Madras High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Madras HC Declines to Strike Down Transfer Route for Assistant Engineers, Orders Direct Recruitment of Graduates to Reserved Posts

G. NAGRAJANv.THE GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU

Madras HC Declines to Strike Down Transfer Route for Assistant Engineers, Orders Direct Recruitment of Graduates to Reserved Posts. G. NAGRAJAN vs THE GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether persons outside the service (aspirants) have locus to challenge service rules that open promotional/transfer avenues to in-service candidates.

The court held

The Court held that aspirants outside the service generally cannot challenge the promotional/transfer avenues in the Special Rules.

It also directed

The Court declined to declare Rules 2(a) and 3 illegal or to cancel the transfer-based appointments, as that would unsettle a settled position.

The writ petitions were disposed of, and the connected M.P.s were closed without costs.

The Court directed the respondents to: (a) determine the number of substantive AE (Agricultural Engineering) posts and the number reserved for Engineering graduates to be filled through TNPSC; (b) fill any such slots not filled by direct-recruit graduates through TNPSC by direct recruitment; (c) create supernumerary posts for incumbents occupying direct-recruitment slots, to be absorbed through the catch-up principle as transfer slots fall vacant; and (d) commence the direct-recruitment process within two months of receipt of the order and complete it within nine months thereafter.

01Facts

The petitioner in W.P. No. 34990/2007 is a Scheduled Caste B.E. (Agricultural Engineering) graduate of 1993 who has not secured appointment as Assistant Engineer (AE).

¶ 3

The petitioner in W.P. No. 37033/2007 is the President of the Confederation of Agricultural Engineers, representing unemployed Agricultural Engineering graduates.

¶ 4

Both petitioners challenge Rule 2(a) and Rule 3 of the Special Rules for the Tamil Nadu Agricultural Engineering Service, insofar as they permit appointment of AEs by "recruitment by transfer" from Assistant Soil Conservation Officers, Junior Draughtsmen and Agricultural Engineering Foremen.

¶ 3–4 · p. 13

The petitioners relied on G.O.Ms.No.582 (09.11.1995), which fixed a 24:1 and then 91:9 direct-recruitment-to-transfer ratio with retrospective effect from 27.12.1990.

¶ 16–19

The petitioners relied on G.O.Ms.No.431 (22.10.1996), which re-designated Junior Engineers as AEs on acquiring a B.E. degree and fixed their seniority.

¶ 20

The petitioners relied on G.O.Ms.No.533 (14.12.2004).

¶ 21–22

The petitioners relied on G.O.Ms.No.479 (16.11.2007), which re-designated 399 ASCOs as Junior Engineers.

¶ 5

The petitioners alleged that no direct recruitment of B.E. graduates to AE posts had occurred for about ten years.

¶ 5

The State, through the Chief Engineer's counter-affidavit, stated that the direct-recruitment process through TNPSC had been stayed in W.P. No. 4816 of 2008, and that the re-designations were administrative decisions to address stagnation.

¶ 6–10

The State further contended that the petitioners, not being in service, lacked locus.

¶ 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether persons outside the service (aspirants) have locus to challenge service rules that open promotional/transfer avenues to in-service candidates.

¶ 9, 27, 33

ii.2. Whether Rule 2(a) and Rule 3 of the Special Rules, and the amendments permitting recruitment by transfer and re-designation, are arbitrary, discriminatory, or violative of Articles 14, 16, 309 and 335 of the Constitution.

¶ 13, 24–25

iii.3. Whether all AEs appointed by recruitment by transfer after 19.07.1994 are illegal, and whether their posts must be notified for direct recruitment through TNPSC.

¶ 25

iv.4. Whether the petitioners are entitled to the relief of direct recruitment, and if so, in what form.

¶ 33–34

03Law Applied

The Court located the State's power to frame service rules in Article 309 of the Constitution, which is subject to Articles 14 and 16; rules that are arbitrary or discriminatory are open to judicial review under Article 226.

¶ 24

The petitioners also invoked Article 335 and Section 5 of the Tamil Nadu Reservation Act, 1993, which the Court noted but did not separately decide.

¶ 3, 13

K. Narayanan v. State of Karnataka (1994 Suppl (1) SCC 44) held that a policy decision is not interfered with unless the rule-making authority acted arbitrarily or violated Articles 14 and 16, and struck down the retrospective operation of a rule that caused inequality between direct recruits and promotees.

¶ 30–31

B. Thirumal v. Ananda Sivakumar (2014) 16 SCC 593 held that degree-holder Junior Engineers redesignated as AEs remain members of the subordinate service and may be considered only against the quota reserved for that service.

¶ 32

The general principle that challenges to service rules by persons outside the service are ordinarily not sustainable, and that re-designation for administrative reasons lies beyond judicial review, was drawn from these authorities and the Court's own reasoning.

¶ 33

Provisions in the judgment · 4

A.M.I.E. AB

Tamil Nadu Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of Seats in Educational Institutions and of Appointments or Posts in the Services under the State) Act, 1993 Section 5

Tamil Nadu Services Manual, 1969 Section 38

04Reasoning

The Court held that the petitioners had made out a prima facie case, because the direct-recruitment quota for B.E. graduates had been drastically reduced through successive amendments and the quota had not been filled through TNPSC for years.

¶ 25

The Court distinguished K. Narayanan, since that case involved in-service employees challenging retrospective seniority rules, whereas the present petitioners are outsiders seeking to reverse appointments made over twelve years.

¶ 27, 29–30

Applying B. Thirumal, the Court accepted that providing promotional or transfer avenues to in-service candidates cannot ordinarily be challenged by aspirants.

¶ 33

The Court nonetheless found "continuous deprivation" of the opportunity for unemployed graduates to participate in selection, arising from multiple amendments and the State's failure to hold periodic direct recruitment.

¶ 33–34

Because a declaration voiding all transfer-based appointments since 1994 would unsettle a settled position, the Court declined that relief, but used its remedial power to direct a structured restoration of direct-recruitment slots.

¶ 34

The Court's approach balanced the prima facie illegality of the quota erosion against the disruption and equity concerns of in-service incumbents, who were to be accommodated through supernumerary posts and the "catch-up" principle rather than removed.

¶ 34

05Holding

The Court held that aspirants outside the service generally cannot challenge the promotional/transfer avenues in the Special Rules.

¶ 33

The Court declined to declare Rules 2(a) and 3 illegal or to cancel the transfer-based appointments, as that would unsettle a settled position.

¶ 34

The writ petitions were disposed of, and the connected M.P.s were closed without costs.

¶ 35

The Court directed the respondents to: (a) determine the number of substantive AE (Agricultural Engineering) posts and the number reserved for Engineering graduates to be filled through TNPSC; (b) fill any such slots not filled by direct-recruit graduates through TNPSC by direct recruitment; (c) create supernumerary posts for incumbents occupying direct-recruitment slots, to be absorbed through the catch-up principle as transfer slots fall vacant; and (d) commence the direct-recruitment process within two months of receipt of the order and complete it within nine months thereafter.

¶ 34
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

G. NAGRAJANvsTHE GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU

Madras High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment