01Facts
The petitioners, plaintiffs in O.S. No. 336 of 2013, sought permanent and mandatory injunctions.
pp. 2–4While the suit was at the stage of examining defence witnesses, they applied under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend the plaint’s property description on the basis of a digital surveyor’s report.
pp. 2–4The trial court dismissed the application, finding that the proposed amendment was sought after more than thirteen years and relied on a report that contradicted the Advocate Commissioner’s report, which had been marked as Exhibits C1 and C2.
pp. 2–4The plaintiffs challenged that dismissal under Article 227 of the Constitution.
pp. 2–402Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court’s refusal to permit amendment of the plaint’s property description, at the stage of defence evidence and on the basis of a digital surveyor’s report, warranted interference under Article 227
pp. 3–6ii.2. Whether the property’s extent and any encroachment should instead be determined at trial on the evidence and the Advocate Commissioner’s report, with further clarification available if required
pp. 5–603Law Applied
Order VI Rule 17 CPC governs amendment of pleadings; Article 227 of the Constitution provides the supervisory jurisdiction invoked in the revision.
p. 2The Court’s reasoning also applied the principles that the property description as at the date of suit is material, that an Advocate Commissioner’s report is a piece of evidence rather than a conclusive determination, and that the trial court must decide the suit on the evidence adduced.
pp. 5–6The judgment cited no precedents.
pp. 2, 5–604Reasoning
The proposed amendment sought to change the property description more than thirteen years after the suit was filed and relied on a digital surveyor’s report that was not among the marked documents and contradicted the Advocate Commissioner’s report.
pp. 5–6The Court held that the trial court had correctly refused the amendment.
pp. 5–6The extent of any encroachment should be decided on the evidence and the Commissioner’s report; if clarification is needed, the trial court may seek a further report.
pp. 5–6The Commissioner’s report does not itself finally determine the suit.
pp. 5–605Holding
The Court sustained the trial court’s order dismissing the amendment application and dismissed the civil revision petition.
p. 6No costs were awarded, and the connected miscellaneous petition was closed.
p. 6Original Court PDF
Backialakshmi (Died) 1.M.VENNALvsN.Vekitasamy Naidu alias Thambu,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
