01Facts
The petitioners challenged the Deputy Commissioner’s memoranda dated 28 February 2022 and 13 February 2025, which earmarked seven acres in Government gomal land in Sy. No. 111, Ramasagara Village, for a solid-waste management unit and sewage treatment plant (STP) serving Hebbagodi CMC, Bommasandra TMC and Chandapura TMC
pp. 13, 20–21 · ¶ 1, 9The petitioners—schools, residents’ associations and local residents—objected that the land was grazing land, that nearby residents had not been consulted, and that homes and schools were close to the proposed site.
pp. 15–17 · ¶ 4–6The State and the project authorities relied on the public purpose of the STP, the NGT proceedings directing action, and the steps taken towards securing regulatory approvals
pp. 18–20 · ¶ 7–802Issues
i.1. Whether the authorities could earmark gomal land for the proposed STP without first consulting or hearing nearby villagers
pp. 21–22 · ¶ 9–10ii.2. Whether the memoranda were invalid because the authorities had not obtained environmental clearance or completed the requirements under the applicable environmental notification before earmarking the land
pp. 15–16, 22 · ¶ 4–5, 10iii.3. Whether the earmarking of gomal land for the STP was unlawful under Section 71 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act and Rule 97 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules
pp. 16–17, 23–25 · ¶ 5–6, 1203Law Applied
Section 71 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964, and Rule 97 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules, 1966, do not impose an absolute bar on reducing or diverting land set apart for cattle grazing; the authorities may balance grazing needs against other essential public requirements.
pp. 23–25 · ¶ 12The Court relied on T.V. Narayanasamy v. State of Karnataka, ILR 2018 KAR 3447, which held that gomal land may be used for another public-welfare purpose where the decision reflects a reasonable balance of competing needs.
pp. 23–25 · ¶ 12The Court also considered the environmental-clearance requirements under the Notification dated 14 September 2006, holding that the relevant requirements under clauses 2 and 7 arise before environmental clearance and after the land has been secured for the project.
p. 22 · ¶ 10Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA INLAND FISHERIES (CONSERVATION DEVELOPMENT AND REGULATION) ACT, 1996 Section 3
04Reasoning
The Court found that the land had been identified for the STP pursuant to NGT proceedings and after consideration of its feasibility by the State-level committee; the project was also supported by State funding and steps towards obtaining Pollution Control Board approvals.
pp. 21–23 · ¶ 10–11It rejected the argument that environmental clearance had to precede the land being secured, reasoning that the relevant clearance requirements applied at a later stage.
p. 22 · ¶ 10Applying T.V. Narayanasamy, the Court treated the STP as an essential public-health and environmental measure and found no absolute rule preventing the use of gomal land for such a purpose.
pp. 22–26 · ¶ 11–13It also considered the respondents’ material on the distance of nearby schools and residences from the proposed site and found the petitioners’ proximity objection unpersuasive.
pp. 26–27 · ¶ 1405Holding
The Court held that the petitioners had not established grounds to interfere with the memoranda earmarking the land for the STP.
p. 27 · ¶ 15It dismissed the writ petition and granted no relief.
p. 27 · ¶ 15Original Court PDF
ST JOSEPHS CHAMINADE ACADEMYvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
