Madras High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceAdministrative and Public Law

Madras HC Upholds Witness Recall In Namakkal Property Suit, But Evidence From Another Suit Is Not Automatically Admitted

Lakshmi Krishnasamyv.C.P.Nagarajan

Madras HC Upholds Witness Recall In Namakkal Property Suit, But Evidence From Another Suit Is Not Automatically Admitted. Lakshmi Krishnasamy vs C.P.Nagarajan. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

Whether the trial court’s order recalling PW1 for further examination-in-chief and permitting the plaintiff to seek to mark evidence from an earlier suit warranted interference under Article 227

The court held

The High Court sustained the trial court’s order and disposed of the revision petition, clarifying that the proposed document was not automatically admissible and that the trial court must consider any objections to it.

It also directed

The trial court was directed to dispose of O.S. No. 162 of 2018 within four months of receiving the order. No costs were awarded, and the connected miscellaneous petition was closed

01Facts

The first respondent/plaintiff sought a declaration of title and recovery of possession in O.S. No. 162 of 2018.

While the defendants’ evidence was underway, the plaintiff applied under Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC to recall PW1 for further examination-in-chief and to seek to mark evidence recorded in an earlier suit.

pp. 4–6

The trial court allowed the application, stating that the proposed document would not be acted upon automatically and that its relevance and proof would be considered when disposing of the suit.

pp. 4–6

Certain defendants challenged that order under Article 227, arguing that, after a summoned witness failed to appear and a warrant was returned with the endorsement “Door Locked,” the trial court should have followed the procedure in Order XVI Rule 10 CPC

pp. 4–6

02Issues

i.Whether the trial court’s order recalling PW1 for further examination-in-chief and permitting the plaintiff to seek to mark evidence from an earlier suit warranted interference under Article 227

pp. 4–6

ii.Whether allowing the recall application meant that the proposed document would be admitted or acted upon without the defendants’ objections to its relevance, proof, and admissibility being considered

pp. 6–7

03Law Applied

Article 227 of the Constitution provides the basis for the High Court’s supervisory review of the trial court’s order.

pp. 4–7

Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC was the procedural provision invoked for recalling PW1; the Court treated permission to recall the witness for further examination-in-chief as distinct from a determination that the proposed document was admissible or proved.

pp. 4–7

The petitioners relied on Order XVI Rule 10 CPC concerning the procedure where a witness fails to comply with summons, but the Court did not decide whether that provision required further steps in this case

pp. 4–7

04Reasoning

The High Court found that the trial court had only permitted PW1 to be recalled and had expressly reserved consideration of the proposed document’s relevance and proof until the suit was decided.

pp. 6–7

Accordingly, allowing the application did not itself establish that the document could be marked or relied upon. The defendants remained entitled to object to its relevance, proof, and admissibility, and the trial court was required to decide those objections when raised. This clarification adequately protected the defendants’ rights, so the Court found no basis to disturb the order

pp. 6–7

05Holding

The High Court sustained the trial court’s order and disposed of the revision petition, clarifying that the proposed document was not automatically admissible and that the trial court must consider any objections to it.

p. 7

The trial court was directed to dispose of O.S. No. 162 of 2018 within four months of receiving the order. No costs were awarded, and the connected miscellaneous petition was closed

p. 7
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

Lakshmi KrishnasamyvsC.P.Nagarajan

Madras High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment