01Facts
The plaintiff sought a declaration of title and permanent injunction over 5.04 cents in Survey No. 64/1B1.
¶ 1–4, 9–10The defendant claimed title to a larger extent, tracing it through a different chain of succession and a 2021 sale deed.
¶ 1–4, 9–10During the suit, the plaintiff applied for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner, with a qualified surveyor, to measure and identify the suit property and distinguish it from property involved in earlier litigation.
¶ 1–4, 9–10The Trial Court dismissed the application, reasoning that surveying the properties could cause confusion.
¶ 1–4, 9–10The plaintiff challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1–4, 9–1002Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court’s refusal to appoint an Advocate Commissioner to measure and identify the suit property warranted interference under Article 227
¶ 1–2, 10–12ii.2. Whether a commission could be used in this case to establish the plaintiff’s title or resolve the parties’ competing title claims
¶ 10–1203Law Applied
The Court considered the revision under Article 227 of the Constitution, under which it assessed whether the Trial Court’s order warranted supervisory interference.
¶ 1It stated that an Advocate Commissioner’s inspection and measurement may assist the court where local investigation is needed to clarify property identity or boundaries, but a commission cannot be used to collect evidence or trace or establish a party’s title; title must be proved through the relevant title deeds and revenue records.
¶ 11–1204Reasoning
The Court found that the dispute was essentially about both title and the identity of the property.
¶ 10Although the plaintiff sought measurement to distinguish the suit property from property involved in earlier proceedings, the plaintiff was required to establish his title through the documents on which he relied.
¶ 11–12Measuring the property could not prove that title, and the commission sought could not be used to trace it.
¶ 11–12The Court therefore found no basis to interfere with the Trial Court’s refusal to appoint a Commissioner.
¶ 1205Holding
The Court dismissed the Civil Revision Petition, holding that the Trial Court rightly dismissed the application for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner.
¶ 13It made no order as to costs and closed the connected miscellaneous petition.
¶ 13Original Court PDF
M.K.Peer Mohammed,vsSelvanayaki,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
