01Facts
The appellant was convicted by the Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Salem, under Sections 366 and 376(1) IPC for taking the victim, with whom he had a relationship, and having sexual intercourse with her on multiple occasions.
pp. 1–3The trial court acquitted him of the charge under Section 450 IPC and imposed concurrent sentences of seven years’ rigorous imprisonment under Section 366 and ten years’ rigorous imprisonment under Section 376(1).
pp. 1–3The prosecution relied on an ossification-test certificate estimating her age as above 14 and below 16 years, and on her parents’ estimates that she was about 15.
pp. 4, 8–902Issues
i.Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the victim was under 16 years of age, such that her consent was immaterial and the appellant committed rape under Section 375 IPC as it stood at the time of the occurrence.
pp. 7–9ii.Whether the appellant’s conviction under Section 366 IPC should be upheld and, if so, whether the sentence should be reduced.
p. 903Law Applied
Under Section 375 IPC as applicable to the 2010 occurrences, sexual intercourse with or without consent constituted rape if the victim was under 16 years of age.
pp. 6–8An age estimate based on radiological or ossification examination is not exact; a sufficient margin must be allowed, and resulting reasonable doubt about the victim’s age must benefit the accused.
p. 8The Court relied on Rajak Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2018) 9 SCC 248, for that principle.
p. 8For Section 366 IPC, the Court treated the victim’s consent to marriage as immaterial because she was below 18, and upheld the conviction on its finding that the appellant took her to his house knowing it was likely she would be compelled to marry against her will.
p. 9Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 363Section 366Section 375Section 376Section 450
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 313
04Reasoning
The evidence indicated that the victim’s relationship with the appellant and the sexual acts were consensual; her medical examination disclosed no external injuries, and she reported intercourse with a known person.
pp. 5–6But consent could not defeat the Section 375 charge if she was under 16.
pp. 8–9The prosecution’s age evidence did not conclusively establish that threshold: the ossification certificate placed her age between 14 and 16, while her parents gave approximate estimates.
pp. 8–9Applying the required margin of error, the Court found reasonable doubt as to whether she was under 16 and therefore held that rape was not proved.
pp. 8–9It nevertheless found the elements of Section 366 established and considered the custody already served sufficient in the circumstances.
p. 905Holding
The appeal was partly allowed.
p. 10The appellant was acquitted of the charge under Section 376(1) IPC, and any fine paid for that offence was ordered to be refunded.
p. 10The conviction under Section 366 IPC was confirmed, but the substantive sentence was reduced to the period already undergone; the fine for that offence remained unchanged.
p. 10Any bail bond was discharged.
p. 10Original Court PDF
CHINNAPAIYANvsTHE STATE REP BY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
