Karnataka High CourtTransport, Maritime, and Aviation LawInsurance Law

Karnataka HC Enhances Accident Compensation to ₹8.77 Lakh, Rules One-Third Income Deduction Applies Even If Only Widow Depends

MEHABOOBI W/O. ABDULSAB DESHANURv.SHRISHAIL S/O. SHIVAPPA HIREMATH

Karnataka HC Enhances Accident Compensation to ₹8.77 Lakh, Rules One-Third Income Deduction Applies Even If Only Widow Depends. MEHABOOBI W/O. ABDULSAB DESHANUR vs SHRISHAIL S/O. SHIVAPPA HIREMATH. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether, where the deceased was married and Claimant 1 alone is the dependant, the deduction towards personal and living expenses should be 1/2 (as contended by the Insurer) or 1/3 (as contended by the claimants).

The court held

The court held that a 1/3 deduction for personal expenses applies where a married deceased leaves a sole dependant, that the notional income is ₹8,750/- per month, and that conventional heads require enhancement.

It also directed

The court found no basis to disturb the 9% interest.

MFA 101271/2021 is allowed in part. MFA 100297/2019 is dismissed. The compensation is modified to ₹8,77,000/- (medical ₹1,86,614; loss of dependency ₹4,90,000; consortium ₹1,59,720; loss of estate ₹19,965; funeral ₹19,965; total ₹8,76,264 rounded off) with 9% interest per annum from the date of petition until realization. The Insurer must deposit the amount with interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy. Disbursement is to be made in the ratio 62:30:08 among Claimants 1–3. The Registry is directed to transmit records and draw the modified award.

01Facts

On 15.04.2016, a 407 passenger tempo (KA-28/3939) and a motorcycle (KA-24/U-4152) were involved in an accident. The occurrence, the deceased's age (65 years), and his avocation were not disputed.

¶ 2

The claimants filed MVC No. 197/2017 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The Tribunal held the accident was caused by rash and negligent driving of the tempo, held the claimants to be dependants, and fastened liability on the Insurance Company. It awarded ₹6,12,614/- (medical ₹1,86,614; loss of dependency ₹3,36,000; funeral ₹10,000; transportation ₹5,000; loss of love and affection ₹75,000).

¶ 3

The Insurance Company appealed (MFA 100297/2019) challenging quantum and liability. The claimants cross-appealed (MFA 101271/2021) seeking enhancement.

¶ 1

The Insurer did not press the fitness-certificate objection.

¶ 4

The Insurer contended that Claimants 2 and 3 (major son and married daughter) were not dependants, that Claimant 1 (widow) was the sole dependant, and that 50% should be deducted for personal expenses.

¶ 4

The claimants conceded that Claimants 2 and 3 were not dependants but argued for a 1/3 deduction and for income of ₹8,750/- per month under the KSLSA Notional Income Chart, rather than the Tribunal's ₹6,000/-. The claimants also contended that conventional heads were under-awarded.

¶ 5

No cogent evidence was produced to establish agricultural or mango-business income.

¶ 8

02Issues

i.1. Whether, where the deceased was married and Claimant 1 alone is the dependant, the deduction towards personal and living expenses should be 1/2 (as contended by the Insurer) or 1/3 (as contended by the claimants).

¶ 4–7

ii.2. Whether the deceased's income should be fixed at ₹8,750/- per month per the KSLSA Notional Income Chart, in the absence of proof of higher income.

¶ 5, 8

iii.3. Whether the compensation under conventional heads (funeral, transportation, loss of estate, loss of consortium) was on the lower side and requires enhancement.

¶ 5, 9

iv.4. Whether the interest awarded requires interference.

¶ 10

03Law Applied

The court applied Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as the basis for the claim.

¶ 2

For the deduction towards personal expenses, the court relied on Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121, which prescribes standardized deductions of 1/3 for married deceased with 2–3 dependants, 1/4 for 4–6, and 1/5 for more than six.

¶ 6

The court applied Ved Kanwar v. Babulal (CA 4296–4297/2026), read as holding that the minimum deduction for a married deceased is 1/3, and National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680, which the court read as not contemplating any deduction lower than 1/3 for a married deceased.

¶ 7

The Division Bench decision in Smt. Ratna v. Veerayya (RP 100058/2021) was relied on for applying 1/3 where a sole dependant remained.

¶ 7

For income, the court applied the KSLSA Notional Income Chart, fixing income at ₹8,750/- per month for an accident in 2016 where no cogent evidence of higher earnings was produced. The multiplier applicable to the deceased's age of 65 was taken as 7.

¶ 8

For conventional heads, the court applied Pranay Sethi and Rojalini Nayak v. Ajit Sahoo (2024 INSC 584).

¶ 9

On interest, the court relied on Puttamma v. K.L. Narayana Reddy (2013) 15 SCC 45 and United India Insurance Co. v. Malyadari (MFA 3895/2018).

¶ 10

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166

04Reasoning

Claimants 2 and 3 were conceded to be non-dependants, so Claimant 1 was the sole dependant of the deceased.

¶ 5

The court held that the Insurer's 1/2 deduction was unsupported. Under Sarla Verma, Ved Kanwar, Pranay Sethi, and Ratna, a married deceased's personal-expense deduction cannot be lower than 1/3, so a 1/3 deduction applied even with a sole dependant.

¶ 7

On income, the claimants' assertion of agricultural or mango-business earnings lacked evidence, so the court applied the KSLSA chart figure of ₹8,750/-.

¶ 8

Applying 1/3 deduction and multiplier 7 yielded ₹4,90,000/- under loss of dependency.

¶ 8

Because the conventional heads awarded by the Tribunal were low, the court re-fixed them under Pranay Sethi and Rojalini Nayak: consortium ₹53,240 x 3 (₹1,59,720), loss of estate ₹19,965, and funeral ₹19,965.

¶ 9

The Tribunal's ₹75,000 for loss of love and affection and its separate transportation and funeral awards were not retained in the modified table.

¶ 3, 9

The court found the 9% interest awarded by the Tribunal correct under Puttamma and Malyadari, so no interference was warranted.

¶ 10

The Insurer's objection to liability and its quantum challenge failed, and the claimants' enhancement succeeded in part.

¶ 11

05Holding

The court held that a 1/3 deduction for personal expenses applies where a married deceased leaves a sole dependant, that the notional income is ₹8,750/- per month, and that conventional heads require enhancement.

¶ 7–9

The court found no basis to disturb the 9% interest.

¶ 10

MFA 101271/2021 is allowed in part. MFA 100297/2019 is dismissed. The compensation is modified to ₹8,77,000/- (medical ₹1,86,614; loss of dependency ₹4,90,000; consortium ₹1,59,720; loss of estate ₹19,965; funeral ₹19,965; total ₹8,76,264 rounded off) with 9% interest per annum from the date of petition until realization. The Insurer must deposit the amount with interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy. Disbursement is to be made in the ratio 62:30:08 among Claimants 1–3. The Registry is directed to transmit records and draw the modified award.

¶ 9, 11(i)–(viii)
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

MEHABOOBI W/O. ABDULSAB DESHANURvsSHRISHAIL S/O. SHIVAPPA HIREMATH

Karnataka High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment