01Facts
The plaintiffs brought a partition suit seeking allotment of 714 sq. ft. in the suit property and permanent injunction. During trial, the defendant/petitioner disputed a copy of a deed dated 21 June 2002 confirming an oral partition. In 2018, the High Court rejected the plaintiffs’ application to mark that document through the petitioner, while leaving them free to seek to mark it through their own witness.
p. 4 · p. 7Later, a typed set containing nine documents, including the disputed deed, was marked as Ex.P.11 during the evidence of D.W.1. The petitioner applied to have Ex.P.11 eschewed; the trial court dismissed the application. In this revision under Article 227, the High Court examined the trial record and found that the disputed deed had in fact been marked through D.W.2, not D.W.1.
pp. 8–1202Issues
i.1. Whether Ex.P.11, including the disputed deed dated 21 June 2002, should be eschewed because it was allegedly marked through D.W.1 in breach of the High Court’s 2018 order.
pp. 10–12ii.2. Whether the trial court’s refusal to eschew Ex.P.11 warranted interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.
p. 1203Law Applied
Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (now Section 148 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023) permits a witness to be confronted with a prior written statement to establish a contradiction; the document must be put to the witness and the contradiction elicited. Such use is principally directed at impeaching the witness’s credit, rather than proving the document’s contents as substantive evidence.
p. 9The evidentiary value and proof of a marked document remain open to assessment by the trial court; marking alone does not determine those questions.
pp. 11–12Under Article 227, interference was not warranted absent a finding that the trial court’s order was perverse or illegal.
p. 12Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 Section 148
04Reasoning
The High Court criticised the marking of nine independent documents together as a single exhibit, particularly during cross-examination of D.W.1 without identifying any contradiction sought to be elicited.
pp. 8–10However, the record showed that the disputed deed was marked through D.W.2, who admitted its existence and supported the plaintiffs’ case—not through D.W.1 as alleged. The marking therefore did not violate the 2018 order, which had barred marking the deed through D.W.1 but left open its production through the plaintiffs’ witness. The trial court could independently assess the deed’s relevance, proof and evidentiary value, so the refusal to eschew it was not perverse or illegal.
pp. 10–1205Holding
The High Court sustained the trial court’s order dismissing the application to eschew Ex.P.11 and disposed of the revision petition.
p. 12It left the petitioner free to challenge the disputed deed’s evidentiary value before the trial court, which was to consider that question on its merits and in accordance with law. No costs were awarded; the connected miscellaneous petition was closed.
p. 12Original Court PDF
V.RADHAKRISHNANvsCHITHRA BALAKRISHNAN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
