CAT - ['Delhi']Administrative and Public LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Non-filing of reply to a general notice is not civil contempt absent a specific direction to file and wilful disobedience.

sanjiv Chaturvediv.SH. R K SUDHANSU, IAS, PRINCIPAL SECRETARY FOREST GOVERNMENT OF UTTARAKHAND

Non-filing of reply to a general notice is not civil contempt absent a specific direction to file and wilful disobedience.. sanjiv Chaturvedi vs SH. R K SUDHANSU, IAS, PRINCIPAL SECRETARY FOREST  GOVERNMENT OF UTTARAKHAND. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the filing of a common counter affidavit by an officer other than Respondent No. 3, and the absence of a personal reply by Respondent No. 3, constitute wilful disobedience of the Tribunal's order dated 17.06.2026 under Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.

The court held

The Tribunal held that non-filing of a personal reply by Respondent No. 3, in the absence of a specific direction to him, does not constitute wilful disobedience of the order dated 17.06.2026 and therefore does not amount to civil contempt under Section 2(b).

It also directed

Pratibha Kashyap is inapplicable because it involved a specific direction that was disobeyed.

The authorities on non-traversal concern the merits of the O.A. and do not establish contempt.

The Tribunal found no contempt, declined to issue notice, and dismissed the Contempt Petition with no costs.

The non-filing of a reply remains a matter for the O.A., where the allegations may be treated as admitted.

01Facts

The applicant, an IFS officer, challenged the downgrading of his APAR grading for 01.05.2024 to 31.03.2025 from 9.74 (recorded by the Reporting and Reviewing Authorities) to 9.30 by the Accepting Authority, the Principal Secretary (Forest).

¶ 1

He alleged malice, linking the downgrading to two disciplinary references against a junior officer that were allegedly kept pending, followed by that officer's promotion.

¶ 1

On 17.06.2026, the Tribunal issued notice in the O.A., directing the respondents to file counter replies within six weeks.

¶ 2

The applicant alleged that Respondent No. 3, who was impleaded in his personal capacity and against whom personal mala fides were alleged, filed no personal affidavit.

¶ 3-4

Instead, a common counter affidavit for Respondents 1-3 was sworn by Shri Himanshu Khurana, Additional Secretary, Forest Department.

¶ 4

On 21.09.2026, the Tribunal recorded that no reply on behalf of the contemnors was on record, found no prima facie wilful defiance, and listed the matter before a Bench after one Member recused.

¶ 5

At the hearing, the applicant argued that the affidavit was filed late, was defectively verified, and was not personally sworn by Respondent No. 3, and that non-filing amounted to contempt.

¶ 6-7

He relied on Pratibha Kashyap v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1105.

¶ 7

He relied on S. Pratap Singh v. State of Punjab (1964) 4 SCR 733, R.P. Kapur v. Sardar Pratap Singh Kairon (1960 SCC OnLine SC 122), and C.S. Rowjee v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1964 SCC OnLine SC 71) for the proposition that unrebutted allegations of personal bias must be accepted.

¶ 8-10

The counter affidavit's paragraph 11 defended the 9.30 grading as within the Accepting Authority's powers under the AIS (PAR) Rules, 2007.

¶ 11

02Issues

i.1. Whether the filing of a common counter affidavit by an officer other than Respondent No. 3, and the absence of a personal reply by Respondent No. 3, constitute wilful disobedience of the Tribunal's order dated 17.06.2026 under Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.

¶ 4, 15-19, 22

ii.2. Whether Pratibha Kashyap applies to the present facts, given the alleged delegation of the filing of an explanation.

¶ 7, 20-22

iii.3. Whether the non-traversal of allegations, relied upon through S. Pratap Singh, R.P. Kapur and C.S. Rowjee, can be treated as contempt.

¶ 8-10, 23

03Law Applied

The Tribunal relied on Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, which defines civil contempt as wilful disobedience to any judgment, decree, direction, or order of a court.

¶ 18

Under this definition, contempt requires wilful disobedience of a specific direction, so an order that merely calls for a reply is not disobeyed by non-filing.

¶ 17, 19

The Tribunal held that non-filing of a reply is contempt only where a specific direction is issued to a named person or officer to file an affidavit, and that the consequence of not filing is the forfeiture of the right to rebut allegations.

¶ 19

The Tribunal distinguished Pratibha Kashyap, in which the Supreme Court had specifically directed the impleaded Director to submit an explanation personally, and held that delegating that explanation to a subordinate was contempt.

¶ 20-21

The Tribunal also relied on the principle, drawn from S. Pratap Singh, R.P. Kapur and C.S. Rowjee, that unrebutted allegations of bias or malice may be accepted in the main proceedings, so that non-filing results in admission of the allegations for merits purposes.

¶ 8-10, 23

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 Section 12Section 2

04Reasoning

The Tribunal held that the 17.06.2026 order was a standard notice calling upon all respondents to file replies, and contained no specific direction to Respondent No. 3 to file a personal affidavit.

¶ 17, 22

Because the order was not specific, the absence of a personal affidavit could not be wilful disobedience, and the Tribunal held that non-filing "cannot be termed as disobedience, much less willful disobedience." The Tribunal further reasoned that accepting the applicant's submission would require contempt proceedings in every case where a reply is not filed, which would be untenable.

¶ 22

On Pratibha Kashyap, the Tribunal noted that the Supreme Court had issued a specific direction to the Director to explain his conduct personally, and that the explanation was filed by an authorized subordinate in violation of that direction. Here, no equivalent direction existed, so the authority was distinguishable.

¶ 20-21

On the non-traversal authorities, the Tribunal observed that they concern the evidentiary consequence of unrebutted allegations on the merits of the O.A., not contempt. Consequently, the appropriate remedy is for the Tribunal to consider the absence of a reply in deciding the O.A., not to initiate contempt.

¶ 23

The Tribunal did not adjudicate the applicant's points on the timeliness and verification of the common affidavit, or the merits of paragraph 11 of the counter affidavit; those issues are left for the O.A.

¶ 7, 11, 22-23

05Holding

The Tribunal held that non-filing of a personal reply by Respondent No. 3, in the absence of a specific direction to him, does not constitute wilful disobedience of the order dated 17.06.2026 and therefore does not amount to civil contempt under Section 2(b).

¶ 19, 22

Pratibha Kashyap is inapplicable because it involved a specific direction that was disobeyed.

¶ 20-21

The authorities on non-traversal concern the merits of the O.A. and do not establish contempt.

¶ 23

The Tribunal found no contempt, declined to issue notice, and dismissed the Contempt Petition with no costs.

¶ 24

The non-filing of a reply remains a matter for the O.A., where the allegations may be treated as admitted.

¶ 23
CAT - ['Delhi']

Original Court PDF

sanjiv ChaturvedivsSH. R K SUDHANSU, IAS, PRINCIPAL SECRETARY FOREST GOVERNMENT OF UTTARAKHAND

CAT - ['Delhi'] · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment