Madras High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceConstitutional Law

Madras HC Refuses CBCID Probe In 2015 Murder Case, Says Victim's Wife Must Protest Police Report In Trial Court

B.Radhikav.The State Rep by The Director General of Police

Madras HC Refuses CBCID Probe In 2015 Murder Case, Says Victim's Wife Must Protest Police Report In Trial Court. B.Radhika vs The State Rep by The Director General of Police. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the High Court, in writ jurisdiction under Article 226, can entertain a relief in the nature of a protest petition against the police supplementary report filed under s.173(8) CrPC

The court held

The High Court held that Article 226 cannot be invoked as a form of protest petition against a s.173(8) supplementary report, and that the petitioner must approach the jurisdictional Court

It also directed

The writ petition was dismissed, with liberty granted to the petitioner to seek the relief before the competent trial court, and the connected W.P.M.P. was closed

The order was directed to be communicated to the District Judge, Thirupathur, the III Additional Sessions Judge, the DGP, the SP, the Inspector of Police, and the Public Prosecutor

01Facts

The petitioner is the wife of Babu, who was murdered on 31.08.2015.

¶ 2 / p.2

She alleges that an auto driver, who carried the deceased from Kalandara Village to Vaniyambadi, was an eyewitness

¶ 2 / p.2

The police investigated and filed a positive final report. Cognizance was taken and the case was committed to the Sessions Court, where it is pending as S.C. No. 39 of 2018 before the District Judge, Thirupathur

¶ 3 / p.2

The petitioner alleges that, despite an order in Crl.M.P. No. 295 of 2022 dated 19.06.2023 by the III Additional District and Sessions Judge, the police have not identified the auto driver, and she seeks transfer of the investigation in Crime No. 224 of 2025 to CBCID

¶ 4–5 / p.3

The Government Advocate reported that the trial court has fixed a schedule for trial

¶ 6 / p.3

Under a petition under s.173(8) CrPC, the police earlier reported that they could not trace the auto driver. The District Judge's report dated 12.11.2026 shows that the s.173(8) petition was allowed and the police filed a first supplementary report on 09.01.2024, copies of which were furnished to the accused

¶ 7 / p.6

The petitioner's relief is, in substance, a protest petition against that supplementary report

¶ 8 / p.6

02Issues

i.1. Whether the High Court, in writ jurisdiction under Article 226, can entertain a relief in the nature of a protest petition against the police supplementary report filed under s.173(8) CrPC

¶ 8 / p.6

ii.2. Whether a writ of mandamus can be issued to transfer the investigation to CBCID when the matter is pending before the jurisdictional Sessions Court and the trial court has taken up the case

¶ 5–8 / pp.3, 6

03Law Applied

The court relied on Section 173(8) CrPC, which permits further investigation after a final report and the filing of a further report before the Magistrate/Court, as the procedural basis for the supplementary report dated 09.01.2024

¶ 7 / p.6

The court relied on the settled principle that Article 226 is an extraordinary remedy that cannot be invoked as a substitute for a protest or objection before the jurisdictional court, which is the forum competent to examine the police report and any objections to it

¶ 8 / p.6

The judgment cites no precedent

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 173

04Reasoning

The court first examined the record, including the District Judge's report, and found that the s.173(8) petition had been allowed and the supplementary report already filed and furnished to the accused

¶ 7 / p.6

This resolved the factual dispute over whether the police could trace the auto driver, which the petitioner's counsel disputed

¶ 7 / p.6

The court then held that the petitioner's real grievance was a challenge to the supplementary report. That is a matter for the jurisdictional Court, not for the writ court under Article 226

¶ 8 / p.6

Because the trial is pending and the trial court has fixed a schedule for it, the writ court declined to direct a transfer of investigation to CBCID, which would have bypassed the trial court's supervision

¶ 6, 8 / pp.3, 6

The court therefore treated the writ as an improper substitute for a protest petition

¶ 8 / p.6

05Holding

The High Court held that Article 226 cannot be invoked as a form of protest petition against a s.173(8) supplementary report, and that the petitioner must approach the jurisdictional Court

¶ 8 / p.6

The writ petition was dismissed, with liberty granted to the petitioner to seek the relief before the competent trial court, and the connected W.P.M.P. was closed

¶ 8 / p.6

The order was directed to be communicated to the District Judge, Thirupathur, the III Additional Sessions Judge, the DGP, the SP, the Inspector of Police, and the Public Prosecutor

p. 7
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

B.RadhikavsThe State Rep by The Director General of Police

Madras High Court · November 13, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment