01Facts
Two sets of petitioners held Saguvali chit grants under Rule 29 of the Karnataka Land Grant Rules over 3 acres in Sy. No. 20/2, Mamankeri Village, Bidar
¶ 4, 11The Deputy Commissioner cancelled the grants in 1979–80.
¶ 5, 11This Court set aside the cancellations in W.P. No. 16783 of 1980 and remanded the matters to the Tahsildar.
¶ 5, 11The Tahsildar re-granted the land by order dated 16.12.1998 and re-entered the grantees' names in the revenue records (Columns 9 and 12).
¶ 6, 11, 21In 2022, on a letter from the Assistant Forest Conservator, the Assistant Commissioner set aside the re-grant on the ground that the State had notified the land as forest under s. 4 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 by notification dated 27.06.1991, and directed mutation as Government land.
¶ 7, 12The Deputy Commissioner rejected the revision on 22.06.2023.
¶ 8In the second set, a further Deputy Commissioner order dated 27.06.2024 held the petitioners not entitled to regularisation.
¶ 12The learned Single Judge allowed W.P. No. 203295 of 2023 on 23.09.2025 and W.P. No. 202993 of 2024 on 24.09.2025 and set aside the impugned orders.
¶ 9, 13The State filed these writ appeals.
¶ 10, 1402Issues
i.1. Whether the subject lands are "reserved forest" under ss. 2(14) and 4 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, such that they cannot be granted or regularised in favour of the petitioners.
¶ 22–23, 26–31ii.2. Whether the principle in T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad (that land once declared forest always remains forest) applies where no valid s. 4 notification is shown to exist.
¶ 32–33iii.3. Whether the learned Single Judge's orders suffer from a patent error of law, manifest procedural illegality, misreading of evidence, or perversity warranting interference in intra-court appeal.
¶ 34–3503Law Applied
Section 2(14) of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 defines a "reserved forest" as land settled and notified under Chapter II.
¶ 23Section 4 requires the State to issue a notification declaring its intention to constitute a reserved forest, specifying the limits, and appointing a Forest Settlement Officer.
¶ 24Section 2(10) defines "notification" as one published in the official gazette.
¶ 25Under Viraj Impex Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (SLP(C) No. 1979 of 2019, decided 21.01.2026), a notification has the force of law only upon publication in the Official Gazette.
¶ 28Sri D.M. Deve Gowda v. Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (W.P. No. 10502 of 2022), following Dhananjay v. State of Karnataka (W.P. No. 54476 of 2016), holds that a land is either forest or not, and there is no "deemed forest" absent statutory provision.
¶ 30T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India, AIR 1997 SC 1228, was cited by the State for the proposition that declared forest remains forest.
¶ 17, 32Airports Authority of India v. Pradip Kumar Banerjee, (2025) 4 SCC 111, limits intra-court interference with a Single Judge's writ order to patent legal error, manifest procedural illegality, misreading of evidence, or perversity.
¶ 34A party's failure to produce a directed document may be held against it, and an adverse inference may be drawn.
¶ 2604Reasoning
The State contended that the land was forest under the 1991 notification and that s. 6 of the Act bars acquisition of rights after a s. 4 declaration.
¶ 16The petitioners argued that no such notification was ever gazetted.
¶ 18The Court found that the State, despite a specific direction, did not produce the s. 4 notification, and drew an adverse inference against it.
¶ 26Applying s. 4 and s. 2(10) together with Viraj Impex, the Court held that the gazette publication requirement is substantive, not a formality, because it is what converts an executive decision into law.
¶ 27The notification relied on itself stated that it was yet to be published in the gazette, which confirmed its incompleteness.
¶ 29Because no valid declaration was shown, the lands could not be treated as forest.
¶ 31The Court held that Godavarman did not apply, since the State had not shown the land had been declared forest through a gazetted s. 4 notification.
¶ 33Since the Single Judge's conclusion rested on the absence of a statutory declaration, the Division Bench found no patent error, procedural illegality, or perversity requiring interference.
¶ 34–35The judgment does not expressly analyse the scope of s. 6, which the State had invoked.
¶ 1605Holding
Issue 1 was answered in the negative: without a gazetted s. 4 notification, the lands are not reserved forest and cannot be treated as forest.
¶ 27, 31Issue 2 was answered by holding Godavarman inapplicable on these facts.
¶ 33On Issue 3, the Court held that the Single Judge's orders disclosed no reviewable error.
¶ 35Both writ appeals are dismissed, with pending interlocutory applications disposed of and no order as to costs.
¶ 36The Single Judge's orders setting aside the Assistant Commissioner's order dated 16.12.2022, the Deputy Commissioner's orders dated 22.06.2023 and 27.06.2024, and the grant re-entries stand affirmed.
¶ 9, 13, 35–36Original Court PDF
THE CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS KALABURAGI FOREST QUARTERSvsTUKKAMMA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
