01Facts
The appellants challenged the judgment and decree dated 18.11.2022 in O.S. No. 6632/2011 of the XXXV Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, which partly decreed a suit for partition.
p. 1The appeal was filed under Section 96 read with Order 41 Rule 1 CPC.
p. 1During the pendency of the appeal, the parties reached an out-of-court settlement concerning the "Suit A" Schedule Property.
p. 6An intending purchaser acquired interest in the property under a Memorandum of Understanding dated 05.11.2026.
p. 6The MoU was executed among the appellants, the selling respondents, and a respondent holding a prior agreement of sale.
p. 6The appellants' counsel filed a memo for withdrawal.
p. 7The memo stated that the withdrawal was conditional on timely performance of the MoU's financial and title-clearance covenants and would not operate as a waiver of rights until all conditions were executed.
p. 7The memo also sought absolute liberty to revive, restore, or refile the appeal upon any breach of the MoU by the purchaser, the respondents, or the prior agreement holder.
pp. 7–8The prayers in the memo sought permission to withdraw and a grant of such liberty.
pp. 8–902Issues
i.1. Whether the appellants may withdraw the Regular First Appeal in view of the out-of-court settlement and MoU executed during its pendency.
pp. 6–9ii.2. Whether the appellants may be granted liberty to revive, restore, or refile the appeal in the event of a breach of the MoU.
pp. 7–903Law Applied
The appeal was instituted under Section 96 read with Order 41 Rule 1 CPC, as stated in the caption.
p. 1The court's power to permit withdrawal of an appeal and to record it as withdrawn with liberty rests on the court's procedural discretion, which the order exercises on the basis of the memo and counsel's submission.
p. 9No authority on the scope of such liberty or on the effect of conditional withdrawal is discussed.
Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96Section 41
04Reasoning
The court accepted the withdrawal memo and counsel's submission without examining the merits of the decree or the terms of the MoU, which were not placed on record as part of the order.
p. 9The settlement, which resolved the competing claims of the appellants, the selling respondents, and the prior agreement holder, was treated as removing the subject of the dispute from the appeal.
p. 6The appellants' conditional stance, expressed through the memo's reservation of rights and the liberty to revive upon breach, was incorporated into the order by granting liberty "as prayed."
pp. 7–8 · p. 9The order does not specify the procedure, forum, or time limit for any revival application, nor does it state whether the grant of liberty is confined to the appellants alone.
p. 9The court thus disposed of the appeal on the basis of the parties' consent rather than on any adjudication of the partition decree.
p. 905Holding
The court held that the appellants may withdraw the appeal in view of the multi-party settlement, and it accepted the memo of withdrawal.
p. 9The Regular First Appeal No. 361 of 2023 is dismissed as withdrawn, with liberty to the appellants to seek revival or restoration as prayed in the memo, should any party breach the MoU.
p. 9The decree of 18.11.2022 in O.S. No. 6632/2011 was not adjudicated on merits and stands subject to the terms of the withdrawal order.
p. 9Original Court PDF
MUNIYELLAMMAvsM MUNICHIKKAIAH , SINCE DEAD
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
