01Facts
Seven petitioners challenge the order of the 1st respondent, the Commissioner of Treasuries and Accounts, in Kaa.Mu.182/2024/No.1 dated 06-02-2025 (signed 06-02-2025), and the consequential final inter-se seniority list dated 07-02-2025.
p. 5The petitioners seek quashing of both the order dated 06-02-2025 and the seniority list dated 07-02-2025, and a direction to place them above Sl. Nos. 117, 120, 136, 119, 118, 127 and 130 in the seniority list.
p. 5The petitioners also seek promotion to the post of Sub-Treasury Officer/Superintendent.
p. 5R1 to R3 are the Commissioner and two Treasury Officers; R4 is the Chairman, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission.
p. 2R6 to R39 were impleaded by order dated 06-03-2025 in WMP(MD) No. 4430 of 2025.
p. 3 · p. 1R5 appeared in person, representing himself and other similarly placed persons in the impugned list.
p. 6Notice was published in newspapers on 18-03-2025.
p. 6The reference copy contains no pleadings, counter-affidavit averments, or factual findings beyond the above.
02Issues
i.1. Whether the Commissioner's order dated 06-02-2025 and the seniority list dated 07-02-2025 are sustainable, such that the petitioners are entitled to re-ranking above Sl. Nos. 117, 118, 119, 120, 127, 130 and 136.
p. 5ii.2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to promotion to Sub-Treasury Officer/Superintendent under Rule 9 of the Tamil Nadu Treasuries and Accounts Subordinate Services Special Rules and Rule 40(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016.
p. 503Law Applied
Rule 9 of the Tamil Nadu Treasuries and Accounts Subordinate Services Special Rules, which the petitioners invoke for promotion to Sub-Treasury Officer/Superintendent.
p. 5Rule 40(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, which the petitioners invoke for promotion to Sub-Treasury Officer/Superintendent.
p. 504Reasoning
The reference text contains no reasoning. The order consists of the caption, the prayer, appearances, and the addressee list for issuing notice, ending at the page reflecting the court's order and the names of the parties to whom the order is directed.
pp. 7–9The court's application of Rule 9, Rule 40(2), or any seniority principle to the petitioners' ranking cannot be determined from this text.
The addressee list, which includes R6 to R39 and a second copy for R1, suggests that the text may be a notice-issuing order or may be incomplete.
p. 805Holding
The reference text does not contain the court's answer to any issue, a final holding, or any direction or relief granted. The operative portion of the order is absent.
Before relying on this matter, the complete certified order must be obtained to confirm whether the court granted interim relief, issued notice only, or decided the writ petition on the merits. The order date of 18-11-2026 falls well after the impugned orders of February 2025 and the 2025 filing and impleadment dates and should be verified against the certified copy.
Original Court PDF
K.KamalamvsThe Commissioner of Treasuries and Accounts
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
