01Facts
The Karnataka State Judicial Department Employees House Building Co-operative Society Ltd. ("Society") entered into a development agreement dated 07.01.2005 with a developer for formation of 2,000 intermediate sites for its members.
¶ 5(i)–(ii)Site No.120 (20,789 sq ft, Hejjala Village) was formed under this layout and was to be conveyed to members.
¶ 5(iii) · ¶ 35The developer conveyed Site No.120 to third-party purchasers by sale deed dated 25.08.2023.
¶ 5(v) · ¶ 35The Board's minutes allegedly recorded a resolution authorising the developer to deal with the site, which two directors disputed.
¶ 9 · ¶ 39The Registrar (Respondent No.3) ordered a statutory enquiry under Section 64 KCS Act. The Enquiry Officer held the charges proved.
¶ 5(vii) · ¶ 9(vii) · ¶ 36On 01.12.2025, Respondent No.3 passed an order under Section 68 directing rectification of defects within 45 days and directing the Society to initiate dispute and attachment proceedings against the developer and purchasers.
¶ 5(vii) · ¶ 37The directors' appeal under Section 106 was dismissed on 30.05.2026.
¶ 7Respondent No.3 then initiated surcharge proceedings under Section 69 for Rs.2,61,62,000/- and suo motu disqualification proceedings under Section 29-C(8)(b)(c),(d) against the directors.
¶ 6 · ¶ 12 · ¶ 13 · ¶ 17The High Court earlier restrained Section 69 action but not Section 29-C proceedings.
¶ 16During pendency, a sale deed dated 07.07.2026 conveying Site No.120 from the purchasers to the Society was executed, with the developer as a confirming party and paying the consideration in instalments, some made before the execution date.
¶ 26 · ¶ 45The Society's in-charge secretary filed an affidavit in WP 2690/2026.
¶ 26Respondent No.5 contended the sale deed was vulnerable.
¶ 27 · ¶ 3202Issues
i.1. Whether the disqualification of the petitioner-directors under Section 29-C(8) KCS Act was sustainable, having regard to their non-compliance with the Section 68 order.
¶ 6 · ¶ 18 · ¶ 43 · ¶ 47(ii)ii.2. Whether the Section 68 order dated 01.12.2025 and the appellate order dated 30.05.2026 under Section 106 could be assailed by the directors, who had participated in the Section 64 enquiry.
¶ 41 · ¶ 43 · ¶ 47(iv)iii.3. Whether the Society had locus standi, and whether the in-charge secretary had authority, to maintain WP 2690/2026 challenging the Section 69 surcharge proceedings against the directors.
¶ 41 · ¶ 44iv.4. Whether the sale deed dated 07.07.2026 in favour of the Society should be accepted, and how the relief should be moulded to protect the members' interests.
¶ 45–46 · ¶ 47(v)–(vi)03Law Applied
The Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959, primarily Section 64 (statutory enquiry).
¶ 35–36Section 68 (Registrar's directions to rectify defects and initiate remedial action).
¶ 37 · ¶ 43Section 69 (surcharge proceedings).
¶ 44Section 70 (disputes) and Section 103 (attachment before judgment).
¶ 5(viii) · ¶ 42Section 106 (appeal).
¶ 43Section 29-C(8) (disqualification of directors acting prejudicially to the Society).
¶ 42 · ¶ 43Directors who participated in a Section 64 enquiry cannot assail a consequent Section 68 order or Section 69 action.
¶ 41Under the development agreement, the proper remedy against the developer lay in arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, or a civil suit against purchasers.
¶ 42Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India for the writ jurisdiction invoked.
¶ 3 · ¶ 4Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT, 1959. Section 68Section 69Section 64Section 103Section 70Section 106Section 14
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The Section 64 enquiry established that the directors acted prejudicially to the Society: they failed to act on the unauthorised sale of Site No.120, did not initiate civil or criminal action against the developer, and did not supervise the secretary.
¶ 40–42The developer's letter dated 02.02.2026 indicated the sale was made on directors' instructions.
¶ 40Because the directors had participated in the enquiry without explaining defects, they could not assail the Section 68 order or the Section 106 appellate order.
¶ 41 · ¶ 43Their partial compliance (initiating proceedings against the developer and purchasers but not against the developer, CEO or secretary) fell short of the directions.
¶ 42The disqualification under Section 29-C was upheld, as the directors had not been denied hearing.
¶ 43Regarding Section 69, the Society itself, not the directors, had challenged the surcharge proceedings. The Society had no locus to do so, and the in-charge secretary, against whom proceedings were pending, had no board authorisation.
¶ 41 · ¶ 44The sale deed of 07.07.2026 was open to challenge because the consideration was paid well before its execution without explanation, and the 2023 sale deed had not been cancelled.
¶ 45–46Since Site No.120 had returned to the Society, the Court moulded relief rather than quashing the Section 68 direction for prosecution, to allow the developer to cancel the 2023 sale and re-plan the site into 16 sites for members.
¶ 46 · ¶ 47(v)05Holding
The disqualification of the petitioner-directors under Section 29-C was valid, and the Section 68 and Section 106 orders were justified.
¶ 43 · ¶ 47(ii), (iv)WP 12472/2026 is dismissed, and the order appointing a Special Officer for elections is upheld.
¶ 47(i)–(ii)WP 18567/2026 is allowed in part. The Section 68 order and the Section 106 appellate order are confirmed. The direction to initiate criminal prosecution against the developer and purchasers is kept in abeyance for six months to enable cancellation of the 25.08.2023 sale deed, re-plan of Site No.120 into 16 sites, and conveyance to members. On such conveyance, the 07.07.2026 sale deed stands cancelled.
¶ 47(iii)–(v)The developer and purchasers are declared to have no right, title or interest in Site No.120 and are barred from challenging the 07.07.2026 sale deed.
¶ 47(vi)WP 2690/2026 is disposed of, upholding the Section 69 action, with further action held in abeyance for six months.
¶ 44 · ¶ 47(vii)The Special Officer is directed to initiate disciplinary action against the in-charge secretary and CEO per the Section 68 order. The matter is listed on 08.01.2027 for compliance. All registration expenses and stamp duty for the 07.07.2026 sale deed are to be borne by the developer.
¶ 47(viii)–(x)Original Court PDF
SRI K C ANNEGOWDAvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
