01Facts
The appellants were engaged by the Karnataka Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Agency (KRWSSA) and related authorities as Assistant Accounts Consultant, M&E Coordinator Consultant, Assistant Director (O.P.), Assistant Technical Consultant and Assistant Accountant, initially for three years and later continued.
¶ 2The engagement was under the World Bank-assisted "Jal Nirmal" Project.
¶ 2The appellants claimed their appointments followed a notification and written and oral examinations, but that the respondents instead executed consultancy agreements, which they were compelled to sign.
¶ 3Agreements dated 12.10.2009 described the appellants as individual consultants on a fixed-cost, time-based contract at a monthly consultancy fee (initially Rs. 7,000, later Rs. 13,000), with no HRA or conveyance allowance.
¶ 9, 12The Terms of Reference authorised engagement of individual consultants for a defined period.
¶ 10Orders dated 25.03.2019, 30.03.2019 and 08.07.2019 relieved the appellants from service.
¶ 4The appellants challenged these orders in writ petitions (W.P. Nos. 205275/2019, 226043/2020 and 223136/2020) and sought regularisation on the basis of about ten years' service.
¶ 4–5A learned Single Judge dismissed the petitions on 12.11.2024.
¶ 6The appellants then filed these writ appeals and contended that they continued under an interim order that the respondents never sought to vacate.
¶ 17The respondents conceded that no sanctioned posts were used and no due selection process was followed.
¶ 1302Issues
i.1. Whether consultants engaged under individual consultancy agreements, without selection against sanctioned posts or a due selection process, can claim regularisation or absorption into civil posts merely because they have served for a long period.
¶ 13–16, 26ii.2. Whether the continuation of the appellants under interim orders, or the respondents' failure to seek vacation of those orders, confers any right to regularisation or continued employment.
¶ 17–18iii.3. Whether the learned Single Judge erred in dismissing the writ petitions seeking regularisation.
¶ 2503Law Applied
The Court relied on Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, which require public employment to follow a constitutionally sanctioned process, as reaffirmed in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1.
¶ 18, 20Under Umadevi, an appointment not made under the rules after proper competition confers no right, a contractual appointment ends with the contract, and High Courts should not ordinarily direct absorption or regularisation unless recruitment was regular.
¶ 20The Court relied on Vibhuti Shankar Pandey v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2023 LiveLaw (SC) 91), which applied Umadevi's one-time measure to deny regularisation where the claimant was never appointed against a post by a competent authority.
¶ 21The Court noted State of Gujarat v. R.J. Pathan (2022 LiveLaw (SC) 313), which held that directions for absorption of project-based temporary appointees are unsustainable, and that Umadevi is confined to irregular appointments on sanctioned posts in regular establishments.
¶ 22The Court cited Madan Singh v. State of Haryana (2026 SCC OnLine SC 628), which holds that regularising persons not appointed through advertisement or interview is arbitrary, and that the one-time measure cannot be invoked repeatedly.
¶ 23The Court relied on Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Thane v. Santosh Tukaram Tiware (2023) 1 SCC 456, which holds that continuance on a contract basis does not by itself warrant regularisation.
¶ 24Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
04Reasoning
The agreements and Terms of Reference showed the appellants were individual consultants, not employees, and their remuneration was assignment-based.
¶ 9–10, 12Because the appellants had accepted these terms with their eyes open, they could not later assert that they held sanctioned posts or seek regularisation under those terms.
¶ 15The appellants produced no material showing appointment pursuant to a notification against sanctioned posts, and the respondents had not made such appointments.
¶ 13On that basis, the appellants failed the Article 14 and 16 scrutiny that Umadevi requires.
¶ 18Consultancy engagements do not, ipso facto, create a right to regularisation, and the authorities may discontinue such services when the project ends or the need ceases.
¶ 16, 19The Court rejected the argument based on interim orders and the respondents' inaction, treating these contentions as lacking merit.
¶ 18The Court relied on the Umadevi line and the cases in paras. 21–24 to hold that long duration of service and continuation under agreements do not confer a right to regularisation.
¶ 24, 26The judgment does not expressly address the R.J. Pathan distinction for project-based temporary appointments, although it recites that decision.
¶ 22The Court's reasoning rests principally on the absence of a sanctioned post and of a due selection process, and on the consultancy character of the engagement.
¶ 13–16, 2605Holding
The appellants, engaged as individual consultants under consultancy agreements without selection against sanctioned posts, cannot claim regularisation or absorption as of right, and the learned Single Judge committed no error in dismissing the writ petitions.
¶ 25–26The authorities cannot be compelled to absorb or regularise such consultants.
¶ 16The writ appeals were rejected in their entirety.
¶ 26 · OrderNo specific relief, direction, or costs order was granted in favour of the appellants.
Original Court PDF
VASANTKUMARvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
