01Facts
The petitioner sought a mandamus directing the Railways to provide Battery Operated Car services, free of cost, for passengers requiring mobility assistance at stations in the Tiruchirappalli and Madurai Divisions.
pp. 1–2He also sought pickup-point signage, compliance with Railway Board Commercial Circular Nos. 38/2009 and 39/2018, and effective grievance-redressal mechanisms.
pp. 1–2The Railways stated that such services were already operating at several stations in both divisions, but that provision at every station depended on factors including station category, passenger footfall, platform configuration and infrastructure.
pp. 3–402Issues
i.1. Whether the Railways should be directed to provide Battery Operated Car services at stations in the Tiruchirappalli and Madurai Divisions where the services were not then available.
pp. 4–5ii.2. Whether operational feasibility, passenger footfall and station infrastructure justified not extending the service to those stations.
p. 403Law Applied
The petition invoked the High Court’s jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.
p. 1The Court stated that Indian Railways, as a public service provider, has an obligation to take appropriate measures to make railway facilities accessible, particularly for persons with disabilities and senior citizens.
p. 4The judgment cited no specific statutory provision or precedent as the basis for this principle.
Although the petitioner relied on Railway Board Commercial Circular Nos. 38/2009 and 39/2018, the Court’s directions did not expressly interpret or apply those circulars.
pp. 1–2, 5–604Reasoning
The Court treated access to platforms and coaches as a significant concern for passengers with restricted mobility, particularly given trains’ limited halting times.
p. 4It held that operational feasibility, passenger footfall and infrastructure considerations could not, by themselves, justify withholding Battery Operated Car services from stations where they were absent.
pp. 4–5Having regard to the accessibility needs of affected passengers and the Railways’ public-service obligation, the Court found the grievance genuine and considered the requested relief warranted.
pp. 4–505Holding
The Court directed the respondents to provide Battery Operated Car services at all stations in the Tiruchirappalli and Madurai Divisions where the facilities had not yet been provided, and to ensure their effective functioning, monitoring and maintenance.
pp. 5–6The exercise was to be completed within six months from receipt of a copy of the judgment.
p. 6The petition was disposed of without costs.
p. 6The operative directions do not separately address the requests for free service, pickup-point signage or grievance-redressal mechanisms.
pp. 5–6Original Court PDF
Sundara Vimal Nathan alias Swamimalai Sundara Vimal NathanvsUnion of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
