01Facts
The business "Children's Corner" was started by late Narayana T. Rai around 1981 and later converted into a partnership.
¶ 3The first defendant, Smt. Yashoda N. Rai, was a partner from 10.10.2008, and the plaintiff No. 2, Smt. Nishali Rai, and the second defendant, Sri Aditya N. Rai, were inducted under a deed dated 12.04.2013.
¶ 3The second defendant retired on 01.10.2014.
¶ 3After Narayana T. Rai's death in November 2018, the firm was reconstituted on 09.11.2018 with profit-sharing of 40% (first defendant) and 60% (second plaintiff).
¶ 3The second plaintiff issued a dissolution notice dated 20.03.2024, served on 22.03.2024.
¶ 4The plaintiffs allege the defendants started a rival business under the same name using the old firm's goodwill and stock, with turnover of about Rs. 5.2 crore.
¶ 4The defendants contend that the first defendant was the original proprietor, that disputes over dissolution and goodwill are pending before a sole Arbitrator in A.C. No. 644/2024, and that a new partnership was formed on 15.04.2024.
¶ 5–6An earlier injunction application (A.A. No. 6/2024) was rejected on 10.09.2024, and Com.O.S. No. 284/2024 was rejected for non-compliance with Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act.
¶ 6, 18The plaintiffs filed Com.O.S. No. 152/2026 with an Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC application.
¶ 9An ex parte ad interim injunction was granted on 30.04.2026.
¶ 9The High Court in W.P. No. 16621/2026 directed disposal within thirty days.
¶ 9By order dated 21.07.2026, the Commercial Court made the injunction absolute.
¶ 10The defendants appealed.
¶ 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the plaintiffs established a prima facie right to protect the goodwill attached to the business name "Children's Corner".
¶ 13ii.2. Whether the defendants were attempting to pass off their business as that of the plaintiffs.
¶ 13iii.3. Whether the plaintiffs established the balance of convenience and irreparable injury warranting interlocutory injunction.
¶ 2103Law Applied
The Court applied Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC, which govern temporary injunctions, as the procedural basis for the application.
¶ 7The relief of temporary injunction is discretionary and cannot be granted merely on apprehension where the applicant's right is yet to be established.
¶ 21The passing-off action protects goodwill against misrepresentation and resulting or likely damage; the essential considerations are goodwill, misrepresentation and damage, and the claimant must first show a prima facie entitlement to the goodwill.
¶ 14Non-registration of a trade name does not by itself defeat a passing-off action.
¶ 14The effect of prior proceedings and the conduct of parties are relevant, and the trial court must not treat disputed questions pending before an arbitrator as settled.
¶ 17–18Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 13
04Reasoning
The dispute could not be resolved by comparing the names "Children's Corner" and "The Children's Corner" alone.
¶ 12The first defendant's claim as original proprietor and continuing partner was not insignificant, while the second plaintiff's claim could not be accepted merely because she was a partner.
¶ 15, 17The Commercial Court erred by assuming the plaintiffs were the first users with exclusive goodwill, since the ownership and valuation of goodwill were pending before the Arbitrator.
¶ 15–17The earlier rejection of injunction in A.A. No. 6/2024 and the parties' conduct were relevant and should have been examined before granting substantially similar relief again.
¶ 18On the passing-off elements, the plaintiffs had not shown that goodwill vested exclusively in them or that the defendants made any specific misrepresentation to customers. The turnover figure did not establish exclusive entitlement, and no particular customers were identified.
¶ 19–20On balance of convenience, the defendants were operating under a new partnership formed on 15.04.2024, and the injunction would effectively halt that business before the rights concerning the old firm were determined.
¶ 2105Holding
The plaintiffs had not established a prima facie right to the goodwill or a passing-off case, nor the balance of convenience or irreparable injury.
¶ 19–21The Commercial Appeal is allowed. The order dated 21.07.2026 in Com.O.S. No. 152/2026 is set aside, and the plaintiffs' application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC stands dismissed. The Court clarified that its observations are confined to the interlocutory application and will not influence the suit or the pending arbitration on merits.
¶ 21, Order (ii)–(iv)Original Court PDF
SMT. YASHODA N RAIvsM/S CHILDREN CORNER
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
