01Facts
The Petitioner (Judgment Debtor) challenged an order dated 11.07.2024 in Execution No. 1132/2020, by which the LVI Addl. City Civil & Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, rejected his I.A. No. 1 under Order XXI Rule 90 CPC seeking to set aside an auction.
¶ 1The Executing Court issued a spot sale proclamation on 30.08.2023, fixing the sale for 05.10.2023.
¶ 7On 05.10.2023, the suit property was sold in a spot sale, and Respondent No. 2, a third-party bidder, was declared highest bidder at ₹1,08,00,000.
¶ 7Respondent No. 2 deposited 25% of the bid amount on 27.10.2023 and the balance 75% on 23.11.2023.
¶ 7The earlier order records the payment dates as 30.10.2023 and 23.11.2023; the discrepancy in the first deposit date is not resolved in the judgment.
¶ 3The Executing Court held that, although Order XXI Rule 85 required full payment within 15 days, it could accept the belated amounts under Section 151 CPC, that the purchaser was not in default, and that no material irregularity was shown.
¶ 8The Petitioner argued that Rules 84 and 85 are mandatory and that the sale was therefore a nullity.
¶ 2, 4, 9Respondent No. 2 relied on Rosali v. Taico Bank and Ram Karan Gupta v. J.S. Exim Ltd.
¶ 6The Respondent No. 1 decree holder remained unrepresented.
¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether non-compliance with the mandatory timelines under Order XXI Rules 84 and 85 CPC (25% deposit immediately on sale; full payment within 15 days) renders the court auction a nullity.
¶ 4, 13ii.2. Whether the Executing Court could, under its inherent powers under Section 151 CPC, accept belated deposits and treat the purchaser as not in default so as to validate the sale.
¶ 8, 12, 1303Law Applied
Order XXI Rule 64 empowers the executing court to order sale of attached property.
¶ 10Order XXI Rule 72 bars a decree holder from bidding without permission.
¶ 10Order XXI Rule 84 requires the purchaser (other than a decree holder) to deposit 25% immediately on declaration as purchaser, and Order XXI Rule 85 requires full payment before the court closes on the 15th day from sale.
¶ 10Order XXI Rule 86 mandates re-sale on default.
¶ 10Order XXI Rule 90 governs setting aside sales for material irregularity or fraud, requiring proof of substantial injury.
¶ 10Order XXI Rule 92 deals with confirmation of sale.
¶ 18In Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad (1955) 1 SCR 108, the Supreme Court held that the Rule 84 and Rule 85 deposit and payment requirements are mandatory, and that non-compliance means there is no sale at all.
¶ 8–9, 11In Gas Point Petroleum India Ltd. v. Rajendra Marothi (2023) 6 SCC 391, the Court applied Manilal and held that non-compliance with Rules 84 and 85 renders the sale void.
¶ 11.1In Balram v. Ilam Singh (1996) 5 SCC 705, the Court held that Rule 85 is mandatory, that non-compliance makes the proceedings a nullity requiring resale under Rule 86, and that the executing court has no inherent power to extend the time limit.
¶ 11.2Rosali v. Taico Bank (2009) 17 SCC 690 construed the word "immediately" in Rule 84.
¶ 11.1Ram Karan Gupta v. J.S. Exim Ltd. (2012) 13 SCC 568 held that a sale is valid where the 25% deposit is made on the day of sale and the balance within 15 days.
¶ 12Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151Section 73
04Reasoning
The Court first recorded the undisputed chronology: sale on 05.10.2023, with the 25% deposit on 27.10.2023 and the balance on 23.11.2023, both beyond the Rule 84 and 85 timelines.
¶ 3, 7, 13The Court found the facts closely similar to Gas Point, where delayed deposits were held to render the sale a nullity.
¶ 11.1The Court rejected the Executing Court's reliance on Section 151 CPC, holding that Balram forecloses any inherent power to extend the Rule 85 period, even on the court's own mistake.
¶ 11.2The Court distinguished Ram Karan Gupta on the ground that there the 25% deposit was made on the day of sale and the balance within 15 days, so the timelines were complied with.
¶ 12Because Rules 84 and 85 are mandatory, the Court held that the mandatory timeline of depositing the entire purchase money before the 15th day from the sale was not adhered to, and that the auction therefore could not be sustained.
¶ 13The Court did not separately examine the Rule 90(2) substantial injury requirement, since it treated the defective sale as a nullity rather than a mere irregularity.
¶ 10–1305Holding
Non-compliance with the mandatory timelines of Order XXI Rules 84 and 85 CPC renders the auction a nullity.
¶ 13The Executing Court had no power under Section 151 CPC to validate belated deposits.
¶ 11.2, 13The writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 11.07.2024 is set aside, the auction is set aside, and all pending applications are closed.
¶ 14Original Court PDF
SRI T P MURALIDHARvsSRI D SUDHAKAR GUPTA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
