01Facts
The respondent-plaintiff’s partition suit, seeking a one-fifth share, was dismissed in 2017. On appeal, the decree was set aside and the suit remanded in 2019 to enable the plaintiff to implead necessary parties and include the remaining properties.
¶ 4, 32–33The petitioners, defendants 5–9, applied to restore the witness’s former rank and correct the witness and document numbering. The trial court dismissed the application, reasoning that the evidence was being taken afresh following remand.
¶ 5–602Issues
i.1. Whether, on a remand under Order XLI Rule 23A of the Code of Civil Procedure, evidence recorded before remand is wiped out and the matter must proceed as a de novo trial.
¶ 7, 25–29ii.2. Whether a witness examined before remand should retain the same rank when recalled, and whether documents already marked must be marked again.
¶ 5, 34–3503Law Applied
Order XLI Rule 23A CPC empowers an appellate court to remand a case disposed of otherwise than on a preliminary point where the decree is reversed and a retrial is considered necessary; the High Court held that “retrial” under Rule 23A does not, by itself, mean a de novo trial or extinguish evidence already on record.
¶ 15, 25–29The Court distinguished Rule 23’s express provision concerning the use of evidence after remand, but held that in a Rule 23A remand the earlier evidence remains available unless the remand order directs otherwise.
¶ 25–29Relying on Satyajit Banerjee v. State of West Bengal, (2005) 1 SCC 115, the Court noted that a retrial does not erase evidence already recorded; the case is decided on that evidence together with any additional evidence.
¶ 21The Court also relied on Sanatan Mohapatra v. Hakim Mohammad Kazim Mohammad, AIR 1977 Orissa 194, for the principle that the trial court should focus further evidence on the matters identified in the remand order.
¶ 20, 30–31Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151Section 105
delhi rent control act, 1958 Section 15
04Reasoning
The appellate court had remanded the suit to permit the plaintiff to implead parties and include properties; it had not directed that the earlier evidence be expunged or that the suit undergo a de novo trial.
¶ 32–33The High Court therefore treated evidence recorded before remand as continuing to form part of the record and any evidence taken afterwards as additional evidence. It directed the trial court to consider the purpose of the remand when receiving further evidence, retain the existing rank of witnesses recalled for further evidence, and assign new ranks only to additional witnesses.
¶ 29–34Since the documents already marked remained on record, they did not require re-marking; only newly introduced documents were to receive new serial numbers.
¶ 3505Holding
The High Court allowed the revision and set aside the trial court’s order.
¶ 35It directed the trial court to retain the pre-remand evidence and existing document markings, record further evidence of previously examined witnesses under their original ranks, assign new ranks to new witnesses, and consider the earlier and additional evidence together. The trial court was directed to deliver judgment within four months, keeping the appellate court’s remand purpose in view.
¶ 35Original Court PDF
ANDALAMMALvsDJEALATCHOUMY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
