Court held that the length of service and the interim order did not alter the nature of the engagement. It rejected the argument that continuance under interim orders required regularisation, observing that accepting it would "open Pandora's box" and undermine constitutional mandates.
¶ 17–18, 26The Court therefore found no error in the Single Judge's dismissal, which it held to be correct in light of the cited precedents.
¶ 2505Holding
The Division Bench held that individual consultants engaged under a project-specific consultancy agreement, without sanctioned posts or due selection, have no right to regularisation or absorption, regardless of the length of their engagement or continuance under interim orders.
¶ 16, 18, 26The Court found no infirmity in the Single Judge's order dismissing W.P. Nos. 205275/2019, 226043/2020 and 223136/2020.
¶ 25The writ appeals were rejected, and the Respondents were not directed to regularise or absorb the appellants.
¶ 26Original Court PDF
RAGHAVENDRA S KATTIMANIvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
