01Facts
The appellant-plaintiff, a manning agency, entered a manning agency agreement with the second defendant (Star Voyages Shipping Services LLC) effective 10 June 2023.
¶ 7Under the agreement, the second defendant was to pay crew wages, and the plaintiff was to pay them and seek reimbursement if the second defendant defaulted.
¶ 7The plaintiff paid June 2023 wages for crew of three vessels operated by the second defendant (MT Eastern Pearl, MT Fast Kathy, MT Sea Fidelity) and was not reimbursed.
¶ 7The second defendant allegedly transferred its vessels to the third defendant after sanctions.
¶ 7The plaintiff claimed the amounts as maritime claims under Section 4(1)(o), (p) and (w) of the Admiralty Act, 2017.
¶ 7On 31 May 2024 the learned Single Judge ordered ex parte arrest of the first defendant vessel, MT Ocean Faye, which was released on security furnished on 6 June 2024.
¶ 8Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 filed I.A. No. 1 of 2025 seeking vacation of the arrest, refund of security, and dismissal of the suit.
¶ 2, 8The learned Single Judge allowed the application, holding that a sister vessel requires common ownership, that common management by a ship manager is insufficient, and that a wage lien must relate to the vessel where employment arose.
¶ 4The plaintiff appealed, and its counsel conceded that the claim is not founded on a maritime lien and that there is no privity of contract or commonality of interest with the first defendant.
¶ 6, 9, 1002Issues
i.1. Whether a claim under Section 4(1)(o) and (p) of the Admiralty Act, 2017 lies against the first defendant vessel where the crew wages and disbursements relate to three other vessels operated by the second defendant, which was the first defendant's manager.
¶ 9, 17–21ii.2. Whether the first defendant vessel can be arrested as a "securing vessel" under Section 5(2) read with Section 5(1)(b) of the Admiralty Act, 2017, in the absence of a demise charter or common ownership.
¶ 11, 27–28, 32iii.3. Whether a manning agent, having a contract with a ship manager, can invoke admiralty jurisdiction to arrest an unrelated vessel.
¶ 28, 31iv.4. Whether the suit could be dismissed on a preliminary jurisdictional issue under Order XIV Rule 2 CPC.
¶ 12, 1603Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 4(1)(o) and (p) of the Admiralty Act, 2017, under which crew wage claims and disbursements must relate to the vessel on which the crew were employed or on whose behalf the disbursements were made.
¶ 17, 21The Court applied Section 5 of the Act, which permits arrest only where the claim is secured by a maritime lien under Section 9, or where the Section 5(1)(b) conditions of a demise charterer or owner are satisfied, and Section 5(2), which permits arrest of "any other vessel" only subject to Section 5(1).
¶ 19, 23, 28The Court followed Owners and Parties Interested in M.V. Nereus Progress v. Om Freight Forwarders Ltd. (2026 SCC OnLine SC 2007), which held that Section 5(2) is not a standalone source of arrest and that the Section 5(1)(b) conditions must be independently met for the securing vessel.
¶ 15, 28The Court applied Sunil B. Naik v. Geowave Commander (2018) 5 SCC 505, which distinguishes beneficial ownership from charter status and holds that a non-owner's vessel cannot be arrested for another's maritime claim, and referred to the bareboat charter principles discussed there.
¶ 13, 24, 26–27The Court applied the principle that a manning agent is not comparable to a demise charterer.
¶ 31The Court held that Section 5(2) requires prima facie commonality of interest and an intention to defraud, or lifting of the corporate veil.
¶ 3204Reasoning
The Court first held that the claims concern three vessels that are not the first defendant, that no averment shows commonality of interest between their owners and the first defendant, and that those owners were not impleaded, and treated this as a fatal defect.
¶ 22Applying Section 4(1)(o) and (p), the Court held that neither the crew agreement nor the disbursements related to the first defendant vessel, so no maritime claim arose under those clauses, and the plaint did not establish one.
¶ 21, 23The manning agency agreement was not a demise or bareboat charter, so the plaintiff could not show that the first defendant was a demise charterer or owner under Section 5(1)(b).
¶ 30–31The Court distinguished the authorities relied on by the appellant, all of which concerned demise or bareboat charters.
¶ 31Because the wage claim was not secured by a maritime lien, and the concession on that point was accepted, Section 5(1)(e) (referred to as "Section 5(e)" in the judgment) was not attracted.
¶ 18, 23The Court further held that a securing-vessel arrest under Section 5(2) needs prima facie commonality of interest and an intent to defraud, or veil-lifting, and none was established.
¶ 32The judgment does not expressly address Siem Offshore Drilling AS v. Altus Uber (2018 SCC OnLine Bom 2730), which the appellant relied on for the securing-vessel distinction. The Court relied instead on Nereus Progress and Sunil B. Naik.
¶ 11, 24–26, 28The Court found the Single Judge's approach justified and did not separately decide the Order XIV Rule 2 argument.
¶ 12, 1605Holding
The Court held that the first defendant vessel cannot be arrested under Sections 4(1)(o), 4(1)(p), 5(1)(b) or 5(2) of the Admiralty Act, 2017, because no maritime claim arises against it, no demise charter or ownership relationship is shown, and the manning agent's contract does not meet the statutory test.
¶ 21–23, 28, 31The Court did not decide the Order XIV Rule 2 CPC submission.
¶ 12The appeal is dismissed.
¶ 32The Court affirmed the Single Judge's order allowing I.A. No. 1 of 2025, which vacated the arrest and treated the admiralty jurisdiction as wrongly invoked against the first defendant.
¶ 4, 32Original Court PDF
LIGHT HOUSE MARINE SERVICE INDIA PVT. LTD.vsCHARTERER AND PARTIES INTERESTED IN THE VESSEL MT OCEAN FAYE, IMO NO: 9321689
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
