01Facts
M/s. Varadha Steels Private Limited defaulted on financial assistance from the bank. The bank initiated recovery proceedings and issued a sale notice for property belonging to guarantor A.T. Heera Banu. She challenged the notice before the DRT, which permitted the auction to proceed but stayed confirmation of the sale.
pp. 4–5At the auction, C.B. Rajender was declared the highest bidder at ₹5.30 crore and paid the bid amount, despite being informed that confirmation was stayed.
pp. 4–5, 12The bank later withdrew the sale notice, citing defects, and the DRT disposed of the guarantor’s application and directed the bank to consider redemption. It subsequently permitted redemption for ₹5.30 crore. The DRAT set aside that redemption order and, in the auction purchaser’s appeal, declined to require completion of the sale, awarding him ₹5 lakh compensation.
pp. 5–7Both the guarantor and auction purchaser challenged the DRAT’s orders.
pp. 5–702Issues
i.Whether the auction purchaser acquired a concluded sale or vested right to the property, notwithstanding the DRT’s order staying confirmation of the sale.
pp. 14–16, 19–20ii.Whether the guarantor was entitled to redeem the property for ₹5.30 crore, and what steps the bank could take following withdrawal of the sale notice.
pp. 17–2103Law Applied
Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act permits a secured creditor to take measures including sale of secured assets following the borrower’s default.
p. 13Section 13(8), as applied by the Court, permits redemption by tendering the secured creditor’s dues and related costs before publication of the public-auction notice; where the sale notice has been withdrawn and no fresh notice issued, the guarantor may tender the amount due before a fresh notice is issued.
p. 20Rules 8 and 9 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 govern the sale of immovable secured assets, including valuation, sale notice, confirmation, and issuance of the sale certificate.
pp. 13–15The Court also relied on Mathew Varghese v. M. Amritha Kumar, (2014) 5 SCC 610, observing that where court intervention affects sale proceedings, the auction purchaser’s rights crystallise in accordance with the Court’s final order.
p. 20The auction-sale authorities cited by the purchaser were distinguished because, unlike those cases, confirmation here had been stayed.
pp. 19–20Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 Section 13
Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 60
04Reasoning
The DRT had stayed confirmation before the auction and the bank expressly informed the purchaser that the sale could not be confirmed. His payment of the bid amount therefore did not, by itself, conclude the sale or create a vested right; he could have sought impleadment and a determination by the DRT but did not do so.
pp. 15–16, 19–20The bank then withdrew the sale notice, acknowledging discrepancies in the property description and extent, while the guarantor’s challenges to the notice—including valuation and publication—had not been adjudicated on their merits.
pp. 16–18In those circumstances, the purchaser could not compel completion of the sale. Nor could redemption be fixed at ₹5.30 crore solely because that was the auction bid, particularly given the later valuation and the bank’s outstanding dues. Since no fresh sale notice had been issued, however, the guarantor could make an offer before its issuance, for the bank to consider in light of a fresh valuation.
pp. 19–2105Holding
The Court dismissed both revision petitions and declined to interfere with the DRAT’s orders.
p. 21It directed the bank to obtain a fresh valuation and then proceed with a fresh sale notice; before that notice is issued, the bank may consider the guarantor’s offer in accordance with the fresh valuation. Any demand drafts sent by the auction purchaser and still held by the bank were to be returned forthwith.
p. 21Original Court PDF
A.T.HEERA BANUvsPUNJAB NATIONAL BANK
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
