01Facts
The first respondent (plaintiff) sued in O.S. No. 76/2010 for partition and separate possession of his alleged share in the suit schedule properties, along with declaratory and consequential reliefs.
The appellant was defendant No. 6.
p. 6The trial court (Senior Civil Judge, Nanjangud) decreed the suit on 06.10.2017.
p. 6The appellant and defendants 1 to 4 appealed in R.A. No. 246/2017.
p. 6The First Appellate Court (IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Mysuru) dismissed the appeal on 14.03.2019 but modified the trial court's quantification of the parties' shares.
p. 6The appellant then filed the present RSA under Section 100 CPC, which was admitted to consider five substantial questions of law: limitation; compliance with Order XLI Rule 31 CPC; ouster of the plaintiff; bona fide purchaser status of defendant No. 6 for 20 guntas; and the correctness of the share quantification under Section 6 and/or Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act.
p. 7The trial court framed eight issues and recorded evidence of PW1 and DW1 to DW3.
pp. 8–9The First Appellate Court framed only three points for determination.
p. 8Respondent No. 1 and the appellant each consented to remand, subject to liberty to lead additional evidence.
pp. 13–1402Issues
i.1. Whether the First Appellate Court's judgment complies with the mandate of Order XLI Rule 31 CPC, having regard to the adequacy of its points for determination, its decision on them, and its reasons.
pp. 8, 10–12ii.2. Whether the impugned judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court, being contrary to the material on record and to Order XLI Rule 31 CPC, requires to be set aside and the matter remitted.
pp. 12–13iii.3. Whether the substantial questions of law framed on limitation, ouster, bona fide purchaser status, and quantification of shares (SQ Nos. 1, 3, 4, 5) are required to be decided at this stage.
pp. 7, 13–1403Law Applied
Order XLI Rule 31 CPC requires an appellate judgment to state the points for determination, the decision thereon, the reasons for the decision, and, where the decree is reversed or varied, the relief to which the appellant is entitled.
p. 10The Supreme Court's decision in Malluru Mallappa (dead) through LRs v. Kuruvathappa & Ors., (2020) 4 SCC 313, holds that a first appellate court must set out points for determination, record its decision, and give its own reasons, even when affirming the trial court; general agreement with the trial court's reasons suffices where the appellate court concurs on the evidence, but non-compliance with Order XLI Rule 31 renders the judgment infirm.
pp. 11–12Section 107 CPC (cited in the text as "Section 207"), read with Order XLI Rule 23A and Order XLI Rule 33 CPC, empowers the High Court in second appeal to remand a matter for fresh disposal and to direct further evidence or proceedings.
p. 14Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100Section 107
04Reasoning
The Court compared the First Appellate Court's three points with the eight trial issues and the rival pleadings and found that the points did not address the contentions or issues actually in dispute.
pp. 9–10The First Appellate Court's framing therefore failed the "points for determination" requirement, and its decision and reasons on those points were found to be contrary to the mandate in Malluru Mallappa.
p. 12Because the first appellate court is ordinarily the final fact-finding court and must re-appreciate the evidence, the defect went to the root of the appellate decision, rendering the impugned judgment unsustainable irrespective of its merits. The Court did not examine the substantial questions on merits.
pp. 12–1305Holding
The Court answered the first two issues in the affirmative. The First Appellate Court's judgment does not comply with Order XLI Rule 31 CPC, and it is contrary to the material on record.
pp. 12–13The RSA is allowed. The judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court are set aside, and R.A. No. 246/2017 is remitted for fresh disposal in accordance with law. All rival contentions on merits, including the five substantial questions, are kept open and no opinion is expressed on them.
p. 14The parties (the appellant and respondent No. 1) must appear before the First Appellate Court on 14.12.2026 without further notice. The First Appellate Court is to issue notice to the remaining defendants and dispose of the appeal afresh. Liberty is reserved to all parties to adduce additional oral and documentary evidence, and the trial court records are to be transmitted forthwith.
p. 15Original Court PDF
SRI. T. R. RAVIvsSRI. KRISHNAMURTHY T.K.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
