01Facts
The petitioners, sixty-six individuals, filed a writ petition under Article 226 seeking a mandamus directing the respondents (the Secretaries to Government, Finance, Water Resources and Public Works Departments, and the Engineers-in-Chief/Chief Engineers) to compute their entire temporary service as qualifying service for pension.
p. 11The claim rested on an earlier order of the Court in W.P. No. 29285 of 2007 dated 19.02.2009.
p. 11 · p. 12The petitioners were represented by Mr. M. Muthappan and the State by the Additional Government Pleader, Mr. K.K. Ram Siddhartha.
p. 11The order does not record the petitioners' service particulars or the factual disputes, if any.
02Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioners are entitled to a mandamus directing computation of their entire temporary service as qualifying service for pension, in terms of the order in W.P. No. 29285 of 2007 dated 19.02.2009.
p. 12ii.2. Whether, in view of the Full Bench decision in *Government of Tamil Nadu v. R. Kaliyamoorthy*, any issue survives for adjudication in the present writ petition.
p. 1203Law Applied
The Court's sole stated basis for disposal was the Full Bench decision of the Madras High Court in *The Government of Tamil Nadu v. R. Kaliyamoorthy*, 2019 (6) CTC 705, rendered in W.A. Nos. 158 of 2016 etc. batch, which the Court treated as settling the question of counting temporary service for qualifying service for pension.
p. 12The order also refers to the earlier single-judge order in W.P. No. 29285 of 2007 dated 19.02.2009, which the petitioners relied upon as the source of their entitlement. The order does not reproduce the reasoning or ratio of either decision, nor does it cite any statutory provision governing qualifying service under the pension rules.
p. 12 · no citationWhere a binding Full Bench decision governs the question, a writ petition seeking the same relief raises no surviving issue.
p. 1204Reasoning
The Court held that the relief sought, computation of temporary service for pension under the 2009 order, was already covered by the Full Bench ruling in *Kaliyamoorthy*. Because the prayer was framed in terms of that earlier order and the Full Bench decision was treated as having resolved the controlling question, the Court found that "nothing survives for further consideration."
p. 12The Court did not examine the merits of the petitioners' entitlement, the scope of the 2009 order, or any distinguishing facts for the sixty-six petitioners. The disposal is thus procedural in effect: the petition was dismissed as infructuous in light of binding precedent rather than on a reasoned determination of the claim.
05Holding
The Court answered both issues against the petitioners, holding that no relief survives in view of the Full Bench decision in *Kaliyamoorthy*.
p. 12The writ petition was dismissed without costs, and the connected miscellaneous petitions (WMP Nos. 28924 and 28925 of 2022) were closed. No fresh direction to the respondents was issued.
¶ 2 · p. 13Original Court PDF
I.LazarusvsThe Secretary to Government
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
