Facts
The Appellants, acting as unsecured financial creditors and homebuyers of the Corporate Debtor (M/s. Lokaa Developer Pvt. Ltd.), challenged an order dated 28.10.2025 passed by the Adjudicating Authority (NCLT).
Source reference: p. 3The impugned order approved a Resolution Plan submitted by the "Mone Flat Owners Association" under Section 30(6) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).
Source reference: para. 3The Appellants filed their appeals electronically on 13.12.2025.
Source reference: para. 4They contended that the limitation period should be calculated from 30.10.2025, the date the order was uploaded on the NCLT e-portal, rather than the date of pronouncement.
Source reference: para. 5The Registry reported a delay of 16 days, while the Appellants sought condonation for 14 days, asserting the delay was due to time taken to obtain the order and seek legal advice.
Source reference: para. 4-5Notably, the Appellants did not apply for a certified copy of the order and instead sought an exemption from filing it.
Source reference: para. 10-11Issues
1. Whether the limitation period for filing an appeal under Section 61 of the IBC commences from the date of pronouncement of the order or the date of uploading/knowledge of the order.
Source reference: para. 7, 162. Whether the Appellate Tribunal has the statutory authority to condone a delay that exceeds the 15-day period prescribed under the proviso to Section 61(2) of the IBC.
Source reference: para. 12, 18Law Applied
The court primarily applied Section 61(2) of the IBC, which mandates that appeals must be filed within 30 days, with a proviso allowing a maximum extension of only 15 days upon showing sufficient cause.
Source reference: para. 12It relied on the Supreme Court precedent in V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat and Power Limited, which clarifies that the IBC framework does not link limitation to the receipt of a certified copy, but rather to the date of pronouncement.
Source reference: para. 13The court further cited A. Rajendra v. Gonugunta Madhusudhan Rao and Ashdan Properties Pvt. Ltd. v. DSK Global Education and Research Pvt. Ltd., affirming that limitation starts from the date of pronouncement in open court, and relief under Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act (excluding time for preparing a certified copy) is only available if an application for a certified copy was made within the initial limitation period.
Source reference: para. 13, 16Reasoning
The Tribunal determined that since the order was pronounced on 28.10.2025, the 30-day limitation period ended on 27.11.2025.
Source reference: para. 7, 9Including the maximum condonable period of 15 days, the absolute deadline to file the appeal was 12.12.2025.
Source reference: para. 9The Appellants filed the appeal on 13.12.2025, which was the 46th day.
Source reference: para. 18The Tribunal rejected the plea to calculate limitation from the date of uploading (30.10.2025), noting that as members of the Committee of Creditors (CoC), the Appellants were deemed to have knowledge of the proceedings and the pronouncement.
Source reference: para. 6, 14Furthermore, because the Appellants failed to even apply for a certified copy, they were ineligible for any time exclusion under the Limitation Act.
Source reference: para. 11, 13The Tribunal emphasized that Section 61(2) is a self-contained provision with a strict "upper limit" of 45 days, leaving the court with no jurisdiction to condone a delay of even a single day beyond that threshold.
Source reference: para. 12, 18Holding
The Tribunal held that the appeals were barred by limitation as they were preferred on the 46th day from the date of pronouncement.
The court answered that limitation under Section 61(2) of the IBC commences from the date of pronouncement in open court and not from the date of uploading.
Source reference: para. 17Consequently, IA Nos. 135 & 142/2026 (for condonation of delay) were rejected, and Company Appeals (AT) (CH) (INS) Nos. 54 & 56 / 2026 were dismissed as barred by limitation.
Source reference: para. 18Original Court PDF
Harish ShahvsRamakrishnan Sadasivan Resolution Professional Of M/S. Lokaa Developer Pvt Ltd
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in