01Facts
The appellant-plaintiff obtained a decree in O.S. No. 130/2006 (judgment dated 10.12.2010) declaring his title to "A" schedule land, directing the defendant to deliver possession of the 0.06-guntas "B" schedule portion, and awarding current and future mesne profits from the date of suit until possession.
pp. 4, 20–21The defendant's appeal, R.A. No. 21/2010, was dismissed on 09.10.2014 and no further appeal was filed, so the decree attained finality.
p. 21The plaintiff took possession only on 26.03.2017, about 11 years after the suit was instituted (the judgment records the institution date as "35.05.2006", evidently a typographical error).
p. 21, 31The plaintiff then filed C.Mis. No. 1/2017 under Order XX Rules 12 and 18 CPC, claiming mesne profits of Rs. 6,22,600.
p. 21The respondents remained ex parte, filed no objections, did not cross-examine PW-1, and led no defence evidence.
pp. 21–22Relying on Nemichand Tavanappa Kudachi v. Jinnappa Mahadev Kudachi, the plaintiff contended that a Court Commissioner was required to determine mesne profits.
p. 23The Trial Court dismissed the petition on 02.08.2018.
p. 2, 22The First Appellate Court (R.A. No. 77/2018) dismissed the appeal as not maintainable, since the order arose from a miscellaneous petition and not a regular suit.
p. 2, 2302Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court was justified in dismissing C.Mis. No. 1/2017 without applying the Division Bench decision in Nemichand, which requires appointment of a Court Commissioner to determine mesne profits.
p. 3 · pp. 23–24 · ¶ 9ii.2. Whether the order passed in C.Mis. No. 1/2017 is a "decree" in the nature of a final decree under Order XX Rule 12(2) CPC, such that an appeal under Section 96 CPC lies, and whether the First Appellate Court erred in holding the appeal not maintainable.
p. 3 · pp. 28–32 · ¶ 13–1603Law Applied
Section 2(2) CPC defines a decree as a formal expression of adjudication that conclusively determines rights in the matters in controversy, whether preliminary or final.
pp. 29–30 · ¶ 14Order XX Rule 12(1)(b-a) and (c) CPC permit a decree for mesne profits or a direction for inquiry into mesne profits from institution of the suit until delivery of possession, and Order XX Rule 12(2) CPC requires a final decree in accordance with the result of such inquiry.
pp. 30–31 · ¶ 14–16The Division Bench decision in Nemichand Tavanappa Kudachi v. Jinnappa Mahadev Kudachi, ILR 1974 Kar 661, holds that where mesne profits involve an extensive or complex accounting, the court must appoint a Commissioner to take accounts, with objections and further reports to follow, and that failure to do so vitiates the proceedings.
pp. 25–28 · ¶ 10–11A remand is appropriate where the respondents remained ex parte and the matter requires fresh adjudication in accordance with law.
pp. 32–33 · ¶ 17Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100Section 151Section 2Section 144Section 96
04Reasoning
The Trial Court rejected the mesne profits claim without appointing a Commissioner, despite citing Nemichand and despite an unchallenged, final decree that expressly awarded mesne profits.
p. 24, 28 · ¶ 9, 12The respondents had not contested the petition, so the plaintiff's evidence stood uncontroverted.
p. 28 · ¶ 12The Court held that the mesne profits in issue were not simple, because the accounting covered an 11-year period, and that Nemichand required a Commissioner for such an exercise.
p. 28 · ¶ 11On maintainability, the Court reasoned that the C.Mis. order was not an interlocutory order but a final adjudication of the appellant's right to mesne profits under the decree. It therefore fell within the scope of a "final decree" under Order XX Rule 12(2) CPC and was appealable under Section 96 CPC.
pp. 31–32 · ¶ 16The First Appellate Court's dismissal as not maintainable was therefore erroneous.
p. 32 · ¶ 16Because both lower courts erred and the respondents never contested the proceedings, the Court considered that the matter should be re-examined by the Trial Court in accordance with Nemichand rather than decided on appeal.
pp. 32–33 · ¶ 1705Holding
Both substantial questions of law were answered in favour of the appellant.
p. 32The Trial Court's dismissal of C.Mis. No. 1/2017 without appointing a Court Commissioner, and the First Appellate Court's holding that the appeal was not maintainable, were both set aside. The matter is remitted to the Trial Court for fresh consideration in accordance with law and with due regard to Nemichand Tavanappa Kudachi. The appellant is directed to appear before the Trial Court on 07.12.2026 without awaiting further notice. The appeal is allowed.
pp. 32–34 · ¶ 17–18(ii) · p. 34, orders (i), (iii), (iv)Original Court PDF
SRI. B K NAGESH GOWDAvsB R NAGARAJ
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
