01Facts
The petitioner, a Supervisor (In-charge) at the Block Resource Centre, Koliyanur Block, Villupuram District, obtained an M.Phil. through distance education from Vinayaga Mission University (Respondent 7) in June 2009.
p. 2The Department was paid a second incentive on 18.01.2013 for this qualification.
p. 1By proceedings dated 27.08.2018, the Chief Educational Officer (Respondent 5), acting on an audit objection, ordered recovery of the incentive on the ground that the university was unrecognised.
p. 1 · ¶ 1The petitioner paid ₹1,87,743 on 05.09.2018 under the impugned notice.
p. 5 · ¶ 7The petitioner contended that the university held valid recognition during the relevant period and that the issue was settled by the Division Bench in S. Sivan v. Regional Accounts Officer (W.A. No. 2328 of 2018 and batch, dated 04.08.2023).
p. 2 · ¶ 2The Government Pleader did not seriously dispute this position but argued that the writ petition was filed after an inordinate delay of more than six years.
p. 3 · ¶ 302Issues
i.1. Whether the recovery of the second incentive, based on the alleged non-recognition of Vinayaga Mission University, is sustainable where the petitioner obtained the M.Phil. in 2009, during a period when the university held recognition.
p. 1 · ¶ 1 · p. 5 · ¶ 5–6ii.2. Whether the petitioner's delay of more than six years in approaching the court bars relief under Article 226.
p. 3 · ¶ 3–403Law Applied
The Court relied on Article 226 of the Constitution as the basis for the writ jurisdiction.
p. 1Its principal authority was the Division Bench decision in S. Sivan, which held that the recognition position of Vinayaga Mission University was institution-wise from 2007 to 2012 and programme-wise from 2011–2014.
p. 4 · ¶ 5, quoting paras. 23–24The Division Bench held that teachers who joined in 2007 or 2008 and completed the one-year course in 2008 or 2009, when the university held DEC/IGNOU approval, had acquired a valid qualification. Audit objections on this ground could not be sustained, and incentives already granted should not be disturbed.
pp. 4–5 · ¶ 5, quoting paras. 25, 35Where incentives had been stopped, they were to be restored with arrears.
p. 5 · ¶ 5, quoting para. 35The Court also relied on the general principle that a settled legal position applies to similarly situated persons, a point it treated as not seriously disputed.
pp. 2–3 · ¶ 204Reasoning
The Court first identified the sole basis of the impugned recovery order as the alleged absence of recognition of the university.
p. 3 · ¶ 5It found that the S. Sivan ruling dealt with this issue in detail and was directly applicable.
pp. 3–4 · ¶ 5Because the petitioner obtained the M.Phil. in June 2009, while the university held valid recognition, his case fell within the class of degrees the Division Bench had upheld.
p. 5 · ¶ 6On delay, the Court did not treat the six-year gap as a bar. It addressed the merits, noting that the legal position was settled and that the Government Pleader had not disputed it.
p. 3 · ¶ 3–4, 6On the refund, the Court accepted the petitioner's uncontested claim of payment of ₹1,87,743 and directed verification and refund rather than deciding the factual payment dispute itself.
pp. 5–6 · ¶ 705Holding
The recovery of the second incentive is unsustainable because the petitioner's M.Phil. was obtained in 2009, when Vinayaga Mission University held valid recognition, bringing it within the protection of S. Sivan. The Court held that the audit objection could not stand and that the recovery order was liable to be interfered with.
p. 5 · ¶ 6The impugned proceedings dated 27.08.2018 are set aside. The respondents are directed to verify the petitioner's payment of ₹1,87,743 made on 05.09.2018 and refund that amount within eight weeks of receipt of the order. The writ petition is allowed as prayed for, without costs. Although the prayer sought a direction to continue paying the second incentive, the operative paragraphs address only the setting aside of the recovery and the refund. The order does not expressly direct continued payment of the incentive or the restoration of arrears.
pp. 5–6 · ¶ 6–8Original Court PDF
D.CHANDIRA SEKARvsTHE PRICIPAL SECRETARY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
