01Facts
The appellant Geetha (plaintiff in O.S. No. 8450/2012) and the respondent Prabhu (defendant No. 1) are siblings.
¶ 5(i), 21Their father, Kuppuswamy, held the suit property, which was allotted and sold by BDA, and gifted it to Geetha on 25.02.2006.
¶ 5(i), 21Geetha mortgaged the property to BDA Housing Co-operative Society for a loan of Rs. 4,00,000, repaid Rs. 2,00,000, and sought Prabhu's help to clear the balance of Rs. 2,00,000.
¶ 5(ii), 21Prabhu obtained a housing loan of Rs. 6,00,000 from Vijaya Bank (defendant No. 2). Out of it, Rs. 2,74,254 was paid by DD to the BDA Society and Rs. 3,25,746 was credited to Geetha's bank account.
¶ 22, 32, 34A registered sale deed dated 01.10.2007 for Rs. 8,00,000 was executed in Prabhu's favour, supported by a sale agreement dated 23.08.2007 (Ex. D31) under which Rs. 2,00,000 was paid in cash.
¶ 22, 31, 34A lease of the second floor was executed in Geetha's favour on 11.10.2007 at Rs. 4,000 per month.
¶ 35Geetha pleaded that she signed the sale deed believing it to be a loan/mortgage document, that she is illiterate, and that Prabhu misrepresented its nature.
¶ 5(ii)–(iii), 12Prabhu's legal notice terminating the tenancy was issued on 04.03.2013.
¶ 10The trial court dismissed Geetha's suit on 15.10.2019.
¶ 9Prabhu then filed O.S. No. 1913/2020 for ejectment and arrears of rent, which was decreed on 04.09.2024.
¶ 10Both decrees are challenged in these appeals, RFA No. 650 of 2020 and RFA No. 2683 of 2024.
¶ 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the appellant proved that the respondent No. 1 misrepresented the nature of the document and played fraud in procuring the sale deed dated 01.10.2007 under the guise of a mortgage deed in favour of the Bank.
¶ 20(i)ii.2. Whether the trial court was justified in dismissing O.S. No. 8450/2012.
¶ 20(ii)iii.3. Whether the trial court was justified in decreeing the ejectment suit O.S. No. 1913/2020.
¶ 20(iii), 4003Law Applied
The court relied on the distinction between fraud as to the character of a document, which renders the transaction void, and fraud as to its contents, which renders it voidable, as laid down in Ningawwa v. Byrappa.
¶ 24The distinction in Ningawwa v. Byrappa was followed in Dularia Devi v. Janardan Singh.
¶ 25The court applied the plea of non est factum and the three-part test in Ramathal v. K. Rajamani (based on Saunders v. Anglia Building Society). That test requires the signatory to belong to a class unable to understand the document through illiteracy or a similar disability, to have made a fundamental mistake as to the nature of the contents, and to have signed a document radically different from the one intended.
¶ 26The court noted the principles of undue influence under Section 16 of the Indian Contract Act from Subhas Chandra Das Mushib, though it did not analyse them in its reasoning.
¶ 27On the ejectment issue, the court relied on the principle that a tenant cannot dispute the landlord's title where the sale deed has been upheld, as implicitly reflected in the dismissal of the plaintiff's title suit.
¶ 42Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 95
Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 16
04Reasoning
The court held that the plea of illiteracy was not established. Geetha, in cross-examination, identified and admitted several documents, which showed she was literate and could read the documents placed before her.
¶ 29Her earlier visits to the Sub-Registrar's office, for the gift deed and the 2006 BDA mortgage, showed familiarity with registration procedure.
¶ 30The court relied on the signed sale agreement (Ex. D31) and the cash advance as conduct consistent with a genuine sale.
¶ 31Her admitted receipt of the DD for Rs. 2,74,254 and the later registration of the BDA discharge certificate were treated as consistent with a genuine sale.
¶ 32The sub-registrar's endorsement recording her admission of execution was taken into account.
¶ 33Her withdrawals from the account credited with Rs. 3,25,746 were treated as acceptance of part consideration.
¶ 34The lease deed executed on 11.10.2007 was held to post-date the sale, and the stamp paper's purchase date of 09.10.2007 negated the claim that she signed the lease and sale on the same day.
¶ 35The court further relied on the non-payment of property tax by Geetha after 2007 and her motive of paying her daughter's marriage expenses and the BDA dues.
¶ 37–38Together these indicated that the sale was knowing and for consideration, so the misrepresentation case failed.
¶ 39On the ejectment, the court found that the dismissal of the title suit, which had challenged the sale deed, established Prabhu's ownership. Geetha's continued occupation under the lease of 11.10.2007 therefore made her a tenant, and the decree followed.
¶ 42The court also noted that the claim was limited to three years before filing, which was consistent with limitation.
¶ 42The judgment does not expressly address the appellant's contention that the sale consideration was stated as Rs. 16,00,000 in the witness's testimony, nor the delay in filing the ejectment suit.
¶ 12, 1405Holding
The appellant failed to prove that the respondent No. 1 misrepresented the character or contents of the sale deed dated 01.10.2007.
¶ 39The trial court was therefore justified in dismissing O.S. No. 8450/2012.
¶ 39The trial court was also justified in decreeing the ejectment suit O.S. No. 1913/2020, since the sale deed was upheld and the appellant was a tenant under the lease dated 11.10.2007.
¶ 42Both RFA No. 650/2020 and RFA No. 2683/2024 were dismissed, leaving the dismissal of the title suit and the ejectment decree intact.
¶ 43Original Court PDF
SMT. K GEETHAvsSHRI K PRABHU
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
